Andrew Collins to face tribunal

[The Sleeping Giant]

Oh, my apologies. I didn't realise you're allowed to dish it out, but it's poor form to respond in kind.

Toughen up, ML.

Pot. Kettle. Black.

[MagareyLegend]

sticks and stones - who cares? its not poor form its just that nobody cares mate! get over it.

on a lighter note Andy Collins is famous himself for injurying a player on a tackle - anyone know the famous answer?

[Wedgie]

sticks and stones - who cares?

on a lighter note Andy Collins is famous himself for injurying a player on a tackle - anyone know the famous answer?

His tackle on Hawks team mate Tony Hall in the State of Origin match perhaps?

[am Bays]

Glenelg Fans can't forget....

[MagareyLegend]

Correct Wedgie - nothing sinister in it though - unlike another cowardly tackle on another great SA champ by a Hawthorn player.

Lest we (North Adelaide supporters) forget.

[redden whites]

Correct Wedgie - nothing sinister in though - unlike another cowardly tackle on another great SA champ by a Hawthorn player.

Lest we (North Adelaide supporters) forget.

High? Spear? Coathanger? Swinging arm?

[MagareyLegend]

Collins tackle - just run him down from behind and dragged him down in muddy MCG conditions in 1989 State game IIRC

the other one - late, blind-sided, cowardly .... and worst of all non-apologetic (every dog [Hawk] has their day).

[redden whites]

Collins tackle - just run him down from behind and dragged him down in muddy MCG conditions in 1989 State game IIRC

the other one - late, blind-sided, cowardly .... and worst of all non-apologetic (every dog [Hawk] has their day).

Well he was named player of the century so yes he did have his day or two

[bayman]

And Bayman, you are an idiot. You're trying to say that wanting to have an uncompromised legal process is akin to living in a repressive communist regime? Do you know anything at all? The sort of society you are trying to claim this makes up part of would allow anyone and everyone to pass judgement without knowing the facts. Your willingness to allow anyone to say whatever they like indicates you'd be happy to let the mob decide his fate. "The truth" in this matter is up to the trinunal to decide, not you. Thank goodness.

firstly, it was a throw away line trying to add a bit of humour
2nd, why can't we (including you) have a say/comment on what we see
3rd, i don't know what a 'trinunal' is
4th, get a life

[matt1]

And Bayman, you are an idiot. You're trying to say that wanting to have an uncompromised legal process is akin to living in a repressive communist regime? Do you know anything at all? The sort of society you are trying to claim this makes up part of would allow anyone and everyone to pass judgement without knowing the facts. Your willingness to allow anyone to say whatever they like indicates you'd be happy to let the mob decide his fate. "The truth" in this matter is up to the trinunal to decide, not you. Thank goodness.

firstly, it was a throw away line trying to add a bit of humour
2nd, why can't we (including you) have a say/comment on what we see
3rd, i don't know what a 'trinunal' is
4th, get a life

It's 10:11pm and the SANFL still haven't posted the results of the two hearings... Surely they aren't still going????? C'mon SANFL.............

[Dirko]

It's 10:11pm and the SANFL still haven't posted the results of the two hearings... Surely they aren't still going????? C'mon SANFL.............

They didn't post last weeks result until late afternoon the following day....

[redandblack]

One hearing.

I think Lokan's was withdrawn.

[CoverKing]

One hearing.

I think Lokan's was withdrawn.

two isnt there? collins and shirley??

[PhilH]

Found not guilty

[Blacky]

fair enough result

[dedja]

ML, NN, RandB ... where are you???

I'm missing my pointless legal argument fix this morning.

[Pseudo]

It's a bit hard to let it go

*

[bayman]

Found not guilty

correct decision because forget all this legal garbage i've read you can not (in life) get in trouble for telling the truth (barring criminals who admit guilt)

[Wedgie]

Found not guilty

correct decision because forget all this legal garbage i've read you can not (in life) get in trouble for telling the truth (barring criminals who admit guilt)

Maybe in an ideal world but in this country you can get in A LOT of trouble for telling the truth!

[MagareyLegend]

ML, NN, RandB ... where are you???

I'm missing my pointless legal argument fix this morning.

Well done, good result. Justice has been served.