by Wedgie » Thu Jul 17, 2008 7:20 pm
Armchair expert wrote:Such a great club are Geelong
by Injured Phantom » Thu Jul 17, 2008 7:29 pm
topsywaldron wrote:Question for smac.
Do the clubs have different attitudes to this carnival? Do some take it seriously and try and win it while some just field a couple of teams or do all nine clubs take similar approaches?
by Squawk » Thu Jul 17, 2008 8:24 pm
by Big Phil » Thu Jul 17, 2008 8:29 pm
by Injured Phantom » Thu Jul 17, 2008 9:07 pm
Squawk wrote:Who is playing who in the two semis?
by smac » Thu Jul 17, 2008 9:14 pm
by CUTTERMAN » Thu Jul 17, 2008 9:50 pm
Injured Phantom wrote:topsywaldron wrote:Question for smac.
Do the clubs have different attitudes to this carnival? Do some take it seriously and try and win it while some just field a couple of teams or do all nine clubs take similar approaches?
Great response smac. I am heavily involved with the sturt program and I think most clubs here take a very similar view, but its the path to this that differs. This U15 carnival is the start of the serious end of football. Players must play for the club they are zoned in (based on address, not school/club) unless a club purchases a player & places them on their youth list. It is a busy few weeks for clubs, finalising all the paperwork.
Each club plays a maximum of 25 players in both metro & country teams. For some clubs, this is the first time players are cut from a development squad, while other clubs trim their squad each year. This is where education/development may differ from competition/winning at the carnivals end.
Come the start of the carnival though I think all clubs have education & competition on similar lines (since there are restrictions in the number of players who can play over the week). It is a great preparation path to U17's football and many lads are not used every opponent on the opposition being as talented (give or take) as themselves.
Every coach I have seen over the past week or so has been positive towards their group (despite results), showing there is a lot of educating being done at this level. I am yet to see a 'blast' or 'roast' for a poor performance.
A great week of football for all involved!!!!
by GWW » Thu Jul 17, 2008 9:57 pm
Big Phil wrote:Was down Richmond way for work out on the road today so I popped into Broadspectrum this arvo and took in about 25 minutes of the Port v Glenelg Country game. There was a couple of pretty impressive youngsters in that Glenelg line up, one lad took an absolute hanger![]()
by smac » Thu Jul 17, 2008 10:21 pm
CUTTERMAN wrote:Injured Phantom wrote:topsywaldron wrote:Question for smac.
Do the clubs have different attitudes to this carnival? Do some take it seriously and try and win it while some just field a couple of teams or do all nine clubs take similar approaches?
Great response smac. I am heavily involved with the sturt program and I think most clubs here take a very similar view, but its the path to this that differs. This U15 carnival is the start of the serious end of football. Players must play for the club they are zoned in (based on address, not school/club) unless a club purchases a player & places them on their youth list. It is a busy few weeks for clubs, finalising all the paperwork.
Each club plays a maximum of 25 players in both metro & country teams. For some clubs, this is the first time players are cut from a development squad, while other clubs trim their squad each year. This is where education/development may differ from competition/winning at the carnivals end.
Come the start of the carnival though I think all clubs have education & competition on similar lines (since there are restrictions in the number of players who can play over the week). It is a great preparation path to U17's football and many lads are not used every opponent on the opposition being as talented (give or take) as themselves.
Every coach I have seen over the past week or so has been positive towards their group (despite results), showing there is a lot of educating being done at this level. I am yet to see a 'blast' or 'roast' for a poor performance.
A great week of football for all involved!!!!
IP, can you please tell me what the metro and country teams wear if they're playing each other from the same club, and I gather all other times they wear the clubs jumper, eg sturt's
by oldwiseman » Thu Jul 17, 2008 11:00 pm
by Squawk » Thu Jul 17, 2008 11:02 pm
by smac » Thu Jul 17, 2008 11:44 pm
Squawk wrote:Will a state u/15 team or "team of the carnival" be named afterwards and if so, do they play anyone?
by CUTTERMAN » Fri Jul 18, 2008 10:11 am
smac wrote:CUTTERMAN wrote:Injured Phantom wrote:topsywaldron wrote:Question for smac.
Do the clubs have different attitudes to this carnival? Do some take it seriously and try and win it while some just field a couple of teams or do all nine clubs take similar approaches?
Great response smac. I am heavily involved with the sturt program and I think most clubs here take a very similar view, but its the path to this that differs. This U15 carnival is the start of the serious end of football. Players must play for the club they are zoned in (based on address, not school/club) unless a club purchases a player & places them on their youth list. It is a busy few weeks for clubs, finalising all the paperwork.
Each club plays a maximum of 25 players in both metro & country teams. For some clubs, this is the first time players are cut from a development squad, while other clubs trim their squad each year. This is where education/development may differ from competition/winning at the carnivals end.
Come the start of the carnival though I think all clubs have education & competition on similar lines (since there are restrictions in the number of players who can play over the week). It is a great preparation path to U17's football and many lads are not used every opponent on the opposition being as talented (give or take) as themselves.
Every coach I have seen over the past week or so has been positive towards their group (despite results), showing there is a lot of educating being done at this level. I am yet to see a 'blast' or 'roast' for a poor performance.
A great week of football for all involved!!!!
IP, can you please tell me what the metro and country teams wear if they're playing each other from the same club, and I gather all other times they wear the clubs jumper, eg sturt's
THere is a country comp and a metro comp - when Norwood play Sturt in the Metro comp, the game that follows is the Norwood V Sturt country game.
Some clubs have alternate guernseys for the country squads anyway (South and Norwood were the 2 I noticed this week), we have used Centrals away guernsey for both Metro and Country this year.
by MightyEagles » Fri Jul 18, 2008 10:34 am
Injured Phantom wrote:Squawk wrote:Who is playing who in the two semis?
Semi Final 1 1st Div 1 Metro v 2nd Div 2 Metro
9.45am Glenelg Central District
Semi Final 2 1st Div 1 Country v 2nd Div 2 Country
11.20am Woodville West Torrens North Adelaide
Semi Final 3 1st Div 2 Country v 2nd Div 1 Country
12.55pm Sturt Glenelg
Semi Final 4 1st Div 2 Metro v 2nd Div 1 Metro
2.30pm Norwood Woodville West Torrens
(Norwood metro a very impressive unit in my opinion. Got plenty of height about them)
by MagareyLegend » Fri Jul 18, 2008 12:13 pm
by MagareyLegend » Fri Jul 18, 2008 12:20 pm
Big Phil wrote:I actually bumped into "Sticks" in the loo before I left and asked him if he would put his hand up for the North job if Jars jumped or got the flick. He said he was enjoying coaching the kids too much as they don't answer back as much as the older guys...
by am Bays » Fri Jul 18, 2008 12:21 pm
GWW wrote:
Theres a young lad with the surname Gregory in the Glenelg country side, i think that would be Jack Gregory who plays for Tantanoola in the Mid South East League. He's kicked about 80 goals in the Under 15's so far this year and at 14 years of age is a big lad. Kicked 2 goals in his club's B Grade a couple of weeks ago.
by smac » Fri Jul 18, 2008 12:56 pm
by Dogwatcher » Fri Jul 18, 2008 12:58 pm
by GWW » Fri Jul 18, 2008 1:34 pm
1980 Tassie Medalist wrote:GWW wrote:
Theres a young lad with the surname Gregory in the Glenelg country side, i think that would be Jack Gregory who plays for Tantanoola in the Mid South East League. He's kicked about 80 goals in the Under 15's so far this year and at 14 years of age is a big lad. Kicked 2 goals in his club's B Grade a couple of weeks ago.
Didn't he "do" his knee playing a test for Australia in the 1920s...
Competitions SANFL Official Site | Country Footy SA | Southern Football League | VFL Footy
Club Forums Snouts Louts | The Roost | Redlegs Forum |