SAAFL Div 6 & Div 6R (2011)

[story of my life]

shoc to stay in div 7 according to my sources

if that happens IF get the offer to stay up before angle vale get the off to come up?
anyone know for sure?

Ingle Farm, then Henley, then AV.

I find it hard to believe that SHOC would be sandbaggers.

i concur..dont forget they won the div7r as well..no lack of depth

and their 5th grade made the G.F.
Edwardstown's under 18's are in the G.F. tomorrow, most of them go to sacred heart college and next year will be lining up for SHOCS. So i wouldn't have thought depth would be a problem for them next year

[morell]

shoc to stay in div 7 according to my sources

SAAFL need to show some gumption here and enforce divisional parity.

[Half Back Flanker]

It comes back to the same old argument, there should be a C and D grade competition don't ya think??

[story of my life]

It comes back to the same old argument, there should be a C and D grade competition don't ya think??

yep

[dee man]

It comes back to the same old argument, there should be a C and D grade competition don't ya think??

think you will find that the league is already looking at that(div8)
that has been raised before but again was ruled out when strong clubs said no
if that is the case its time for the league to set the agenda and enforce what they think will be the best for the whole saafl not just some of the league

[BFG]

It comes back to the same old argument, there should be a C and D grade competition don't ya think??

think you will find that the league is already looking at that(div8)
that has been raised before but again was ruled out when strong clubs said no
if that is the case its time for the league to set the agenda and enforce what they think will be the best for the whole saafl not just some of the league

only thing with this is that some of the sides that have a's and b's would cop an absolute hiding each week. i.e flinders uni. plus im sure there would be some genuine floggings in the C,D grade comp as well due to clubs depths being of varying degrees of quality. i still think if a side wins a flag they should be made to go up rather than have the choice. unless it can be proven that they will be markedly weaker the next year.

[woodublieve12]

It comes back to the same old argument, there should be a C and D grade competition don't ya think??

think you will find that the league is already looking at that(div8)
that has been raised before but again was ruled out when strong clubs said no
if that is the case its time for the league to set the agenda and enforce what they think will be the best for the whole saafl not just some of the league

only thing with this is that some of the sides that have a's and b's would cop an absolute hiding each week. i.e flinders uni. plus im sure there would be some genuine floggings in the C,D grade comp as well due to clubs depths being of varying degrees of quality. i still think if a side wins a flag they should be made to go up rather than have the choice. unless it can be proven that they will be markedly weaker the next year.

what BFG said....

Also shocs should have no choice but go up!!!

[sprinttospace]

shoc to stay in div 7 according to my sources

if that happens IF get the offer to stay up before angle vale get the off to come up?
anyone know for sure?

Ingle Farm, then Henley, then AV.

I find it hard to believe that SHOC would be sandbaggers.

Tosser might be able to give his opinion on this but i reckon SHOC's would stay in D7 only to avoid getting there arses kicked by Blacks and Trinity in 2012.

[dee man]

It comes back to the same old argument, there should be a C and D grade competition don't ya think??

think you will find that the league is already looking at that(div8)
that has been raised before but again was ruled out when strong clubs said no
if that is the case its time for the league to set the agenda and enforce what they think will be the best for the whole saafl not just some of the league

only thing with this is that some of the sides that have a's and b's would cop an absolute hiding each week. i.e flinders uni. plus im sure there would be some genuine floggings in the C,D grade comp as well due to clubs depths being of varying degrees of quality. i still think if a side wins a flag they should be made to go up rather than have the choice. unless it can be proven that they will be markedly weaker the next year.

agree with you but i believe the concept of the div 8 was for all the c and d grade teams to stay in the one division
their would be no promotion or relegation system
that then would mean teams like henley and uni shocs would leave the division they were in and go into 8
off top of my head not sure how many clubs would make up this division but i would have thought their would be enough
imo the clubs would endorse this concept which would help, not only financially but also with help ect for the clubs

[Former Roo]

It comes back to the same old argument, there should be a C and D grade competition don't ya think??

think you will find that the league is already looking at that(div8)
that has been raised before but again was ruled out when strong clubs said no
if that is the case its time for the league to set the agenda and enforce what they think will be the best for the whole saafl not just some of the league

only thing with this is that some of the sides that have a's and b's would cop an absolute hiding each week. i.e flinders uni. plus im sure there would be some genuine floggings in the C,D grade comp as well due to clubs depths being of varying degrees of quality. i still think if a side wins a flag they should be made to go up rather than have the choice. unless it can be proven that they will be markedly weaker the next year.

agree with you but i believe the concept of the div 8 was for all the c and d grade teams to stay in the one division
their would be no promotion or relegation system
that then would mean teams like henley and uni shocs would leave the division they were in and go into 8
off top of my head not sure how many clubs would make up this division but i would have thought their would be enough
imo the clubs would endorse this concept which would help, not only financially but also with help ect for the clubs

Wouldn't there be to many clubs for the one division. I beleive div 7 and 8 should be C and D grades from the highest div to the lower. Div 1 C grade shouldnt be playing against Div 6 C Grade.

[TOS_lad23]

Tosser might be able to give his opinion on this but i reckon SHOC's would stay in D7 only to avoid getting there arses kicked by Blacks and Trinity in 2012.

It would be nice to dish out some pain that was handed out to us during the 1stXVIII days. we'll take any win against SHOC, whatever the grade.

[TOSSER]

Tosser might be able to give his opinion on this but i reckon SHOC's would stay in D7 only to avoid getting there arses kicked by Blacks and Trinity in 2012.

It would be nice to dish out some pain that was handed out to us during the 1stXVIII days. we'll take any win against SHOC, whatever the grade.

I'd love to agree with you Sprint but I had a look at them in the GF and they will be more than competitive if they come up just as the 3 sides this year were. Having said that, they certainly gave my school some hidings back in the day so would love to inflict some pain on them if we get the chance.

[Half Back Flanker]

Great to see so many faces up at Ingle Farm last night. Lots of new recruits and alot of the old faces returning. Quite exciting for next year, everything in place so bring on pre season i say!!

[blackRoo]

Great to see so many faces up at Ingle Farm last night. Lots of new recruits and alot of the old faces returning. Quite exciting for next year, everything in place so bring on pre season i say!!

[TOS_lad23]

Now that the footy is done and dusted for this season, where is everyone heading for end of season trips??

Tossers are making the trip down to Mt Gambier and have a few ideas for this years batch of "virgins".... always makes for a great weekend!

[red strip roo]

Ingle farm- looked ok in the first half of the year and were in the mix for a finals berth at one stage. fell in a huge hole at the halfway mark and didnt win a game for the 2nd half. had their good players, ruckman was good first time around against us and tremain and rigney were great. malbunka gave them a target but lacked a bit of depth which showed in the second half. respectable effort after being beaten by just about everyone last year and will go ok in div 7 one would think.


Couldn't agree more BFG. A quality core group of players and some good recruiting, already well and truly on the way, will be a complete different team next year. We realise div 7 will not be easy, but teams be wary, Ingle Farm will turn it around next year!!

Fringe B/C graders coming your way, hope all goes well & can get out of DIV 7.. Dont want to be like Mawson Lakes & be stuck there for a long time

Para Hills rubbing their hands together on this 1... if rumored 10-15 players going, of which 60-70% still have subs outstanding @ $200 a pop? At least 1 owes 2 years & played 15 games in 2 years ( 1 this year ) So i think PH will be waiting for the forms to come in & send back un financial

[marbles]

clubs require more volunteers to facilitate a C grade comp cos both AsBsCsDs all might play away and then things get tough

plus a clubs d-grade side could be posted elsewhere at a totally different ground from the Cs then it gets worse

[The Informer]

Ingle farm- looked ok in the first half of the year and were in the mix for a finals berth at one stage. fell in a huge hole at the halfway mark and didnt win a game for the 2nd half. had their good players, ruckman was good first time around against us and tremain and rigney were great. malbunka gave them a target but lacked a bit of depth which showed in the second half. respectable effort after being beaten by just about everyone last year and will go ok in div 7 one would think.


Couldn't agree more BFG. A quality core group of players and some good recruiting, already well and truly on the way, will be a complete different team next year. We realise div 7 will not be easy, but teams be wary, Ingle Farm will turn it around next year!!

Fringe B/C graders coming your way, hope all goes well & can get out of DIV 7.. Dont want to be like Mawson Lakes & be stuck there for a long time

Para Hills rubbing their hands together on this 1... if rumored 10-15 players going, of which 60-70% still have subs outstanding @ $200 a pop? At least 1 owes 2 years & played 15 games in 2 years ( 1 this year ) So i think PH will be waiting for the forms to come in & send back un financial

I hope u get your money out of these blokes. As far as i know you can only hold them back for the year just gone, not the one before

[The Informer]

Have heard the former Central United coach Paul Niven has a interview this week at Central united for the coaches role. As far as i was aware, he was pretty tied up with Ingle Farm over the last couple of years.
With Ingle Farm a lay down for next seasons flag i thought he might of hung around there.
Would Central United go down this path again? Y did Niven move on in the first place from United?

[old roo]

Have heard the former Central United coach Paul Niven has a interview this week at Central united for the coaches role. As far as i was aware, he was pretty tied up with Ingle Farm over the last couple of years.
With Ingle Farm a lay down for next seasons flag i thought he might of hung around there.
Would Central United go down this path again? Y did Niven move on in the first place from United?

Ingle farm a lay down for flag? Would love for them to win 1 as it's been a while. But I'd say div 7 won't be easy and are still a chance of staying up