Mike Sheahan's all-time top 50

[stan]

Alot of people forget how good carey was when he was at the roos. I mean he was the forward line.

[carey]

Alot of people forget how good carey was when he was at the roos. I mean he was the forward line.

alot of people do forget how good he was because of his off field actions so whilst i dont agree with what he did i think we should judge the guy on what he did on the field and what he did for the game he was the best i've seen thats for sure .

[RoosterMarty]

Good to see an ex-North Adelaide lad named number 1

[sasquatch]

May be going blind, but I couldn't see Doug Hawkins...

[BUZZ]

Carey at no 1
Platten definately in the top 10, champion
Cousins top 15

[LaughingKookaburra]

Some are shockers. John Platten has to be in there, also Bradley. Would also have Paul Kelly. Heres one for the thoughts 'Shaun Rehn'. He was the heart behind the Crows flags and was the best ruck in the League for years (When not injured).Hell of a player, many did say 94,95 he would be better than Farmer (Then the injuries set in..........)

[BUZZ]

Brereton, 10 premierships, 5 day, 5 night??????????????

[LaughingKookaburra]

Very good point,also some bloke they call Dipper??

[BUZZ]

Arnt there several medals handed out each year in the AFl, namely:
The Brownlow Medal, Coleman Medal, Norm Smith Medal and Tuck Medal for players who have excelled at the level these guys once did, where are they on the list(s)?

[LaughingKookaburra]

now I think of it put that whole Hawthorn 85-91 side in that list. Hell of a side

[LaughingKookaburra]

Arnt there several medals handed out each year in the AFl, namely:
The Brownlow Medal, Coleman Medal, Norm Smith Medal and Tuck Medal for players who have excelled at the level these guys once did, where are they on the list(s)?

Very good point esp. Norm Smith.How the hell he is not on either list??

[BUZZ]

Arnt there several medals handed out each year in the AFl, namely:
The Brownlow Medal, Coleman Medal, Norm Smith Medal and Tuck Medal for players who have excelled at the level these guys once did, where are they on the list(s)?

Very good point esp. Norm Smith.How the hell he is not on either list??

Got me stuffed mate, maybe one day it will be the Wayne Carey Medal, Leigh Mathews Medal and the Tony Lockett Medal, but not in our life time i feel

[Leaping Lindner]

Arnt there several medals handed out each year in the AFl, namely:
The Brownlow Medal, Coleman Medal, Norm Smith Medal and Tuck Medal for players who have excelled at the level these guys once did, where are they on the list(s)?

Very good point esp. Norm Smith.How the hell he is not on either list??

Smith was a brilliant coach and a good player. This is for players.

Also guys this is (supposedly) of ALL time not just in our time.

[Leaping Lindner]

Arnt there several medals handed out each year in the AFl, namely:
The Brownlow Medal, Coleman Medal, Norm Smith Medal and Tuck Medal for players who have excelled at the level these guys once did, where are they on the list(s)?

Very good point esp. Norm Smith.How the hell he is not on either list??

Got me stuffed mate, maybe one day it will be the Wayne Carey Medal, Leigh Mathews Medal and the Tony Lockett Medal, but not in our life time i feel

The day they name the Best and Fairest after Leigh "sniper" Matthews I'll give up football and follow soccer - and I hate soccer.

[BUZZ]

Arnt there several medals handed out each year in the AFl, namely:
The Brownlow Medal, Coleman Medal, Norm Smith Medal and Tuck Medal for players who have excelled at the level these guys once did, where are they on the list(s)?

Very good point esp. Norm Smith.How the hell he is not on either list??

Got me stuffed mate, maybe one day it will be the Wayne Carey Medal, Leigh Mathews Medal and the Tony Lockett Medal, but not in our life time i feel

The day they name the Best and Fairest after Leigh "sniper" Matthews I'll give up football and follow soccer - and I hate soccer.

Agree mate, but according to the experts he's the 2nd best player, as you stated 'of all time' a load of wank.
Lists written by tossers who have never contributed to the game appart from the above listings they concture up every year, why do the top 20-30 change from year to year, once your listed as a 'GREAT' and given a status number you should retain that holding, our olympians do???

[redden whites]

now I think of it put that whole Hawthorn 85-91 side in that list. Hell of a side

83 and 84 where not up to it clearly?

[Baron Greenback]

What about Scott West?
Not on Mike's or Rucci's lists.
Has been one of the best players for the past 15 seasons.

[Booney]

What about Scott West?
Not on Mike's or Rucci's lists.
Has been one of the best players for the past 15 seasons.

One of the best in the last 15 years? Probably.One of the best of all time? Probably not.

But,these lists are made to be criticised and discussed,hell,if 50 of us did a list of our top 50,we would have 50 different lists.

[GWW]

Would Scott West even be in the Bulldogs top 10 of all time? I doubt it. Can't see how he'd be in the top 50 of all time.

[smac]

What about Scott West?
Not on Mike's or Rucci's lists.
Has been one of the best players for the past 15 seasons.

One of the best in the last 15 years? Probably.One of the best of all time? Probably not.

But,these lists are made to be criticised and discussed,hell,if 50 of us did a list of our top 50,we would have 50 different lists.

I'd copy someone elses list out of laziness...

I agree, not quite top 50 all time, but certainly top 50 of his playing days.