reppoh_eht wrote:Look Good In Leather wrote:Peter Griffen wrote:You'd have to look over a 5 year period and strength of all grades on the borderline teams.
Definite Div 1 - Reynella, Morphett Vale, Noarlunga, Happy Valley, Brighton, Flagstaff Hill
Borderline - Morphy Park, Pt Noarlunga, Edwardstown, Cove, Christies
Definite Div 2 - Hackham, Marion, Lonsdale, Aldinga
Flagstaff Hill definite Div 1 on this year's form, not over 5 years though
Ok I'll bite...
A Grade
2011: Prelim Final
2012: Elimination Final
2013: Missed Finals
2014: Semi Final
2015: Unknown - but currently sitting 2nd on Premiership Table
B Grade:
2011: Prelim Final
2012: Grand Final
2013: Premiers
2014: Grand Final
2015: Unknown - but currently sitting 3rd on Premiership Table
If you wanted to count Juniors the picture would be even better...
2011's finals run does skew the results somewhat as the highest minor round finish has been 6th. I was more commenting in relation to the other teams Peter Griffen had as "borderline" clubs as the Port Noarlunga and Morphettville Park records during that period have been more impressive.
It should only be worked out on the current season anyhow, these ideas of 5 years, 10 years and the like have no bearing on current strength, why not 20 years, 50 years, 100 year... where do you end?
If there is a divisional structure it should be on A-Grade strength and the fielding of all Saturday grades.
At the moment the only "Definites" are Flagstaff Hill, Reynella, Happy Valley, Brighton & Christies Beach.