Luke15 wrote:Would this work
Division 1
Reynella
Flaggies
Morphett Vale
Noarlunga
Happy Valley
Brighton
Porties
Cove
Division 2
MParks
Edwardstown
Christies
Hackham
Aldinga
Marion
OSB
Explanation is that most of the Div 1 clubs have a full compliment of juniors plus are reasonably successful this year and.in the last 3 years.
Div 2 clubs well Morphy Parks, Edwardstown are stiff because they are going well in the As but in my.opinion they dont qualify for Div 1 unless they make more of an effort to get Saturday juniors. Christies do have a full compliment and good on Cratey and the club for building it up this well but i have them in Div 2 based on A grade performances especially this year.
Only 4 of your "Div 1" clubs have full juniors, so your reasoning for Morphy Park & Edwardstown being down conflicts with having CB down.
As for solving the problem of scores, these results would still occur:
Div 1
Reynella 14.12 (96) d Noarlunga 5.6 (36)
Reynella 24.14 (158) d Happy Valley 5.4 (34)
Port Noarlunga 18.8 (116) d Happy Valley 8.9 (57)
Reynella 31.21 (207) d Cove 6.8 (44)
Div 2
Morphettville Park 35.20 (230) d Lonsdale 9.10 (64)
Morphettville Park 13.14 (92) d Marion 5.11 (41)
Morphettville Park 21.20 (146) d Aldinga 3.8 (26)
Edwardstown 26.11 (167) d Hackham 10.11 (71)
But at least we would avoid the embarrassment of "Div 1" teams being beaten by "Div 2" teams like these:
Morphettville Park 12.15 (87) d Brighton 9.18 (72)
Christies Beach 7.12 (54) d Happy Valley 4.12 (36)
It's only 7 weeks in, it's not like we have Hamley Bridge, Kangarilla, Sedan Cambrai, Flinders University or North pines in our comp