by Phantom Gossiper » Mon Jan 21, 2013 10:55 am
by Phantom Gossiper » Mon Jan 21, 2013 11:25 am
by TheDarkKnight » Mon Jan 21, 2013 7:35 pm
by Grahaml » Mon Jan 21, 2013 7:47 pm
by TheDarkKnight » Mon Jan 21, 2013 7:59 pm
Grahaml wrote:A grade in the grade they deserve, B grade no higher than 1 grade below that.
by footys the winner » Mon Jan 21, 2013 9:18 pm
TheDarkKnight wrote:Grahaml wrote:A grade in the grade they deserve, B grade no higher than 1 grade below that.
Ok so A grades get relegated and B grades stay in grade 3??
What about angle vale if their B grade don't finish in grade 2 relegation, they don't deserve to go down though??
by SmithyOTH » Mon Jan 21, 2013 9:50 pm
Phantom Gossiper wrote:PREMIERSHIP TABLE
GRADE 1
Westies 105.47
Rosies 90.65
Goats 81.30
Units 78.46
Rams 65.55
Craigmore 54.20
ATCO 53.89
Vale 39.27
Run Home to finals
OTH: Rose & Crown (A), ATCO (A), Craigmore (H), Wesies (A)
CU: Westies (H), Rose & Crown (A), ATCO (H), Craigmore (A)
VIR: Craigmore (A), Westies (A), Rose & Crown (H), ATCO (A)
Goats: Although all 3 teams have the same sides left to face, OTH have the toughest run home with 3 away trips to finish the season. A capable batting lineup which has struggled in the past couple of games, the Goats will be looking forward to the return of the 2 day format which better suits their strong batting lineup. Always a tough close match up against R&C, they should be confident going into this weekend.
by Grahaml » Tue Jan 22, 2013 12:05 am
footys the winner wrote:TheDarkKnight wrote:Grahaml wrote:A grade in the grade they deserve, B grade no higher than 1 grade below that.
Ok so A grades get relegated and B grades stay in grade 3??
What about angle vale if their B grade don't finish in grade 2 relegation, they don't deserve to go down though??
Can't have 2 teams from the same club in the same grade.
by whufc » Tue Jan 22, 2013 6:55 am
Grahaml wrote:footys the winner wrote:TheDarkKnight wrote:Grahaml wrote:A grade in the grade they deserve, B grade no higher than 1 grade below that.
Ok so A grades get relegated and B grades stay in grade 3??
What about angle vale if their B grade don't finish in grade 2 relegation, they don't deserve to go down though??
Can't have 2 teams from the same club in the same grade.
Well, you can but they association won't allow it with the higher grades. In the lower grades a C and D grade side might end up in the one grade but if a club's A grade finishes bottom in grade 1 and their B grade win a grade 2 flag, both sides get relegated.
by Lightning McQueen » Tue Jan 22, 2013 8:38 am
whufc wrote:
Nope incorrect if your a grade were relegated from div2 and b grade promoted from 3 then u stay in the exact same grades as what happened to Atco 2 years ago, there a grade finished bottom in div 2 their b grade runner up in div 3, the next year they stayed in the same divs and the a grade made a div 2 GF
by Executive Member » Tue Jan 22, 2013 10:04 am
by Lightning McQueen » Tue Jan 22, 2013 10:32 am
Executive Member wrote:Probably getting to the stage where the PDCA should reduce numbers from 8 to 6 in each grade so that will incraese the cpmetiveness of games each week and shuffle some sides out of grades that they shouldn't be in
Play every side home and away two day games comes out to 20 weeks, premier only promoted and have a play off 5 v 6 for relegation
Just something out of left field that could work and make the grades far more interesting
by Grahaml » Tue Jan 22, 2013 12:00 pm
whufc wrote:Grahaml wrote:
Well, you can but they association won't allow it with the higher grades. In the lower grades a C and D grade side might end up in the one grade but if a club's A grade finishes bottom in grade 1 and their B grade win a grade 2 flag, both sides get relegated.
Nope incorrect if your a grade were relegated from div2 and b grade promoted from 3 then u stay in the exact same grades as what happened to Atco 2 years ago, there a grade finished bottom in div 2 their b grade runner up in div 3, the next year they stayed in the same divs and the a grade made a div 2 GF
by Grahaml » Tue Jan 22, 2013 12:02 pm
Lightning McQueen wrote:Executive Member wrote:Probably getting to the stage where the PDCA should reduce numbers from 8 to 6 in each grade so that will incraese the cpmetiveness of games each week and shuffle some sides out of grades that they shouldn't be in
Play every side home and away two day games comes out to 20 weeks, premier only promoted and have a play off 5 v 6 for relegation
Just something out of left field that could work and make the grades far more interesting
I've been an advocate for that concept for a while, having said that though, Grade 1 is as even as you could possibly get, the number of beltings is decreasing, there's going to one very unlucky side come season's end.
by Lethal Dose » Tue Jan 22, 2013 3:42 pm
Executive Member wrote:Probably getting to the stage where the PDCA should reduce numbers from 8 to 6 in each grade so that will incraese the cpmetiveness of games each week and shuffle some sides out of grades that they shouldn't be in
Play every side home and away two day games comes out to 20 weeks, premier only promoted and have a play off 5 v 6 for relegation
Just something out of left field that could work and make the grades far more interesting
by Lethal Dose » Tue Jan 22, 2013 3:46 pm
Phantom Gossiper wrote:PREMIERSHIP TABLE
GRADE 1
Westies 105.47
Rosies 90.65
Goats 81.30
Units 78.46
Rams 65.55
Craigmore 54.20
ATCO 53.89
Vale 39.27
Run Home to finals
OTH: Rose & Crown (A), ATCO (A), Craigmore (H), Wesies (A)
CU: Westies (H), Rose & Crown (A), ATCO (H), Craigmore (A)
VIR: Craigmore (A), Westies (A), Rose & Crown (H), ATCO (A)
Goats: Although all 3 teams have the same sides left to face, OTH have the toughest run home with 3 away trips to finish the season. A capable batting lineup which has struggled in the past couple of games, the Goats will be looking forward to the return of the 2 day format which better suits their strong batting lineup. Always a tough close match up against R&C, they should be confident going into this weekend.
Units: Arguably the best run home out of the 3 sides, they tackle a Westies outfit that has been slightly off the boil at home this week then get R&C out the way the following round, giving them ATCO & Craigmore to finish the season.
VIR: The dark horse, capable of producing magic some weeks as have shown in the new year, would fancy themselves in each of the remaining games after falling agonisingly short against R&C earlier in the year, and pushing SW also and have proved in recent years they are Westies achilles heel. 11pts behind the teams above, they would need to rely on results to go their way and put in a flawless finish.
by bagster » Tue Jan 22, 2013 8:14 pm
by fineleg2fineleg » Wed Jan 23, 2013 12:34 am
bagster wrote:Well done to John Parker and the PDCA u/21s ,they travelled to Flinders Pk last sunday and smashed the ATCA u/21s 107 all out Vs 7/110 on turf , the lads now get a gig on the hallowed turf of Adelaide Oval. great effort to everyone involved .
by whufc » Wed Jan 23, 2013 4:41 am
Grahaml wrote:whufc wrote:Grahaml wrote:
Well, you can but they association won't allow it with the higher grades. In the lower grades a C and D grade side might end up in the one grade but if a club's A grade finishes bottom in grade 1 and their B grade win a grade 2 flag, both sides get relegated.
Nope incorrect if your a grade were relegated from div2 and b grade promoted from 3 then u stay in the exact same grades as what happened to Atco 2 years ago, there a grade finished bottom in div 2 their b grade runner up in div 3, the next year they stayed in the same divs and the a grade made a div 2 GF
Which part of my comment do you believe was incorrect? The example you've cited doesn't negate anything I said so far as I can tell.
by Lightning McQueen » Wed Jan 23, 2013 7:28 am
Competitions SANFL Official Site | Country Footy SA | Southern Football League | VFL Footy
Club Forums Snouts Louts | The Roost | Redlegs Forum |