Carlton

[LMA]

just wait until trade week then

[marbles]

Only about 3 here that have flourished

Id rather carlton traded it for certainty in getting an established player

20180802_085131-720x893.jpg (193.28 KiB) Viewed 4199 times

[MW]

Only 3?

[PatowalongaPirate]

Where is Adam Cooney?

Only number 1 pick to have won a Brownlow.

[MW]

Where is Adam Cooney?

Only number 1 pick to have won a Brownlow.

Current players

[PatowalongaPirate]

Where is Adam Cooney?

Only number 1 pick to have won a Brownlow.

Current players

Righto.

If the conversation is around number 1 picks that turned out to be very good players then he shouldn't be ignored just because he is retired.

[Spargo]

Only 3?

Reckon that’s pretty close.
Hodge, Murphy & Gibbs.

[Armchair expert]

Whitfield is an absolute gun, overshadowed by Kelly but he has easily made it.

[David Brent]

Only 3?

Reckon that’s pretty close.
Hodge, Murphy & Gibbs.

I'd be taking Deledio's career any day with a number one pick. Also Scully before injury had been tracking very well the last couple years.

B Deledio 2x B&F & 2x AA --- B Gibbs 1x B&F 0xAA

[Spargo]

Only 3?

Reckon that’s pretty close.
Hodge, Murphy & Gibbs.

I'd be taking Deledio's career any day with a number one pick. Also Scully before injury had been tracking very well the last couple years.

B Deledio 2x B&F & 2x AA --- B Gibbs 1x B&F 0xAA

Gibbs is a far better player than Deledio IMO.

[amber_fluid]

Gibbs has 2 x BF at Carlton.

[David Brent]

Gibbs has 2 x BF at Carlton.

Not according to Wikipedia

[David Brent]

Only 3?

Reckon that’s pretty close.
Hodge, Murphy & Gibbs.

I'd be taking Deledio's career any day with a number one pick. Also Scully before injury had been tracking very well the last couple years.

B Deledio 2x B&F & 2x AA --- B Gibbs 1x B&F 0xAA

Gibbs is a far better player than Deledio IMO.

I probably agree Gibbs is a slightly better player also but was more a point to say if you had Deledio's career from your pick one you would take it in a heartbeat.

[amber_fluid]

Gibbs has 2 x BF at Carlton.

Not according to Wikipedia

He won it last year as well.
It mightn’t include that one.

[David Brent]

Gibbs has 2 x BF at Carlton.

Not according to Wikipedia

He won it last year as well.
It mightn’t include that one.

From AFL website, 2017 count

Top 10
1. Marc Murphy 174
2. Sam Docherty 169
3. Matthew Kreuzer 164
4. Bryce Gibbs 130
5. Kade Simpson 103

[amber_fluid]

Gibbs has 2 x BF at Carlton.

Not according to Wikipedia

He won it last year as well.
It mightn’t include that one.

From AFL website, 2017 count

Top 10
1. Marc Murphy 174
2. Sam Docherty 169
3. Matthew Kreuzer 164
4. Bryce Gibbs 130
5. Kade Simpson 103

I think you are right mate.
It was Murphy’s 2nd B&F not Gibbs.

[Lightning McQueen]

Gibbs has 2 x BF at Carlton.

I won an under 9 and under 10 B&F at Smithfield, probably on par.

[Booney]

Only 3?

Reckon that’s pretty close.
Hodge, Murphy & Gibbs.

I'd be taking Deledio's career any day with a number one pick. Also Scully before injury had been tracking very well the last couple years.

B Deledio 2x B&F & 2x AA --- B Gibbs 1x B&F 0xAA

Gibbs is a far better player than Deledio IMO.

I'd say Deledio is the better player when fit and firing, but Gibbs has been far more durable.

I'd be taking Deledio over Gibbs at their peak though.

[mighty_tiger_79]

Gibbs for me, Ross Gibbs.

[amber_fluid]

Gibbs has 2 x BF at Carlton.

I won an under 9 and under 10 B&F at Smithfield, probably on par.

At that age at Smithfield you would have celebrated with a VB can and a durrie surely?