Who is the best player in the comp?

[LBT]

Warren Partland regularly refers to Jeremy Clayton as the best player in the SANFL.
Who do you think is? I reckon he probably is with Jimmy Allen next best.

[bayman]

if clayton had his head screwed on properly 100% of the time he would be, obviously callinan, allen, backwell, crane etc could all claim the 'title' but the smokey would be (imho) torney

[drebin]

Too many players to choose from but Allan (again spelt with an A after the two l's!) right up there as is Alleway who must be close to the best key position player in the SANFL.

[Ian]

right up there as is Alleway who must be close to the best key position player in the SANFL.

Alleway for me, with Jimmy not far behind.

[Psyber]

Zorzi by a mile.

[Cambridge Clarrie]

As a Sturt supporter I'd have to say Sheedy or Chambers. Clayton's too undisciplined but I'd agree Allen is pretty good...

[LBT]

gee nearly all these guys are interstaters . Who would be the best SA born player?

[sturtpeter]

A tie: Jade Sheedy and Luke Crane.

[Adelaide Hawk]

I know he hasn't played much in 2008, but I'd pick Callinan, with Crane a very close second.

[LT Smash]

Jeremy Clayton. No contest.

[Dog_ger]

Jimmy Gowans....

[LBT]

Any South australians??
Bode, Thomas(Paul), Summerton, Torney, Gallagher,.....struggling for too many more

[Dutchy]

clayton is a great player however i think he shines cause he is in a poor team of late

[JK]

Clayton is the best for mine no question ... Is prone to "brain explosions" which IMHO hurt his team, but the PAM's finish well in front on him.

[Macca19]

Id say Clayton as well.

The thing that puts Clayton ahead of the other smalls named is his ability to play as a marking target in the forward and his contested marking ability. Allan is probably on a par with Clayton as a pure midfielder, but doesnt have the ability of Claytons to play as a genuine forward.

Ill use yesterday as an example of what I mean, but in the last quarter he moved forward, played on Torney who played 195 AFL games (and the majority of Crows supporters were shocked at his delisting) and is over 10cm taller than Clayton...in the first 6 minutes of the last quarter Jeremy kicked 2.2 and dished a goal off to Waterhouse. game over.

Clayton has the best mark of a non-KPP ive seen at SANFL level. Probably AFL level too.

As I said, Allan is probably on a par with Clayton as a midfielder, and Callinan is probably on a par with Clayton as a small forward, but Clayton is the complete package.

I think its incredibly dissapointing that pure footballers such as these dont get a look in at the highest level. Clayton (and the other two) would have more natural talent than half the players on an AFL list.

In terms of talls, id say Alleway is the most talented non-AFL listed tall in the league.

[Macca19]

Clayton's too undisciplined

His free kick stats this year are 29 for, 21 against.

Can be undisciplined, but has improved a lot this year.

[am Bays]

Todd Grima, took ten weeks to get into the SANFL grove but is now showing his class.

Yes centurion we are very happy we paid what we did to get him to Brighton Rd

http://www.safooty.net/forum/viewtopic.php?f=1&t=16713

In reality it is hard to split Sheedy, Backwell, Clayton and Allan (no particular order) as each on their day looks a class above the rest of the competition.

[goraw]

chambers would be my pick. if he went to any other club he would improve then10 fold inmy opinion

[ElizabethVCRThief]

chambers would be my pick. if he went to any other club he would improve then10 fold inmy opinion

Nice attempted trolling.

[goraw]

chambers would be my pick. if he went to any other club he would improve then10 fold inmy opinion

Nice attempted trolling.

not at all i would love him in a north jumper.