SAAFL Division 3 & D3R (2012)

[marbles]

no offense, and the man is a legend, but why is Macca so highly regarded

so far the record has seen a div 1 relegation, a div 2 relegation and now has missed a div 3 grand final

whats with all the hype

honestly??

couldnt somebody see there that nup this really isnt working out...

[lutz]

no offense, and the man is a legend, but why is Macca so highly regarded

so far the record has seen a div 1 relegation, a div 2 relegation and now has missed a div 3 grand final

whats with all the hype

honestly??

I think he also took them from D3 to D1, marbles.

[LMA]

no offense, and the man is a legend, but why is Macca so highly regarded

so far the record has seen a div 1 relegation, a div 2 relegation and now has missed a div 3 grand final

whats with all the hype

honestly??

I think he also took them from D3 to D1, marbles.

I know they came from Div 4 in the notorious Sailsbury West GF clash, I'm not sure if he was coaching them then ?

[wristwatcher]

no offense, and the man is a legend, but why is Macca so highly regarded

so far the record has seen a div 1 relegation, a div 2 relegation and now has missed a div 3 grand final

whats with all the hype

honestly??

couldnt somebody see there that nup this really isnt working out...

Took the club from div 4 to Div 1 with 2 premeirships along the way and helped get them to a prelim this year with a very young team, coaches juniors each year, is at the club 5 days a week, works hard, brings in sponsors, players and lots of visitors and treats everyone well and is and always will be a legend....

No offense marbles, but whats with your stupid post

honestly

[marbles]

just asking for clarity, simple

as an outsider i can see your point of view

as an insider u can see mine and probably many others point of view

for now we are all very much informed

regards

[Yank Man]

no offense, and the man is a legend, but why is Macca so highly regarded

so far the record has seen a div 1 relegation, a div 2 relegation and now has missed a div 3 grand final

whats with all the hype

honestly??

couldnt somebody see there that nup this really isnt working out...

Took the club from div 4 to Div 1 with 2 premeirships along the way and helped get them to a prelim this year with a very young team, coaches juniors each year, is at the club 5 days a week, works hard, brings in sponsors, players and lots of visitors and treats everyone well and is and always will be a legend....

No offense marbles, but whats with your stupid post

honestly

I coached a Div 2 res team in 2008 that he played in to help educate the kids, he then went and coached the A's. He was a great man then and a great man now. Came in to the MP rooms before our Div 7 GF and emptied all the cupboards to see if he could find a pair of boots when our skipper left his home. Turned the place upside down trying to help, he remembered me from back then, shook my hand and wished us all the best. Then went out and helped with the bar, canteen and whatever else he needed to do. He has a presence about him that commands respect and respect is what he gets in return. Great man and more than just a coach.

[Footy Chick]

Someone forgot their boots on GF Day?

[The Riddler]

no offense, and the man is a legend, but why is Macca so highly regarded

so far the record has seen a div 1 relegation, a div 2 relegation and now has missed a div 3 grand final

whats with all the hype

honestly??

couldnt somebody see there that nup this really isnt working out...

Took the club from div 4 to Div 1 with 2 premeirships along the way and helped get them to a prelim this year with a very young team, coaches juniors each year, is at the club 5 days a week, works hard, brings in sponsors, players and lots of visitors and treats everyone well and is and always will be a legend....

No offense marbles, but whats with your stupid post

honestly

I coached a Div 2 res team in 2008 that he played in to help educate the kids, he then went and coached the A's. He was a great man then and a great man now. Came in to the MP rooms before our Div 7 GF and emptied all the cupboards to see if he could find a pair of boots when our skipper left his home. Turned the place upside down trying to help, he remembered me from back then, shook my hand and wished us all the best. Then went out and helped with the bar, canteen and whatever else he needed to do. He has a presence about him that commands respect and respect is what he gets in return. Great man and more than just a coach.

Agreed the blokes a living legend. Came into our rooms after our GF loss last year just to see if I was alright & to give me some advice to keep our heads up, as my boyhood idol It put an instant smile on a very shattered face. He doesn't have to do this stuff & like Yank says he's more than a coach.

[Darth Demon]

G. McIntosh = a bloke who has always given everything that he's got. His record speaks for itself at all levels. Honestly!

[Nearly Was]

Lookout people the Chic's are back and don't intend being in Div 2 too long . All the way from Div 4 to Div 1 in consecutive years (?) Has it ever been done?

[Gatt_Weasel]

Think he is making it up

it seems i have to go into great detail every time i post anything in here any post i have made about kilburn this year has been true the points cap the payments being put on hold half way through season and now the final payments in which the club has said please hang on we like the mississippi running dry\

and now i have reported that they have paid the sign on bonus for the now former 2 reserve glenelg players.....shrek i know your a lawyer so spinning shit is what you do all day......i must know someone higher then you at kilburn to know what is going on....ill ask you this did one of your big sponsors pull out during the year and the money they had pledged was already spent so when they bailed this made $$$$$ problem bigger then the lies started


good luck anyway shrek deny deny deny

[numb nuts]

all set then pt districts and kilburn in the gf
no uni poofs around

[Jimmy_041]

[wristwatcher]

Lookout people the Chic's are back and don't intend being in Div 2 too long . All the way from Div 4 to Div 1 in consecutive years (?) Has it ever been done?

Pretty sure Woody South did it from Div 5 to Div 1 and then straight back down again...Kilburn were awesome this year but before you get ahead of yourself be warned the jump from Div 3 to Div 2 is a very big one

[Littlelegs]

i would have to agree, no point getting ahead of yourself. in div two and one you need depth to cover injuries. so depending on how good your fringe players are you will not walk through.

[Footy Chick]

sorry guys, have merged these posts, just too early to start with 2013 talk yet

[kickinit]

Lookout people the Chic's are back and don't intend being in Div 2 too long . All the way from Div 4 to Div 1 in consecutive years (?) Has it ever been done?

Pretty sure Woody South did it from Div 5 to Div 1 and then straight back down again...Kilburn were awesome this year but before you get ahead of yourself be warned the jump from Div 3 to Div 2 is a very big one

I think especially this year. Div 3 was a weaker comp compared to last year. Smosh would of got smashed by portland and flinders park if they where in div 3.

[Dazzler]

Lookout people the Chic's are back and don't intend being in Div 2 too long . All the way from Div 4 to Div 1 in consecutive years (?) Has it ever been done?

Pretty sure Woody South did it from Div 5 to Div 1 and then straight back down again...Kilburn were awesome this year but before you get ahead of yourself be warned the jump from Div 3 to Div 2 is a very big one

When Woody South went through from D5 to D1 we finished out of the finals in our first year in D2, before going up the following year. Much bigger jump than D4 to D3.

[lutz]

Lookout people the Chic's are back and don't intend being in Div 2 too long . All the way from Div 4 to Div 1 in consecutive years (?) Has it ever been done?

Pretty sure Woody South did it from Div 5 to Div 1 and then straight back down again...Kilburn were awesome this year but before you get ahead of yourself be warned the jump from Div 3 to Div 2 is a very big one

I guess Portland and FP would disagree.

Kilburn would need to retain a majority of their list to play finals next year though.

[piccachu]

I guess Portland and FP would disagree.

Kilburn would need to retain a majority of their list to play finals next year though.

i dont think we would disagree, Portland had a very young list and natural improvemwnt was always going to happen along with a few handy recruits and as for Flinders they recruited the biggest man in the comp and Martinello to go along with Ohara in the big man stakes, and if you remember Flinders were down in relegation zone for the first half of the year which tells me they took some time to adapt to the higher level of footy