AFL 2020 Season

[Booney]

Brown is the best KPP since Carey IMO

Franklin.

KPP needs to be able to take contested marks IMO.

Stats say Brown took 490 in his 256 games ( 1.91 ) and Franklin 488 in his 300 games ( 1.63 ).

[Booney]

Brown is the best KPP since Carey IMO

Franklin.

Franklin best since Brown.

[whufc]

For me Brown over Franklin if i was a coaching picking, both absolute elite though.

For mine Brown brings more other players into the game, from what we percieve and see in the media i think Brown would fit a clubs culture better and was a harder worker on the track than Franklin.

[mots02]

I can’t believe there hasn’t been more contention re Lenny Hayes getting inducted the night before.
He might’ve been a “really good bloke” & a “great teammate” but his inclusion only reaffirms by belief the HOF should be every 2-3 years. His selection is right up there with Dean Kemp & Simon Goodwin.

This.

I'm more intrigued by his selection when you compare his records to some of the SANFL / WAFL players of yesteryear that haven't been included yet.

if players of the ilk of Lenny Hayes keep getting it, where does it leave a Garry McIntosh or Andrew Jarman?

[Dutchy]

For me Brown over Franklin if i was a coaching picking, both absolute elite though.

For mine Brown brings more other players into the game, from what we percieve and see in the media i think Brown would fit a clubs culture better and was a harder worker on the track than Franklin.

Franklin on the wing, Brown CHF.

[whufc]

I can’t believe there hasn’t been more contention re Lenny Hayes getting inducted the night before.
He might’ve been a “really good bloke” & a “great teammate” but his inclusion only reaffirms by belief the HOF should be every 2-3 years. His selection is right up there with Dean Kemp & Simon Goodwin.

This.

I'm more intrigued by his selection when you compare his records to some of the SANFL / WAFL players of yesteryear that haven't been included yet.

if players of the ilk of Lenny Hayes keep getting it, where does it leave a Garry McIntosh or Andrew Jarman?

No chance Garry McIntosh will ever get into the rebranded VFL's Hall of Fame.

[am Bays]

Carey isn't even the best Carey to play the game

or the best off-field

Bring him back......

[Lightning McQueen]

Brown is the best KPP since Carey IMO

Franklin.

I thought you'd chime in with Wazza.

[David Brent]

Brown is the best KPP since Carey IMO

Franklin.

I thought you'd chime in with Wazza.

I was comparing their stats earlier. Warren probably pips Brown except for flags won .

Brown an AA only twice was a surprise.

[Booney]

Brown is the best KPP since Carey IMO

Franklin.

I thought you'd chime in with Wazza.

I was comparing their stats earlier. Warren probably pips Brown except for flags won .

Brown an AA only twice was a surprise.

That's because Tredrea was playing at the time.

[Lightning McQueen]

I was comparing their stats earlier. Warren probably pips Brown except for flags won .

Brown an AA only twice was a surprise.

Brown was surrounded by better players for a longer period of time.

[Lightning McQueen]

I reckon this was a huge debate a year or so ago either on here or FB.

[mots02]

I reckon this was a huge debate a year or so ago either on here or FB.

If Booney was included in a debate involving treaders would it be better defined as a mass debate rather than a huge debate?

[Booney]

I was comparing their stats earlier. Warren probably pips Brown except for flags won .

Brown an AA only twice was a surprise.

Brown was surrounded by better players for a longer period of time.

"If" Port had won 3 then the likes of Francou, James, Carr, P.Burgoyne etc may have been seen in a different light.

I'm not for one moment comparing them to Voss, Black, Akermanis, Lappin, but there's little doubt the 3-peat adds some weight to their higher standing within the game.

[Booney]

I reckon this was a huge debate a year or so ago either on here or FB.

If Booney was included in a debate involving treaders would it be better defined as a mass debate rather than a huge debate?

No, it's huge.

[mighty_tiger_79]

Absolutely the more Flags won enhances a players standing.

Sent from my SM-A520F using Tapatalk

[The Bedge]

but there's little doubt the 3-peat adds some weight to their higher standing within the game.

.. and the Brownlows?

[The Bedge]

I reckon this was a huge debate a year or so ago either on here or FB.

Bring back morell

[Booney]

but there's little doubt the 3-peat adds some weight to their higher standing within the game.

.. and the Brownlows?

As long as Shane Woewodin has one it makes it hard to argue their value.

[The Bedge]

As long as Shane Woewodin has one it makes it hard to argue their value.

He did kick a good goal this one time.