Who'll be the Coca Cola Star Search winner for the year?

[topsywaldron]

Hopefully it'll be Norwood's Josh Donohue. He's kicked nearly thirty goals and has had as big an impact for a young player as I've seen in a long time. He's got great hands, super awareness and his tackling for someone his size is extraordinary.

Who does anyone think will finish second?

[ca]

Hopefully it'll be Norwood's Josh Donohue. He's kicked nearly thirty goals and has had as big an impact for a young player as I've seen in a long time. He's got great hands, super awareness and his tackling for someone his size is extraordinary.

Who does anyone think will finish second?

Paul Puopollo

[Big Phil]

Maybe Broadbent from the Eagles could win, he is a real talent but did miss a few games with State Under 18's duties...

Tommy Holmes from the Bays for me, should win it just over James Boyd from South...

[topsywaldron]

Tommy Holmes from the Bays for me, should win it just over James Boyd from South...

Not seen any Norwood games this year then?

[am Bays]

I have and int eh two games I saw Holmes was ahead of Donohue - have you forgotten May 23rd already Topsy?

[Morphies Magic]

Holmes for me aswell!!

[Big Phil]

Tommy Holmes from the Bays for me, should win it just over James Boyd from South...

Not seen any Norwood games this year then?

Actually I have Topsy and a couple of non Centrals games for that matter. I just think Holmes and Boyd have been more consistant than Josh and because the Glenelg and South boys play on the ball, I think they will get a little more notice than Donohue. I think Josh is a talented player and think he'll be right up there so if it makes you happy...

1st - Tom Holmes (Glenelg)
2nd - James Boyd (South)
3rd - Josh Donohue (Norwood)

[topsywaldron]

Weren't you at the game Saturday? JD spent a lot of time playing on-ball.

To nearly be in the top ten goal kickers playing off a flank and on ball is almost Callinan-esque IMHO. A shame for him he's not on Ian's $80K!

[wycbloods]

I think Jared Petrenko will be high up the pecking order. I also would rate Donohue ahead of Holmes and Boyd. Boyd runs around getting cheap kicks all day and doesn't hurt you. Holmes, well he is very good, but i just think Donohue has had more of an impact on a more consistent basis from what i have seen of them both this year.

[heater31]

I think Jared Petrenko will be high up the pecking order. I also would rate Donohue ahead of Holmes and Boyd. Boyd runs around getting cheap kicks all day and doesn't hurt you. Holmes, well he is very good, but i just think Donohue has had more of an impact on a more consistent basis from what i have seen of them both this year.

don't think he can win it now as he is a full time crow????????

[wycbloods]

I think Jared Petrenko will be high up the pecking order. I also would rate Donohue ahead of Holmes and Boyd. Boyd runs around getting cheap kicks all day and doesn't hurt you. Holmes, well he is very good, but i just think Donohue has had more of an impact on a more consistent basis from what i have seen of them both this year.

don't think he can win it now as he is a full time crow????????

Ok i was unsure of his eligibility due to his promotion to the senior list. Although he still isn't a full time crow, he goes back to the rookie list after the season has finished doesn't he?

[TigerBoss]

I'd love to say Tommy Holmes, but I reakon Boyd just shades him with a slightly better level of consistency over the season...

No doubt someone will have some stats somewhere that indicate Holmes has better consistency than Boyd, but I think Boyd has been slightly better over the year.

[topsywaldron]

No doubt someone will have some stats somewhere that indicate Holmes has better consistency than Boyd, but I think Boyd has been slightly better over the year.

Boyd's a deserving runner up.

[Big Phil]

No doubt someone will have some stats somewhere that indicate Holmes has better consistency than Boyd, but I think Boyd has been slightly better over the year.

Boyd's a deserving runner up.

To Tommy Holmes, followed by Josh Donohue in 3rd spot

[sturtpeter]

I'd really like Martin or Thring to win it as they are both quality people.

But.. Broadbent's an exceptionally talented player.

Good luck to everyone concerned.

[whatever]

Boyd
Holmes
Broadbent


Note ; Hartlett better than the lot of them but in my opinion he hasn't played enough games to win it

[Macca19]

Ill be a sheep and say Holmes or Boyd as well.

[CK]

Matthew Broadbent, with Hamish Hartlett not far behind. While Hartlett had an interrupted season, that shouldn't affect his chances hopefully. A very open field though.

[MightyEagles]

One of the Eagles players.

[saintal]

Boyd will go very very close to winning the B+F down at South. I know I'm biased, but surely this award is his?

He has also polled quite a number of votes in the advertiser's comp, up in the top 1/2 dozen players i think.