2024 AFL Silly Season

[tigerpie]

Nup that's still a firm no from me.
Mcstay, Checkers, Elliott, Hill, Cox, McCreery , throw in Daicos, Hoskin-elliott, Shultze.
Who is he kicking out?
It's only my opinion and it seems Fly is pretty keen so what would I know?

[Armchair expert]

He's a flog but I'd take Stringer at Carlton for a 2nd round pick

[Jim05]

He's a flog but I'd take Stringer at Carlton for a 2nd round pick

You’ll just have to do with spud Laverde instead

[Armchair expert]

He's a flog but I'd take Stringer at Carlton for a 2nd round pick

You’ll just have to do with spud Laverde instead

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ER7bIGwJeho

[Booney]

Mac Andrew.

Worlds gone mad.

[amber_fluid]

Mac Andrew.

Worlds gone mad.

Wow!
Some serious coin

Is he that good or will he be?
Only seen him play 2-3 times in patches and he looks an exciting player but the best player?

Good on him though and his manager as the clubs/AFL have plenty of coin.

[wenchbarwer]

Nup that's still a firm no from me.
Mcstay, Checkers, Elliott, Hill, Cox, McCreery , throw in Daicos, Hoskin-elliott, Shultze.
Who is he kicking out?
It's only my opinion and it seems Fly is pretty keen so what would I know?

Would get a gig in front of all of this lot

[am Bays]

Offensively maybe but when you add the defensive side of his game, not sure he fits Collingwood's forward half pressure game compared to all the others you've highlighted,

[tigerpie]

Nup that's still a firm no from me.
Mcstay, Checkers, Elliott, Hill, Cox, McCreery , throw in Daicos, Hoskin-elliott, Shultze.
Who is he kicking out?
It's only my opinion and it seems Fly is pretty keen so what would I know?

Would get a gig in front of all of this lot

Fat, slow, doesn't tackle, but he is better than the guys you have in bold?
Comedy Central.

[tnt]

Mac Andrew.

Worlds gone mad.

Wow!
Some serious coin

Is he that good or will he be?
Only seen him play 2-3 times in patches and he looks an exciting player but the best player?

Good on him though and his manager as the clubs/AFL have plenty of coin.

I think GC Have to pay overs to keep/get players.
They did give Rory Atkins 5 years @ $400K !... and he is still on their list after recent cuts.

[tigerpie]

Pies want pick 12 for Noble.
Can't see us getting that no way.
A pick in the 20's is more likely.

However if by some miracle GC went for it then that would be tempting for the bully's for Smith.

[wenchbarwer]

Nup that's still a firm no from me.
Mcstay, Checkers, Elliott, Hill, Cox, McCreery , throw in Daicos, Hoskin-elliott, Shultze.
Who is he kicking out?
It's only my opinion and it seems Fly is pretty keen so what would I know?

Would get a gig in front of all of this lot

Fat, slow, doesn't tackle, but he is better than the guys you have in bold?
Comedy Central.

Fat, yes, but not slow. He's there to kick goals, not tackle. Stupid idea that got given too much oxygen by the likes of Neil Craig. Guns kick goal, spuds like McCreery tackle.

Has more ability as a forward than maybe peak Elliot, but is a much better forward than the rest.

Whether he fits in their system is another matter.

[wenchbarwer]

Pies want pick 12 for Noble.
Can't see us getting that no way.
A pick in the 20's is more likely.

However if by some miracle GC went for it then that would be tempting for the bully's for Smith.

Speaking of Comedy Central

Unless it's pick 12 in the rookie draft, then that's a fair deal

[whufc]

Mac Andrew.

Worlds gone mad.

Not bad for a bloke whose kicking ability and decision making doing so is below average. Athletically though a freak even by the high AFL standards.

[Armchair expert]

Mac Andrew.

Worlds gone mad.

Wow!
Some serious coin

Is he that good or will he be?
Only seen him play 2-3 times in patches and he looks an exciting player but the best player?

Good on him though and his manager as the clubs/AFL have plenty of coin.

I think GC Have to pay overs to keep/get players.
They did give Rory Atkins 5 years @ $400K !... and he is still on their list after recent cuts.

I don't care what Korn said that is the worst contract in AFL history

[Brodlach]

Mac Andrew.

Worlds gone mad.

Not bad for a bloke whose kicking ability and decision making doing so is below average. Athletically though a free even by the high AFL standards.

I rate him; can play forward, back and pinch hit in the ruck

[whufc]

Mac Andrew.

Worlds gone mad.

Not bad for a bloke whose kicking ability and decision making doing so is below average. Athletically though a free even by the high AFL standards.

I rate him; can play forward, back and pinch hit in the ruck

Yeah his decent....not saying his not.

His an athletic beast who literally can play any of the 18 positions on the ground.

Just kind of funny that he is imo a below decision maker and kick of the football.

I know the game has changed but i still believe the best footballers are still those with elite skills.

[Brodlach]

Could be anything if he can put on 10kg. I’ll transfer it to him if he likes

[tigerpie]

Nup that's still a firm no from me.
Mcstay, Checkers, Elliott, Hill, Cox, McCreery , throw in Daicos, Hoskin-elliott, Shultze.
Who is he kicking out?
It's only my opinion and it seems Fly is pretty keen so what would I know?

Would get a gig in front of all of this lot

Fat, slow, doesn't tackle, but he is better than the guys you have in bold?
Comedy Central.

Fat, yes, but not slow. He's there to kick goals, not tackle. Stupid idea that got given too much oxygen by the likes of Neil Craig. Guns kick goal, spuds like McCreery tackle.

Has more ability as a forward than maybe peak Elliot, but is a much better forward than the rest.

Whether he fits in their system is another matter.

Modern day football has no room for a forward who can't or won't tackle or won't apply pressure.
That's why it's called team defence not 17 blokes defend. He's part of the reason the bombers couldn't hold the ball in their forward line, it would bounce straight out.
In my opinion Elliott might not have the goal tally but his pressure and ability to kick clutch goals makes him a far better player.
Same with Beau. He's never going to kick 50 a year but his pressure creates goals for the rest.

[wenchbarwer]

Worked pretty bloody well for Geelong and Tom Hawkins...