The most overrated and underrated players in the AFL

[tedbullpit]

I'll start us off: -
Most Overrated: Jeff Farmer, O'Loughlin, DalSanto, Ball, X.Clarke, R.Clarke, Jared Brennan, Daniel Wells
Most Underrated: Scott Stevens, David Rodan, Shaun Higgins, Jarrad McVeigh, Nick Fosdike, Andrew Carrazzo

[Interceptor]

Most overrated: Justin Koschitzke

[dinglinga]

Most overrated:- Scott Thompson

[hearts on fire]

Most overrated:- Scott Thompson

good call followed closely by Brett Burton.

[Rik E Boy]

FS - Nik Fosdike is dead set ordinary. Not sure how you can label him underrated.

regards,

REB

[Macca19]

Most overrated: Brian Lake. Noone else is close.

[the big bang]

brian lake overrated?? i wouldnt say that, maybe abit inconsistant, but when he's on, he goes alright running the ball out of defence.

overrated - steven milne. would average 3 holding the balls a game i rekon, just from trying stupid, selfish things.

underrated - a few names in my head, but i really like the way brock mclean goes about his game.cant really say why, coz i dont know why, but i like watching him!!

[scottiemc]

I'll start us off: -
Most Overrated: Jeff Farmer, O'Loughlin, DalSanto, Ball, X.Clarke, R.Clarke, Jared Brennan, Daniel Wells
Most Underrated: Scott Stevens, David Rodan, Shaun Higgins, Jarrad McVeigh, Nick Fosdike, Andrew Carrazzo

Scott Thompson is all class, and how can you say Higgins is underrated when hes only had a couple of years and was injured most of last year?

[TroyGFC]

Daniel Bradshaw is very much under-rated compared to his forward line offsider, JB.

[hearts on fire]

Daniel Bradshaw is very much under-rated compared to his forward line offsider, JB.

yep, Daniel Bradshaw is a gun! I would have him in my team any day!

[Dutchy]

I'll start us off: -
Most Overrated: Jeff Farmer, O'Loughlin, DalSanto, Ball, X.Clarke, R.Clarke, Jared Brennan, Daniel Wells

Here we go again

Seems strange out of the 8 you have picked there 6 of them are indigenous? Any reason for that?

[dinglinga]

I'll start us off: -
Most Overrated: Jeff Farmer, O'Loughlin, DalSanto, Ball, X.Clarke, R.Clarke, Jared Brennan, Daniel Wells
Most Underrated: Scott Stevens, David Rodan, Shaun Higgins, Jarrad McVeigh, Nick Fosdike, Andrew Carrazzo

Scott Thompson is all class, and how can you say Higgins is underrated when hes only had a couple of years and was injured most of last year?

yet tell me which finals game he has been all class

[silicone skyline]

Scott Thompson is one of the best midfielders in the AFL. I think any opponent would vouch for that.

Under rated: I've always liked Nathan Jones' hardness at it

[Booney]

I'll start us off: -
Most Overrated: Jeff Farmer, O'Loughlin, DalSanto, Ball, X.Clarke, R.Clarke, Jared Brennan, Daniel Wells
Most Underrated: Scott Stevens, David Rodan, Shaun Higgins, Jarrad McVeigh, Nick Fosdike, Andrew Carrazzo

Scott Thompson is all class, and how can you say Higgins is underrated when hes only had a couple of years and was injured most of last year?

If you consider turning the ball over as classy,sure.

[am Bays]

Most overrated.....

http://www.portadelaidefc.com.au/Players/tabid/8088/default.aspx

[tedbullpit]

I'll start us off: -
Most Overrated: Jeff Farmer, O'Loughlin, DalSanto, Ball, X.Clarke, R.Clarke, Jared Brennan, Daniel Wells

Here we go again

Seems strange out of the 8 you have picked there 6 of them are indigenous? Any reason for that?

What are you implying dutchy?

I am merely expressing an opinion. By all means agree or disagree; this is a forum after all; however it is disappointing that you seem to be implying something else.

All the players I have listed have been at one time or another mentioned as being in the AFL's top tier elite players when I dont think they deserve to be. The fact that 6 of the 8 are indigenous is coincidental. I certainly think players like the Burgoyne brothers, Cyril Rioli & Andrew McLeod are superstars. The guys I have listed are not.

[Dutchy]

I'll start us off: -
Most Overrated: Jeff Farmer, O'Loughlin, DalSanto, Ball, X.Clarke, R.Clarke, Jared Brennan, Daniel Wells

Here we go again

Seems strange out of the 8 you have picked there 6 of them are indigenous? Any reason for that?

What are you implying dutchy?

I am merely expressing an opinion. By all means agree or disagree; this is a forum after all; however it is disappointing that you seem to be implying something else.

All the players I have listed have been at one time or another mentioned as being in the AFL's top tier elite players when I dont think they deserve to be. The fact that 6 of the 8 are indigenous is coincidental. I certainly think players like the Burgoyne brothers, Cyril Rioli & Andrew McLeod are superstars. The guys I have listed are not.

Not implying anything, just interesting

Wells has NEVER been mentioned as a top tier elite player...

Peter Burgoyne and Rioli Superstars? now you are kidding yourself.....

[tedbullpit]

I'll start us off: -
Most Overrated: Jeff Farmer, O'Loughlin, DalSanto, Ball, X.Clarke, R.Clarke, Jared Brennan, Daniel Wells

Here we go again

Seems strange out of the 8 you have picked there 6 of them are indigenous? Any reason for that?

What are you implying dutchy?

I am merely expressing an opinion. By all means agree or disagree; this is a forum after all; however it is disappointing that you seem to be implying something else.

All the players I have listed have been at one time or another mentioned as being in the AFL's top tier elite players when I dont think they deserve to be. The fact that 6 of the 8 are indigenous is coincidental. I certainly think players like the Burgoyne brothers, Cyril Rioli & Andrew McLeod are superstars. The guys I have listed are not.

Not implying anything, just interesting

Wells has NEVER been mentioned as a top tier elite player...

Peter Burgoyne and Rioli Superstars? now you are kidding yourself.....

Whatever Dutchy. Doesn't sound like it. You are flog.

[holden78]

Mackie by a mile hes a B grader

[FlyingHigh]

Under rated: I've always liked Nathan Jones' hardness at it

Agree. Good young player. Also Young and Ladson at Hawthorn

Overrated - Stephen Milne.

Always thought Fraser Gehrig was overrated. He was a good player, but not a superstar.

Daniel Wells overrated? Surely, Dutchy, he hasn't lived up to expectations.