PAFC 2025

[wenchbarwer]

Geelong gave up 13,15 and 20 for Jeremy Cameron, he's the only player I can think of in recent memory that you could compare to with the talent on offer.

So it's 3 x 1st rounders or 2 x + the player you have that we want.

Edit - Cameron had played 171 games at GWS, Butters has played 126

As good as Butters is, and I really rate him, I'm always taking a gun KPF over a gun midfielder

[Lightning McQueen]

Geelong gave up 13,15 and 20 for Jeremy Cameron, he's the only player I can think of in recent memory that you could compare to with the talent on offer.

So it's 3 x 1st rounders or 2 x + the player you have that we want.

Edit - Cameron had played 171 games at GWS, Butters has played 126

Cameron is the 2nd most valuable player in the league, incredibly hard to match up on and can turn a game on it's head in a ten minute burst.

Butters on the other hand is an absolute jet, if he ended up at the Dogs it would be very dangerous, could be why they are trying to shift the JUH $$$'s.

[Jim05]

So
Bergman to Hawks for Pick 8
Butters to Essendon for Picks 5, 9, 24 (they also have 27)

Bombers won’t be going for Butters.
If they do go for anyone it will be Reid.
I’d rather we hit the draft though

[daysofourlives]

So
Bergman to Hawks for Pick 8
Butters to Essendon for Picks 5, 9, 24 (they also have 27)

Bombers won’t be going for Butters.
If they do go for anyone it will be Reid.
I’d rather we hit the draft though

Ive heard Reid is a done deal to the Bombers

[daysofourlives]

Privately Carr must be thinking this is the best result for him, there will need to be some patience which is what he needs. Lets say they finished top 4 this year there would have been huge pressure on him to make the next step, now he will get time, and some better draft picks

Not a first rounder though

If Butters and Bergman go you should get 3 first rounders back. All depends on which clubs the players want to go to
Essendon - 5, 9
Hawks - 8
Richmond - 2, 3
Saints - 6 + Nasiah
Bulldogs - 14
Geelong - 12

Will be Dogs, Cats or Hawks..............in that order IMO.

I was hopeful we would be a chance to get Butters but those hopes were dashed, actually they were absolutely smashed by Sam Maclure last night when he declared Butters was going to Hawthorn

[locky801]

When was the last time Sam Maclure got something right

[daysofourlives]

When was the last time Sam Maclure got something right

Thats what i was saying

[shoe boy]

Another train wreck of an interview with Koshi on 5aa!

[Dutchy]

Koch on 5AA spin -

We have a plan
Blame injuries
The future has been identified
Blame injuries
Ken and Josh have a great relationship
Blame injuries
Brisbane were in a similar position last year
Blame injuries
Footy can be a funny game
Blame injuries

[MW]

Koch on 5AA spin -

We have a plan
Blame injuries
The future has been identified
Blame injuries
Ken and Josh have a great relationship
Blame injuries
Brisbane were in a similar position last year
Blame injuries
Footy can be a funny game
Blame injuries

No "blame media", "blame other teams players", "blame public"?

[Armchair expert]

I think Kochie should stick to the business side and not comment about on field issues.

[mots02]

Koch on 5AA spin -

We have a plan
Blame injuries
The future has been identified
Blame injuries
Ken and Josh have a great relationship
Blame injuries
Brisbane were in a similar position last year
Blame injuries
Footy can be a funny game
Blame injuries

Sounds like an interview from the Make Alberton Great Again crew

[mots02]

Thrown the whole farm at Butters, 7 year contract offer to Bergman……………. Whiff of panic or warchest territory?

[MW]

Thrown the whole farm at Butters, 7 year contract offer to Bergman……………. Whiff of panic or warchest territory?

They know they cannot lose those two otherwise its a full rebuild.
All other 17 clubs in their situation would be offering the same deals.

[Booney]

Thrown the whole farm at Butters, 7 year contract offer to Bergman……………. Whiff of panic or warchest territory?

Huh? Do you take any notice of the contracts players get offered nowadays or what?

[amber_fluid]

Thrown the whole farm at Butters, 7 year contract offer to Bergman……………. Whiff of panic or warchest territory?

Contracts mean nothing these days though

[Brodlach]

Esava out this with hamstring awareness

[mots02]

Esava out this with hamstring awareness

With the amount of talk on hamstrings this week I’m not surprised he’s become aware

[Booney]

Horne-Francis, Farrell, Lukosius, Jones, Marshall, Sinn and Ratugolea out of those in the mix for the best 22.

[whufc]

Horne-Francis, Farrell, Lukosius, Jones, Marshall, Sinn and Ratugolea out of those in the mix for the best 22.

Just looking at the AFL website now....compare that to other clubs who we would generally agree would be in their best 21..

Adelaide- 2
Brisbane - 4
Carlton- 9-11
Collingwood- 5-6
Essendon- 4
Fremantle- 6-7
Geelong- 4
Gold Coast- 4-6
GWS- 5
Hawthorn- 3
Melbourne- 2
North Melbourne- 3-4
Richmond- 4-5
St Kilda- 6
Sydney- 7-9
West Coast- 6-8