Ch9 AFL Division 3 - 2015

[jo172]

I hope Glenunga gets to go up. Would be a fantastically Grand Final free meteoric rise

[scottroo]

Any updates on who is going up? If anyone?

[Footy Chick]

Give them some credit...they did go up once via (losing) GF

In seriousness though, they are seriously the exception to the rule and although they've struggled at times, have done very well to meet the challenges of higher grades.

Good on em, I say.

[Mr Beefy]

Any updates on who is going up? If anyone?

Yeah one of these:

Kilburn
Eastern Park

Pooraka
Kenilworth
Hectorville
Glenunga
Westminster
North Haven

[Robb_Stark]

Any updates on who is going up? If anyone?

Yeah one of these:

Kilburn
Eastern Park

Pooraka
Kenilworth
Hectorville
Glenunga
Westminster
North Haven

cross Pooraka out

[Q.]

So will Salisbury West be in D4 or not at all?

[Footy Chick]

that was the next topic of discussion..

They'll be lucky to get a C1 team together.

[Robb_Stark]

make Kilburn stay in div 3 they deserve it after the crap that happen this year they look like they will have a semi decent team this year

[jo172]

that was the next topic of discussion..

They'll be lucky to get a C1 team together.

Seems appropriate on the 10 year anniversary of when they should have been booted out for good

[woodublieve12]

make Kilburn stay in div 3 they deserve it after the crap that happen this year they look like they will have a semi decent team this year

they at least had a crack... kilburn should be relegated as per the rules.

[Robb_Stark]

make Kilburn stay in div 3 they deserve it after the crap that happen this year they look like they will have a semi decent team this year

they at least had a crack... kilburn should be relegated as per the rules.

they had a crack at div 3 i beg to differ ........................they played in div 3 but failed to play like other years and fielded below par team week in week out now they have money and are relegated and have a semi decent squad they should have to replace another side that has done exactly the same thing

[woodublieve12]

make Kilburn stay in div 3 they deserve it after the crap that happen this year they look like they will have a semi decent team this year

they at least had a crack... kilburn should be relegated as per the rules.

they had a crack at div 3 i beg to differ ........................they played in div 3 but failed to play like other years and fielded below par team week in week out now they have money and are relegated and have a semi decent squad they should have to replace another side that has done exactly the same thing

well seeing it first hand, they had a crack... i would prefer that then what others have done recently. now they are in a position to rebuild. good on them

[Q.]

that was the next topic of discussion..

They'll be lucky to get a C1 team together.

So if no one goes up, D3 has a bye? And if a team goes up D4 has a bye?

[Boosh]

Quite obviously Salisbury West are in big strife.

Whilst we are at the bottom of the list North Haven were still asked what our response would be if it comes to that and the answer is no.

So Salisbury, Hope Valley, North Haven are out, any others withdrawn from the race?

[Mr Beefy]

Its down to
Kilburn
Eastern Park
Kenilworth
Hectorville
Glenunga
Westminster

[zedman]

make Kilburn stay in div 3 they deserve it after the crap that happen this year they look like they will have a semi decent team this year

salisbury west out of div 3..kilburn back up to div 3..woodville south back to div 4..brahma back to div 5 and either 9 teams and a bye in div 6 or see if somebody wants to come up from div 7..this view is taken with my lockleys hat firmly in place..

[jo172]

make Kilburn stay in div 3 they deserve it after the crap that happen this year they look like they will have a semi decent team this year

salisbury west out of div 3..kilburn back up to div 3..woodville south back to div 4..brahma back to div 5 and either 9 teams and a bye in div 6 or see if somebody wants to come up from div 7..this view is taken with my lockleys hat firmly in place..

Apart from the logistical/administrative/planning nightmare this would create I have some sympathy for this view.

Having a 9 team Div 3 or 4 while having 10 team Divs 4-8 is ridiculous (although I understand that everyone is a victim of circumstance).

[Q.]

make Kilburn stay in div 3 they deserve it after the crap that happen this year they look like they will have a semi decent team this year

salisbury west out of div 3..kilburn back up to div 3..woodville south back to div 4..brahma back to div 5 and either 9 teams and a bye in div 6 or see if somebody wants to come up from div 7..this view is taken with my lockleys hat firmly in place..

Apart from the logistical/administrative/planning nightmare this would create I have some sympathy for this view.

Having a 9 team Div 3 or 4 while having 10 team Divs 4-8 is ridiculous (although I understand that everyone is a victim of circumstance).

I'll never understand the hate for the bye.

[jo172]

make Kilburn stay in div 3 they deserve it after the crap that happen this year they look like they will have a semi decent team this year

salisbury west out of div 3..kilburn back up to div 3..woodville south back to div 4..brahma back to div 5 and either 9 teams and a bye in div 6 or see if somebody wants to come up from div 7..this view is taken with my lockleys hat firmly in place..

Apart from the logistical/administrative/planning nightmare this would create I have some sympathy for this view.

Having a 9 team Div 3 or 4 while having 10 team Divs 4-8 is ridiculous (although I understand that everyone is a victim of circumstance).

I'll never understand the hate for the bye.

Every time I've been involved in a league that has one my bye is always either Round 1 or Round 9 meaning that it results it a fortnight's break (sometimes leading into finals). It's quite irritating

[Q.]

I'll never understand the hate for the bye.

Every time I've been involved in a league that has one my bye is always either Round 1 or Round 9 meaning that it results it a fortnight's break (sometimes leading into finals). It's quite irritating

It might be an small inconvience for one side if, in the very specific cicumstance, they had a bye in R18 and finished top (you'd think a team in that position is organised enough to counter the inconvenience). Though I doubt a bye has ever been the blame for a team not winning a premiership.