Players who played before 1907

[LEGS 11]

SOUTH AD:

(1905)

W D MOFFATT
J CARROLL
J P McKENNA
T TOUHY

[LEGS 11]

1906

A.WARREN
J L DAVIDSON
W J TYLEY

[spell_check]

Could any of these players be the same?

T Barrett - Norwood/Port
Dick Correll - Port/R Correll - Norwood
J Fitzpatrick - Medindie/Port
W Shaw - Norwood/South
A Slight/Alec Slight - Norwood/Port
N Tonkin - Medindie/Norwood

[Leaping Lindner]

Could any of these players be the same?

T Barrett - Norwood/Port
Dick Correll - Port/R Correll - Norwood
J Fitzpatrick - Medindie/Port
W Shaw - Norwood/South
A Slight/Alec Slight - Norwood/Port
N Tonkin - Medindie/Norwood

Not sure will look into that further. Do you have years for Tonkin at Norwood and Fitzpatrick at Port?

Jim Beasley and John Rout played for Medindie (1890 - 1892) Both had previously played for South Adelaide.

[Leaping Lindner]

North Adelaide

H - O

James Halliday (1898)
J.Jackson (1899)
H.Kinnane (1906)
A.Love (1901)
D.Lyons (1897)
Thomas MacNamara (1897-1900)
C.Martin (1901)
W.May (1897)
C.Milne (1904)
Ernie Mitchell (1900-01;1904)
Norman Mitchell (1897,1899)
H.Mumme (1900-1901)
H.Nightingale (1902-5)
F.Odlum (1904-06)

[LEGS 11]

Tonkin was at Nwd 1884-86

[LEGS 11]

J Fitzpatrick - Port -1882

[spell_check]

More same as questions:

James Halliday North/J.G Halliday Norwood
J Jackson North/J Jackson Norwood
Norman Mitchell North/N.A Mitchell Norwood
H Mumme North/H.W Mumme Norwood

[Leaping Lindner]

J Fitzpatrick - Port -1882

Seems unlikely. Would make him in his late 20's when at Medindie.

Tonkin was at Nwd 1884-86

Possible but would need to investigate further.

[Leaping Lindner]

More same as questions:

James Halliday North/J.G Halliday Norwood
J Jackson North/J Jackson Norwood
Norman Mitchell North/N.A Mitchell Norwood
H Mumme North/H.W Mumme Norwood

Once again I would need years at Norwood Spelly.

[Leaping Lindner]

Some South players from 1893.

C.Allison
H.Rojo
S.Reedman
R.Hancock
G.Rowley
A.Rossiter
L.Pedrotta
E.Monck
A.Goods
J.Kay
E.Jones
A.Marlow
T.Cook
A.Chaplin
P.Kekwick
F.A Fisher
R.Dawe
J.McGaffin
J.Scott
A.Bushby

[LEGS 11]

LL, not sure if this helps, but the following players were in the team photo for MEDINDIE F C (1889)

A Daws
C Schmelzkoff
F Cox
N Tonkin
R Holbertson
W Morris
J Fitzpatrick
A Stent
J Monagen
G Kreusler
A Lodge
J Ballantyne
W Hearfield
E Groves
Charles Nitschke
A Rossiter
T Rosman
J Jarvis
T Oliver
W Jones
R Hornabrook
H Mosel
A Keal
Herbert Brown
Ernie Lord
Arthur Brown

[LEGS 11]

WEST TORRENS --1905

J S TAIT
J COLLINS
V LYONS
S HINES
W BURNS
W O'HALLORAN
J HARLEY
J WING
G COLEY
E PLATT
E FORREST
G BATTEY
J RYAN
E BAILEY
L GOODSALL
P MCMAHON
A CRAFTER
D H SMITH
C MCGAVISK
A TAYLOR
A E EARDSLEY
P MEDWELL
M ELLIS
W ELLIS
W ANGWIN
L FILSELL
A GEORGE
W DRING

[LEGS 11]

WEST AD (1901)

J MCKENNA
W F HYDE
W A SUGG
W PHILPOTT
G BRUCE
P J MCKENNA
J SMITH
J MOYLE
R J GRANEY
C MALONEY
C FULTON
F SUGG
H PACKHAM
A WATSON
E BROOKS
M P T MCKENNA
L L HILL
S TIERNEY
B MCKENNA

[Leaping Lindner]

LL, not sure if this helps, but the following players were in the team photo for MEDINDIE F C (1889)

A Daws
C Schmelzkoff - Charles
F Cox
N Tonkin
R Holbertson - Richard
W Morris
J Fitzpatrick
A Stent
J Monagen
G Kreusler
A Lodge
J Ballantyne
W Hearfield - Walter
E Groves
Charles Nitschke
A Rossiter
T Rosman
J Jarvis
T Oliver
W Jones
R Hornabrook
H Mosel
A Keal
Herbert Brown
Ernie Lord
Arthur Brown

Cheers. There is a copy of that in the NAFC History Book. Very rare photo. I've only ever seen it once before in a magazine from the 60's which I saw at a fair (didn't buy) and have been trying to find since.
I've managed to find some missing first names.

[Leaping Lindner]

HOTHAMS (1887)

Jack Reedman
Warburton
Trathen
Reid
Cox
Turner
Hiles
S.Pash
Braidwood (x2)
Scantlebury
Taylor
Hosken

GALWER ALBION (1887)

Devine
Harker
Fitzgerald
Sanderson
C.Bishoff
Thomson
Bright
Solomon

NORTH ADELAIDE (1888)+

Jack Reedman(also Hotham, South, North, West (post 1907))
C.Bennett (I think this is Chris who later played with West and then North)
T.Bennett
F.Birrell
S.Pash *
F.Pash
N.Downs
Scott
Goss
Kekwick
Watson
Flight
Darmody
Warburton *
Reid *
McFie
Trathen *
Raskine

(* Also played with Hotham)
(+ This version of North Adelaide spent one season in the comp: and isn't related to the current North Adelaide in anyway.)

[Ian]

(* Also played with Hotham)
(+ This version of North Adelaide spent one season in the comp: and isn't related to the current North Adelaide in anyway.)

That was the same year that Medindie joined the league, who went on to become the North Adelaide that we now know in 1893.
There was also a club called North Adelaide that played in 1883 & 1884.

[Leaping Lindner]

I found an article which states that A.H Finlay (Norwood) played one match with Medindie in 1891. He applied for a permit with the SAFA early in the 1892. The same article also says that R.Ewers (who had played with South) also applied for a permit to play with Norwood.

[Leaping Lindner]

NORTH ADELAIDE (1888)+

Jack Reedman(also Hotham, South, North, West (post 1907))
C.Bennett (I think this is Chris who later played with West and then North)
T.Bennett
F.Birrell
S.Pash *
F.Pash
N.Downs
Scott
Goss
Kekwick
Watson
Flight
Darmody
Warburton *
Reid *
McFie
Trathen *
Raskine

(* Also played with Hotham)
(+ This version of North Adelaide spent one season in the comp: and isn't related to the current North Adelaide in anyway.)

F.Pash is Frederick
S.Pash is Sidney
That is Chris Bennett also his brother Tim. They both went onto ADELAIDE (not West - I was confusing the red and black teams ) then North Adelaide.

[spell_check]

This the entire list of all pre 1907 players for Sturt, according to the publication True Blue.
I hope I haven't missed any out from here, and the players who played after 1907 will be listed in that section.
E Ashton -1901
C.E Atkins - 1902
P.E Atkinson - 1902
B.T.B Bailey - 1901-03
R Barron - 1901-06
J.F Beasley - 1905-06, 08
H Bickford - 1901
R Black - 1906
A Bond - 1905, 07
M Bond - 1901-02, 05
H.F.C Burford - 1901-03, 07-09
J.D Burtrose - 1903-06
A.N Cameron - 1906-08
E.M Cameron - 1906-08
S Carter - 1903-04
P.T.A Champion - 1901, 09-10
W.C Chinner - 1904-07
W.B Colyer - 1901-02, 04
S Coombes - 1901-02
M.J Cooney - 1903-06, 08
R.E Correll - 1901
Crittenden - 1902
F Daw - 1904-05
W Dawkins - 1905-08
P.J Dickinson - 1905
J Flynn - 1901
T.F Francis - 1906-08
C.V Fulton - 1905-06
H Gardiner - 1901-02
P Gartell - 1903
C Gent - 1903
A.G Gloster - 1905
G.C Gurr - 1902-07
C Hack - 1902
T.C.M Hantke - 1901
L.H Haslem - 1904-08
H.E Hay - 1901-06
W.A Hewer - 1901-02
A.E Hewett - 1905-14
H.V Hewitt - 1905-06
J.P Hines - 1904-06
V Hughes - 1901-02, 08
V Hugo - 1904-06
H Humphreys - 1905, 07-08
W.T Jackson - 1901
F.L James - 1901-04
L Jessop - 1904-05
H.B Jolly - 1901-03
N.W Jolly - 1901-02
R.G.A Kappler - 1902-04
P.D Kekwick - 1901-03
F.J.P Kell - 1903
F.P Kelsh - 1901-06
Kleinschmidt - 1906
S Lawson - 1902-03
J Leonard - 1902-03
W.C Macklin - 1903-04
Male - 1902
E.C Malpas - 1902-06
J McAloney - 1904
H.E McFarlane - 1901, 03
McKenzie - 1903
J.H.W Moyle - 1903
G.J Murray - 1901-02
W Osman - 1901-02
J.H Pile - 1902
J Pollard - 1904-06
S Pudney - 1901
F.P Pudney - 1903-08
J Richards - 1902
H Sanders - 1902
P.L Shakespeare - 1902
D.B Sharp - 1903-08
G.C Sharp - 1903-05, 08-09, 11-13
W.L Shields - 1906-07
A.G Skuce - 1901
O.G Stoyel - 1903, 06
A.G Thomas - 1901-05, 07
J.J Thompson - 1901-03
Tidswell - 1902
C.S Tolley - 1904
A.E.P Tomlin - 1902-03
P Turner - 1903
F.A Verco - 1901-02, 14
Virgo - 1902
A.A Walker - 1906-07, 11
E.G Warhurst - 1903-06
A.A Warren - 1903
H.S Waye - 1903-10
L.S Waye - 1903
J Woolard - 1901-07
Wrigglesworth - 1901