Best CHB in 2008

[redandblack]

That's a very glib and disrespectful response, Wedgie.

Our results have been terrible and we've been the worst team in the comp for 4 years now.

We've accepted that and haven't pretended to be anything different.

That doesn't disqualify us from claiming we have a few good players.

[Wedgie]

That's a very glib and disrespectful response, Wedgie.

Our results have been terrible and we've been the worst team in the comp for 4 years now.

We've accepted that and haven't pretended to be anything different.

That doesn't disqualify us from claiming we have a few good players.

Im not sure how Im being glib and disrespectful when I think West are the best team with the best players going around in the SANFL? And my opinion is only that because I've been swayed by you.

[redandblack]

Not only glib and disrespectful, but disingenuous as well.

[Wedgie]

Not only glib and disrespectful, but disingenuous as well.

At least I understand the word disrespctful and think you are wrong there.
Explain the other two to me and I'll get back to you as to if you're wrong there too Psyber, whoops, I mean r&b.

[redandblack]

Well, I'm not in Psyber's class. Indeed, none of us mere mortals are.

However, to assist you, Wedgie, disingenuous means insincere, or pretending to be unaware.

For example, when you say Westies are the best team with the best players, I think you're being disingenuous; ie you're pretending, or you're being insincere. If you're not being disingenuous and you really think Westies have the best players and are the best team, then I think you're being delusional. This is the alternative explanation. It has to be one of the two, so I'll leave that to others to judge

[Wedgie]

Well, I'm not in Psyber's class. Indeed, none of us mere mortals are.

However, to assist you, Wedgie, disingenuous means insincere, or pretending to be unaware.

For example, when you say Westies are the best team with the best players, I think you're being disingenuous; ie you're pretending, or you're being insincere. If you're not being disingenuous and you really think Westies have the best players and are the best team, then I think you're being delusional. This is the alternative explanation. It has to be one of the two, so I'll leave that to others to judge

Oh, Im definately delusional not disingenuous then.

[redandblack]

I agree with you

[GWW]

Am i delusional or is this thread going off track?

[am Bays]

Trying to get it back on track...

Would still rather McLeay, and Schell to Fergusson

And before I get told they don't always play CHB maybe Fergusson isn't that versatile or good a player that he can't play other positions....

[TigerBoss]

West should win the best CHB, best rookie, best player and the premiership this year IMHO.
They were sensational today.
Full marks to everyone involved at West this year, easily the most impressive side in the competition.

It must be the beer you consume at games Wedgie, because everytime you post following the day's play, you make some ridiculous comments. Just recently you fronted up the morning after saying something ridiculous and apologised...might be time to give the site a rest following a day at the footy.

PS - Westies might just win two or three of the four "best..." you've mentioned there.