Hudson quits Crows

[hearts on fire]

who cares its only Hudson, Rhett Biglands is better then Hudson, Biglands can play all over the ground...

[Punk Rooster]

who cares its only Hudson, Rhett Biglands is better then Hudson, Biglands can play all over the ground...

[Pidge]

Let Hudson and Biglands go and get a young ruckman in trade week

[Wedgie]

who cares its only Hudson, Rhett Biglands is better then Hudson, Biglands can play all over the ground...

Agreed, and Hudson's only 3rd in the league as far as hard ball gets, I'm sure Rhett will improve on that.

[Blue Boy]

what a turn around

so many of you members frequently posted this year, that Hudson was over rated as a ruckman, now your saying give him what he wants

Who said Huddo was over rated Syd ???

[blink]

Would Biglands ever have even gotten a hard contested ball in his life?

[locky801]

who cares its only Hudson, Rhett Biglands is better then Hudson, Biglands can play all over the ground...

plays all around the ground, doesn't get his hands or knees dirty

[Hondo]

Problem was, he appeared to be the only player of age that they moved on, which was bewildering and disappointing to say the least.

Who else was there the same age as Benny besides Roo?

We are getting off topic a bit here but you keep coming up with these 'thoughts' CP

[Grahaml]

Crows made the right call on Hart.

[NFC]

Let's be honest here, Rhett Biglands is one of the worst players on an AFL list.

Hudson >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> Biglands.

[hearts on fire]

Crows made the right call on Hart.

i agree,
he was injury prone.
he missed most of 2006 didn't he?

[Hondo]

Let's be honest here, Rhett Biglands is one of the worst players on an AFL list.

Hudson >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> Biglands.

That's a stupid comment

You have been on the 'lets ditch Rhett' train for a while now, I don't understand what your issue is it seems unbalanced

Huddo had his moments this season but he was better in 2005 IMO

[NFC]

Let's be honest here, Rhett Biglands is one of the worst players on an AFL list.

Hudson >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> Biglands.

That's a stupid comment

You have been on the 'lets ditch Rhett' train for a while now, I don't understand what your issue is it seems unbalanced

Huddo had his moments this season but he was better in 2005 IMO

When Biglands kicks it you have no idea where it will end up. His skills are average at best and at least once a game you’ll see him kick it on the full. Very poor decision maker, average skills, and average rucking ability BEFORE his knee reconstruction.

[hearts on fire]

Let's be honest here, Rhett Biglands is one of the worst players on an AFL list.

Hudson >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> Biglands.

That's a stupid comment

You have been on the 'lets ditch Rhett' train for a while now, I don't understand what your issue is it seems unbalanced

Huddo had his moments this season but he was better in 2005 IMO

When Biglands kicks it you have no idea where it will end up. His skills are average at best and at least once a game you’ll see him kick it on the full. Very poor decision maker, average skills, and average rucking ability BEFORE his knee reconstruction.

and Hudson has the greatest skills in the world?

no i think not

by far Biglands is better, fitter, stronger, faster, harder

i would have Biglands in my side rather than Hudson

[scoob]

he had a pretty good year considering he was coming back from a knee hondo... expect a big year from him next year IMO... it can take time as can be seen with rodan. will be a big loss for them and i think i a bit unfair to expect too much from biglands.

[NFC]

and Hudson has the greatest skills in the world?

no i think not

by far Biglands is better, fitter, stronger, faster, harder

i would have Biglands in my side rather than Hudson

So by being a better athlete, that makes Rhett better? I know he's quick and strong, but I couldn't give a stuff because he's as average as they come. Pathetic ruckman and terrible skills.

Hudson is a much better player and anyone who thinks otherwise is kidding themselves.

[Booney]

Hypothetical:

1:Round 1,2007,Rhett Biglands is fit,Ben Hudson is fit.Both get picked to play,who leads the ruck?

2: Hudson and Biglands play all 22 games in 2007,on solid SANFL form,would Meeson,Maric,Griffin force one of those 2 out of the side?

3: How can Adelaide afford to let him go?

[JK]

I would have Hudson over Biglands .. Although I don't think the latter is quite as bad as mentioned.

[hearts on fire]

and Hudson has the greatest skills in the world?

no i think not

by far Biglands is better, fitter, stronger, faster, harder

i would have Biglands in my side rather than Hudson

So by being a better athlete, that makes Rhett better? I know he's quick and strong, but I couldn't give a stuff because he's as average as they come. Pathetic ruckman and terrible skills.

Hudson is a much better player and anyone who thinks otherwise is kidding themselves.

Both of them are great players but i think both have around the same skill level and rucking ability but i would prefer to have Biglands in my side for that extra bit of hardness, toughness and speed.

Plus Biglands can play anywhere really.

[NFC]

Hypothetical:

1:Round 1,2007,Rhett Biglands is fit,Ben Hudson is fit.Both get picked to play,who leads the ruck?

2: Hudson and Biglands play all 22 games in 2007,on solid SANFL form,would Meeson,Maric,Griffin force one of those 2 out of the side?

3: How can Adelaide afford to let him go?

1. Hudson

2. Hudson #1, Meesen 2, Griffin FF. Biglands Eagles (reserves)

3. Biglands or Hudson? Biglands can easily be replaced, Hudson not so easily.