Who would you pick?

[prowling panther]

If you were the recuiting manager of your club, who would be the 5 players from the other SANFL clubs would you want in your team next year?

(Taking into account that all players were available and not contracted)

[Aerie]

J Clayton, AhChee, Alleway, J Allan, Schell.

[Big Phil]

You stole my thunder subpol, I was going to post a similar thread to this mate...

Anyway, I'll have a shot at it for each for each club (including my own club, from the perspective of being a neutral supporter)

CENTRALS:
Paul Thomas
Daniel Schell
Ian Callinan
Daniel Havelberg
Andrew Hayes

EAGLES:
Mark McKenzie
Leigh Treeby
Mark Passador
Ben Schwarze
Luke Powell

GLENELG:
Brett Backwell
Trevor Cranston
Todd Grima
Ben Mules
Chris Kane

NORTH ADELAIDE
Clint Alleway
James Allan
Heath Younie
Trent Sporn
Tim Delvins

NORWOOD:
Brett Zorzi
Nick Duigan
Paul Pupolo
James Gallagher
Jamie Vlatko

PORT ADELAIDE:
Jeremy Clayton
Luke Saunders
James Mieklejohn
Corey AhChee
Josh Thurgood

SOUTH ADELAIDE:
Ben Warren
Craig Parry
James Boyd
Tarek Redigolo
Jason Torney

STURT:
Brant Chambers
Luke Crane
Jade Sheedy
Tristian Gum
Ian Perrie

WEST ADELAIDE:
Nathan Brown
Ryan Ferguson
Damien Cupido
Simon Munn
Salim Hassan

[MagareyLegend]

WEST ADELAIDE:
NIL RETURN

[firstblood]

WEST ADELAIDE:
NIL RETURN

MagareyLegend.....you are a twit...and you are consistently bagging Westies. Ryan Ferguson has proved to be one of the best defenders in the SANFL along with Cupido. Most supporters wouldn't mind those two in their side.

[Punk Rooster]

You stole my thunder subpol, I was going to post a similar thread to this mate...

Anyway, I'll have a shot at it for each for each club (including my own club, from the perspective of being a neutral supporter)

NORTH ADELAIDE
Clint Alleway
James Allan
Heath Younie
Trent Sporn
Tim Delvins

Depending on what your policy was, Heath Younie would be too old to recruit.
He's been a great player for North- one of the smartest blokes we've got.
I have a lot of respect for Heath as a player & a leader at North.

[doggies4eva]

Chambers
Passadore
Clayton
Grima
and whoever is the best ruckman going around.

[ElizabethVCRThief]

WEST ADELAIDE:
NIL RETURN

MagareyLegend.....you are a twit...and you are consistently bagging Westies. Ryan Ferguson has proved to be one of the best defenders in the SANFL along with Cupido. Most supporters wouldn't mind those two in their side.

I wouldn't have thought there'd be too many who'd pick Cupido.

[Ian]

Hargraves
Gum
Perrie
Cubillo
McEntee

[wycbloods]

WEST ADELAIDE:
NIL RETURN

MagareyLegend.....you are a twit...and you are consistently bagging Westies. Ryan Ferguson has proved to be one of the best defenders in the SANFL along with Cupido. Most supporters wouldn't mind those two in their side.

I wouldn't have thought there'd be too many who'd pick Cupido.

Yes the ones who have not seen him play at all in defence this year wouldn't pick him. The ones who have seen him i think wouldn't hesitate in picking him as a running defender.

[am Bays]

Yes the ones who have not seen him play at all in defence this year wouldn't pick him. The ones who have seen him i think wouldn't hesitate in picking him as a running defender.

yes some of us have seen him and no we don't want him....

Unless he would be prepared to play for base payments, not the coin he has been on a South and now is on at West....

[wycbloods]

Yes the ones who have not seen him play at all in defence this year wouldn't pick him. The ones who have seen him i think wouldn't hesitate in picking him as a running defender.

yes some of us have seen him and no we don't want him....

Unless he would be prepared to play for base payments, not the coin he has been on a South and now is on at West....

I didn't think that payments were part of the criteria. That would rule out not only Cupido but a few others that have been mentioned.

[TigerBoss]

You stole my thunder subpol, I was going to post a similar thread to this mate...

Anyway, I'll have a shot at it for each for each club (including my own club, from the perspective of being a neutral supporter)

NORTH ADELAIDE
Clint Alleway
James Allan
Heath Younie
Trent Sporn
Tim Delvins

Depending on what your policy was, Heath Younie would be too old to recruit.
He's been a great player for North- one of the smartest blokes we've got.
I have a lot of respect for Heath as a player & a leader at North.

So, as a North supporter, you would pick a player that is already at North?

[ElizabethVCRThief]

WEST ADELAIDE:
NIL RETURN

MagareyLegend.....you are a twit...and you are consistently bagging Westies. Ryan Ferguson has proved to be one of the best defenders in the SANFL along with Cupido. Most supporters wouldn't mind those two in their side.

I wouldn't have thought there'd be too many who'd pick Cupido.

Yes the ones who have not seen him play at all in defence this year wouldn't pick him. The ones who have seen him i think wouldn't hesitate in picking him as a running defender.

I've seen him abuse team-mates, look lazy and play selfish football. If that's the kind of bloke you want at your club good luck to you.

[Sojourner]

Considering that the number of current AFL players that are ex West Adelaide, people could also look into taking 5 of their u/17 players who seem to be playing well at present!

[TigerBoss]

I'd like to say we'd take Chambers, but having him in the forward line could actually be detrimental to our other forwards and the chemistry that Duldig, Grima, Kirkby, McConnell, Bode and co have established this season...

I'm a big fan of the real in and under gutsy types, so to complement Mouse, Allen, Kane and Fisher, I'd have to go with a player like James Gallagher, or Jimmy Allan or Jeremy Clayton.

Daniel Schell would be an excellent compliment to Sherwood, Rudolph and Panozzo down back for us, and having a back-up ruckman for Trevor Cranston would be ideal, so I'd probably take someone like Craig Parry.

[wycbloods]

MagareyLegend.....you are a twit...and you are consistently bagging Westies. Ryan Ferguson has proved to be one of the best defenders in the SANFL along with Cupido. Most supporters wouldn't mind those two in their side.[/quote]

Yes the ones who have not seen him play at all in defence this year wouldn't pick him. The ones who have seen him i think wouldn't hesitate in picking him as a running defender.[/quote]

I've seen him abuse team-mates, look lazy and play selfish football. If that's the kind of bloke you want at your club good luck to you.[/quote][/quote]

I see a lot more of Cupido than you do and he is far from a selfish footballer. He is no doubt a very lazy forward but that is why i said i would pick him as a running defender where he plays his best football. As for abusing team mates what a load of rubbish you see him in the change rooms and at the quarter time breaks and he is very encouraging of all his team mates.

[HeartBeatsTrue]

Chambers
Callinan
Parry
Backwell
AhChee

[PatowalongaPirate]

I'm sure you meant Ben Kane Big Phil....

[JK]

Alleway
Crane
Callinan
Rudolph
P.Thomas