Troy Chaplin - How many weeks will he get?

[Dutchy]

Got him in your DT SS?

[Booney]

He looks alright SS. He bounced up moments after that.

[silicone skyline]

Lucky he is the closest thing to a caveman in the AFL. Looks a lot like Bam Bam

[silicone skyline]

Got him in your DT SS?

No, I thought his performances would decline eventually but they never did.

[rogernumber10]

I'd be predicting a two-week offer

[Dogwatcher]

And Brennan?

[silicone skyline]

Also three.

[jimmy loughnan]

Let him off. Not his fault that Rich is a midget & consqeuently got him a bit high. What is the game coming to!!?? The bloke is in the air, how do avoid a collision when your already in the air?
If he shirks the issue, he would have faced much severe consequences from choco and team-mates.

Brennan's was deliberate & calculated. 4 minimum. No place for that on the footy field anymore.

[rogernumber10]

And Brennan?

Brennan the opposite. He has a five-year good record, which saves him a game, and then an early plea would save him a game as well. I'd say three, to two, and finish up at one.

Sylvia has a bad record, and he will get 3-4 for what he did.

[interested observer]

Let him off. Not his fault that Rich is a midget & consqeuently got him a bit high. What is the game coming to!!?? The bloke is in the air, how do avoid a collision when your already in the air?
If he shirks the issue, he would have faced much severe consequences from choco and team-mates.

Brennan's was deliberate & calculated. 4 minimum. No place for that on the footy field anymore.

The only reason Brennan should get games is because he did not clock that absolute w**ker of a runner..
His carry on after the incident, just shows what sort of a knob he is...

[wycbloods]

Chaplin should get 2. Would've been 1 but for a bad record/carry over points.

Brennan should get 4 which may be 3 due to a good record.

[Booney]

Let him off. Not his fault that Rich is a midget & consqeuently got him a bit high. What is the game coming to!!?? The bloke is in the air, how do avoid a collision when your already in the air?
If he shirks the issue, he would have faced much severe consequences from choco and team-mates.

Brennan's was deliberate & calculated. 4 minimum. No place for that on the footy field anymore.

The only reason Brennan should get games is because he did not clock that absolute w**ker of a runner..
His carry on after the incident, just shows what sort of a knob he is...

Arnfield...bloody good bloke. Has Port Adelaide's best interests at heart...

[wycbloods]

Chaplin has been offered 2 games and Sylvia has been offered 3 games and no chance of reducing it for an early guilty plea the same as Chaplin.

Brennan has been offered 3 games but can take 1 with a guilty plea.

[dedja]

confirms why the AFL are a joke ...

[NO-MERCY]

AFL definately a joke. ( Chaplin 2 games )
Chaplin could not pull out of that collision while in the air, a very couragous Rich put himself in a position to be crunched & crunched he was after taking a great suicide grab, the tough little bugger got up & never complained & good on him, Chaplin deserved to get off as far as i'm concerned.
Brennan well thats a different story, what an absolute joke he got 1 game instead of 3-4 weeks like the report warranted.
A deliberate headbutt that could of fractured an eye socket or cheekbone, i bet if an injury like that occured to Carr Brennan would of got 4-6wks.
AFL Tribunal system

[JK]

AFL definately a joke. ( Chaplin 2 games )
Chaplin could not pull out of that collision while in the air, a very couragous Rich put himself in a position to be crunched & crunched he was after taking a great suicide grab, the tough little bugger got up & never complained & good on him, Chaplin deserved to get off as far as i'm concerned.
Brennan well thats a different story, what an absolute joke he got 1 game instead of 3-4 weeks like the report warranted.
A deliberate headbutt that could of fractured an eye socket or cheekbone, i bet if an injury like that occured to Carr Brennan would of got 4-6wks.
AFL Tribunal system

Im inclined to agree mate, seems the only difference between Chaplin getting games and McPharlin getting off (despite a far more dangerous collision) was the judgement the panel made of where the offenders eyes are ... Does Chaplin not have the right to look at what's in front of him and brace for protection, only the player coming backward? Running forward you can still be focussed on the ball enough to not be aware of bodies backing toward you.

[GWW]

Presumably its all Adrian Anderson's fault (inconsistent and unexplainable tribunal decisions) - the guy who designed the new tribunal system, but hasn't got a clue about the realities of what goes on out on the ground.

That guy is as much of a disgrace as what Demetriou is.

[dedja]

Presumably its all Adrian Anderson's fault (inconsistent and unexplainable tribunal decisions) - the guy who designed the new tribunal system, but hasn't got a clue about the realities of what goes on out on the ground.

That guy is as much of a disgrace as what Demetriou is.

Bloody lawyer who wouldn't know a footy if it hit him in the head

[Dutchy]

Let him off. Not his fault that Rich is a midget & consqeuently got him a bit high. What is the game coming to!!?? The bloke is in the air, how do avoid a collision when your already in the air?
If he shirks the issue, he would have faced much severe consequences from choco and team-mates.

Brennan's was deliberate & calculated. 4 minimum. No place for that on the footy field anymore.

The only reason Brennan should get games is because he did not clock that absolute w**ker of a runner..
His carry on after the incident, just shows what sort of a knob he is...

Arnfield...bloody good bloke. Has Port Adelaide's best interests at heart...

Ive never seen a runner so happy that one of his own players got smashed in the head....weird bloke

[Dutchy]

Presumably its all Adrian Anderson's fault (inconsistent and unexplainable tribunal decisions) - the guy who designed the new tribunal system, but hasn't got a clue about the realities of what goes on out on the ground.

That guy is as much of a disgrace as what Demetriou is.

What AD done wrong?