GSFL Movements

[A Mum]

From the GSFL website.....

The Commissioners met on Tuesday 11/08/09 to hear charges against 4 players - the following decisions were made;

-McLaren Senior Colt Angus Lovell pleaded not guilty to headbutting in the match against Victor Harbor he found found guilty and given a one match penalty.
-Victor Harbor Reserves Player Anthony Davenport was reported for headbutting and oponent from Willunga in the Reserves match on 18/07/09 he pleaded guilty and given an eight match penalty.
-Myponga A Grade player Reagan Scanlon was reported for striking in the match against Yankakilla he pleaded guilty and was given a three match suspension.
-Willunga A Grade player Nathan Genovese was reported for striking in the match against Strathalbyn and given a five match suspension

[petoe]

Does 5 matches put him out of contention to play in the grand final, If willunga (which should) make the GF.? How many gamers left?

[A Mum]

There are 6 weekends left of football in the GSFL.
So if Willunga do make it, I'd say that means he can play the GF ??

[shoe boy]

From the GSFL website.....

The Commissioners met on Tuesday 11/08/09 to hear charges against 4 players - the following decisions were made;

-McLaren Senior Colt Angus Lovell pleaded not guilty to headbutting in the match against Victor Harbor he found found guilty and given a one match penalty.
-Victor Harbor Reserves Player Anthony Davenport was reported for headbutting and oponent from Willunga in the Reserves match on 18/07/09 he pleaded guilty and given an eight match penalty.
-Myponga A Grade player Reagan Scanlon was reported for striking in the match against Yankakilla he pleaded guilty and was given a three match suspension.
-Willunga A Grade player Nathan Genovese was reported for striking in the match against Strathalbyn and given a five match suspension

Do's this put Genners out of a grand final???
As a players advocate I find the decision on the lad that pleaded NOT GUILTY and found Guilty very strange as You usually get one for your plead?
Obviously the 8 week lad had priors?

[ball breaker]

From the GSFL website.....

The Commissioners met on Tuesday 11/08/09 to hear charges against 4 players - the following decisions were made;

-McLaren Senior Colt Angus Lovell pleaded not guilty to headbutting in the match against Victor Harbor he found found guilty and given a one match penalty.
-Victor Harbor Reserves Player Anthony Davenport was reported for headbutting and oponent from Willunga in the Reserves match on 18/07/09 he pleaded guilty and given an eight match penalty.
-Myponga A Grade player Reagan Scanlon was reported for striking in the match against Yankakilla he pleaded guilty and was given a three match suspension.
-Willunga A Grade player Nathan Genovese was reported for striking in the match against Strathalbyn and given a five match suspension

Is Davenport the skinny older fella that plays in their backlines??? No 13?? surprised he didn't get rubbed out earlier with some of his conduct (or misconduct) over the last couple of years!! if i'm thinking of the wrong bloke ... i apologise!

[A Mum]

I'm wondering why the incident was reported on 18th of July and only just been 'heard' ??
Does that mean he's still been playing between then and now??
I suppose it does.

[ball breaker]

I'm wondering why the incident was reported on 18th of July and only just been 'heard' ??
Does that mean he's still been playing between then and now??
I suppose it does.

I thought the exact same thing! maybe they had to drag him there!

[limb]

There are 6 weekends left of football in the GSFL.
So if Willunga do make it, I'd say that means he can play the GF ??

It will come down to whether Willunga finish top or win the 2nd semi final... in both of those scenarios they would get a week off. If either of those things occur he will miss the GF (should they make it).

[A Mum]

Ahh, yes, good point.
Thanks Limb

[s m skinner]

Skinner we all know who you are ..all the more reason for you to keep opinions about tribunals etc to yourself or get an anon post again. You have been umpiring for less than a season and you rate yourself as the Messiah who knows it all...c'mon grasshopper. You might find the maggots won't be revealing to much info to you cos' they probably don't want confidential info leaked by the "Mole"
Let's see if you stick with umpiring, cos' you can only live on your rep as a player and coach for so long before they will actually look at your umpiring.

I dont know what planet your from skimmer but I believe you should get your facts right before having a go a someone , never did i say that i was the best umpire or one of the better ones , secondly i dont believe i gave out any secret information , all i gave was an opinion which this site allows you to do . If the umpiring people are unhappy with me about talking about the game then so be it , I took up umpiring to stay involved in the game . If they dont want me then thats fine and I'll walk away . Atleast get your facts right before having a go .

[teamwork]

I'm wondering why the incident was reported on 18th of July and only just been 'heard' ??
Does that mean he's still been playing between then and now??
I suppose it does.

I thought the exact same thing! maybe they had to drag him there!

I am not 100% familiar with the Davenport situation but I did hear along the lines that he was sent off twice against Willunga and with the rule 3 send off's in two years is a automatic 2 weeks holiday he would have 4 matches from this rule then must have been given 4 weeks for the headbutt incident. He has not played since the Willunga game.

[teamwork]

Once again it looks to me like the GSFL on all those cases went pretty lightly on offending players, do you guys/girl agree?

[limb]

Once again it looks to me like the GSFL on all those cases went pretty lightly on offending players, do you guys/girl agree?

Compared to what?

Compared to the AFL?... yes they were pretty light sentences.

Compared to previous cases heard before the GSFL tribunal?... probably about right.

[dodgingandweaving]

5 weeks for Genovese is OK. Just OK, i still thought he deserved 6+.

[words of wisdom]

From the GSFL website.....

The Commissioners met on Tuesday 11/08/09 to hear charges against 4 players - the following decisions were made;

-McLaren Senior Colt Angus Lovell pleaded not guilty to headbutting in the match against Victor Harbor he found found guilty and given a one match penalty.
-Victor Harbor Reserves Player Anthony Davenport was reported for headbutting and oponent from Willunga in the Reserves match on 18/07/09 he pleaded guilty and given an eight match penalty.
-Myponga A Grade player Reagan Scanlon was reported for striking in the match against Yankakilla he pleaded guilty and was given a three match suspension.
-Willunga A Grade player Nathan Genovese was reported for striking in the match against Strathalbyn and given a five match suspension

Anyone else notice the difference between the 2 penalties for head butting? Interesting
Im not condoning what Gennas did but i personally feel for the guy as i know its out of charcter for him. Massive on field loss for Willunga, they will miss his toughness. I can see the old bull Baxter & the grumpy carnavale now playing a massive part on where Willunga finishes. These guys must fire come finals & feed there runners.

Bit of triva. Myponga has never won a colts flag, unless you count the 1989 mini colts flag which a few of us hang our hats on Both colts sides will play finals at pongy & have a chance, LF your going down , which is a credit to Chris Rowntree & Damien "Sarge" Smith who have developed these kids for a number of years.

[dodgingandweaving]

Genovese is a massive loss. His class, toughness & experience will severely dent Willunga's premiership hopes.

Fair to say, Pilmore and the boys wouldn't be overly impressed.

[jackpot jim]

There are 6 weekends left of football in the GSFL.
So if Willunga do make it, I'd say that means he can play the GF ??

It will come down to whether Willunga finish top or win the 2nd semi final... in both of those scenarios they would get a week off. If either of those things occur he will miss the GF (should they make it).

He could play in the Grand Final IF Willunga lose top spot to the Creeks then LOSE the Qualifying final then WIN the 1st semi and Prelim. Thats 5 matches, 100/1 that this scenerio would happen and if it did, would u pick a player that hadn't played for 6 weeks?

[jackpot jim]

Looking more and more likely that it's the CREEKS premiership to lose and we've seen them do that b4.

[Bruce Almighty]

There are 6 weekends left of football in the GSFL.
So if Willunga do make it, I'd say that means he can play the GF ??

It will come down to whether Willunga finish top or win the 2nd semi final... in both of those scenarios they would get a week off. If either of those things occur he will miss the GF (should they make it).

He could play in the Grand Final IF Willunga lose top spot to the Creeks then LOSE the Qualifying final then WIN the 1st semi and Prelim. Thats 5 matches, 100/1 that this scenerio would happen and if it did, would u pick a player that hadn't played for 6 weeks?

what odds for willunga losing top spot to creeks, win qualifying, lose second semi and win prelim? thats also five games and based on results this year highly likely. willunga/creek gf and genovese would play.

[Zelezny Chucks]

There are 6 weekends left of football in the GSFL.
So if Willunga do make it, I'd say that means he can play the GF ??

It will come down to whether Willunga finish top or win the 2nd semi final... in both of those scenarios they would get a week off. If either of those things occur he will miss the GF (should they make it).

He could play in the Grand Final IF Willunga lose top spot to the Creeks then LOSE the Qualifying final then WIN the 1st semi and Prelim. Thats 5 matches, 100/1 that this scenerio would happen and if it did, would u pick a player that hadn't played for 6 weeks?

what odds for willunga losing top spot to creeks, win qualifying, lose second semi and win prelim? thats also five games and based on results this year highly likely. willunga/creek gf and genovese would play.

Don't tell him, just put a tenner on it.