Trades/Drafts (Nov & PSD/Rookie) - 2015

[stan]

Melbourne got reamed.

Thats my feeling as well. Basically Howe and Toumpass out for Kennedy and Pick 29......

[stan]

Pick 32 ends up with port. Collingwood get Howe and pick 68 and melb get Kennedy 29 and 50.

Port have gone 3 spots back in the second round and off loaded 50 and 68 to get Toumpass.

Adel get Seedsman.

What is the ******* point of getting pick 68 in this shitty draft?

I dont know mate. Been a few days since I spoke to the Collingwood recruitment team, so I dont know what there plans are but when I sit down with Bucks and the boys next over a latte I'll let you know. [emoji6]

[Q.]

Collingwood has traded Nathan Freeman and Pick 68 to St.Kilda for the Saints 2nd Round Pick in the 2016 National Draft and Pick 63.

[Rik E Boy]

Melbourne got reamed.

Thats my feeling as well. Basically Howe and Toumpass out for Kennedy and Pick 29......

Toumpas out is a massive win for Melbourne.

regards,

REB

[MW]

You'd think so. If you can't make Melbournes 22 as a no.4 draft pick, something is not quite right.

[stan]

Possible deal pending that coulst see Troy Menzel at the crows.

Pick 28 and Kerridge for T. Menzel.

[MW]

Possible deal pending that coulst see Troy Menzel at the crows.

Pick 28 and Kerridge for T. Menzel.

Oh hell no. Like the trade of Kerridge for Menzel but giving up 28 as well is stupid

[stan]

You'd think so. If you can't make Melbournes 22 as a no.4 draft pick, something is not quite right.

Yeah there is a buyer beware tag with him but they didn't give up a huge amount for him.

[hawks21]

Possible deal pending that coulst see Troy Menzel at the crows.

Pick 28 and Kerridge for T. Menzel.

Oh hell no. Like the trade of Kerridge for Menzel but giving up 28 as well is stupid

I disagree, Menzel has more upside than Kerridge IMO.
Menzel can be in our starting 22 while Kerridge (Who i like) will most likley be a depth player.
Menzel offers a bit of x-factor and is only 21. Do the deal if we can!
Still leaves us with picks 9 & 13!

[MW]

I agree with what you are saying just would like a pick coming back, maybe their 3rd rounder or something. Just think it is overs for Menzel.

[Feenix]

Possible deal pending that coulst see Troy Menzel at the crows.

Pick 28 and Kerridge for T. Menzel.

Oh hell no. Like the trade of Kerridge for Menzel but giving up 28 as well is stupid

I don’t think Kerridge for Menzal is fair swap although Kerridge and 28 seems overs but their next pick is 71 so they can hardly offer up that.

[Brodlach]

Possible deal pending that coulst see Troy Menzel at the crows.

Pick 28 and Kerridge for T. Menzel.

That would be a shithouse trade

[MW]

Apparently Menzel is in Adelaide for a medical...

[Fricky]

Apparently Menzel is in Adelaide for a medical...

May as well call it a done deal then.

[Turbo]

Possible deal pending that coulst see Troy Menzel at the crows.

Pick 28 and Kerridge for T. Menzel.

That would be a shithouse trade

Pick 13

[Spargo]

I agree with what you are saying just would like a pick coming back, maybe their 3rd rounder or something. Just think it is overs for Menzel.

Sometimes you've got to pay overs - Menzel would be a good get.

[Q.]

Treloar deal reported to be close to done, for the 137th time.

[HH3]

Anyone know whats happening with Aish yet?

Surely Brisbane would rather a deal with the Roos.

Bastinac/Aish straight swappsies?

[Booney]

Melbourne got reamed.

Thats my feeling as well. Basically Howe and Toumpass out for Kennedy and Pick 29......

Toumpas out is a massive win for Melbourne.

regards,

REB

I guess Port looked at picking a second rounder in a shallow draft that is an unknown or getting Toumpas.

I'm not thrilled at this trade, but, given the option of a dubious second rounder or a player who immediately adds depth and could develop into a player is probably a win for the club. Especially given he'd come pretty cheap and is only 21.

[Q.]

Anyone know whats happening with Aish yet?

Surely Brisbane would rather a deal with the Roos.

Bastinac/Aish straight swappsies?

Aish has chosen Collingwood though.

Looking like a couple of second rounders will get it done.