Booney wrote:Robran wrote:Great to see Thommo back i no his the wrong side of 30 but u no what u get from one of the all time greats of our club. For me i would have got seedsman in the side too i think he is a very good player he breaks line's and has a great kick, IMO should be in the side before Mackay. She will be a slog out there tonight
Thompson in is a step backwards, can't be seen as anything but.
I cant see your reasoning for calling a step backwards Boon personally. I know his ability to run defensively you/others question, but as far as winning his own footy, getting it going our way and replacing a kid who plays inside mid @60% game time, I see him as a perfect experienced replacement (exactly why he is on the list).
My issue at selection is Otten over Doedee, I cant see Ottens match up and can see that being exposed rather than Thomo.