Ch9 AFL Division 7 - 2015

[scottroo]

Is that confirmed fc

[Footy Chick]

yeah I believe so Scotty, they've had their one year with one team, just like everyone else.

[Ye Olde Place Kick]

If blackwood don't bring in another team, they're out.

I don't think Wingies are going to get their two teams either, so that's possibly another 2 gone.

So FC if a club has only 1 team they can't play ammos or can they play in a C grade comp?

[Cohiba]

If blackwood don't bring in another team, they're out.

I don't think Wingies are going to get their two teams either, so that's possibly another 2 gone.

So FC if a club has only 1 team they can't play ammos or can they play in a C grade comp?

Same old merry-go-round..... A C Grade comp IMO implies that Clubs who have a "C" grade (or a third team if you like) competes on an equal footing with teams similarly disposed. By definition a single team would represent the Club's as an A grade side irrespective of their capabilities . As such they get to play with big boys in a Division hopefully that reflects their standard. How you measure this....well I'll leave that to some of our "experts"...

That said as I have stated before....if you can't field two teams.......work harder or merge.......

[Footy Chick]

Blackwood have 2 other teams in another comp Cohiiba, do you really think they need to merge?

No, they just need to make up their friggin minds as to which comp they want to play in.

They've had their one year, they can't have their cake and eat it too.

Ye old Place Kick - new rules state that clubs must have 2 sides, if they happen to fall on hard times, they will be given one year with one side to try and rebuild and if they can't produce two teams the following season, they won't be playing in the SAAFL.

All other comps have a minimum teams requirement, it's about time we had one too.

[cracka]

Blackwood have 2 other teams in another comp Cohiiba, do you really think they need to merge?

No, they just need to make up their friggin minds as to which comp they want to play in.

They've had their one year, they can't have their cake and eat it too.

Ye old Place Kick - new rules state that clubs must have 2 sides, if they happen to fall on hard times, they will be given one year with one side to try and rebuild and if they can't produce two teams the following season, they won't be playing in the SAAFL.

All other comps have a minimum teams requirement, it's about time we had one too.

Amazingly there isn't an uproar on the SAAFL enforcing this like there is with the HFL country comp.

[morell]

Probably because everyone agrees it's fair enough.

Mind you if we want to debate the measurements on how we determine whether or not side will have two teams in February.... then I'm all ears.

[Cohiba]

Blackwood have 2 other teams in another comp Cohiiba, do you really think they need to merge?

No, they just need to make up their friggin minds as to which comp they want to play in.

They've had their one year, they can't have their cake and eat it too.

Ye old Place Kick - new rules state that clubs must have 2 sides, if they happen to fall on hard times, they will be given one year with one side to try and rebuild and if they can't produce two teams the following season, they won't be playing in the SAAFL.

All other comps have a minimum teams requirement, it's about time we had one too.

No merge required.. agreed...My post wasn't about Blackwood rather my viewpoint to YOPK's comment to you "if a club has only (1) team they can't play ammos or can they play in a C grade comp"?...

[cracka]

Probably because everyone agrees it's fair enough.

Mind you if we want to debate the measurements on how we determine whether or not side will have two teams in February.... then I'm all ears.

So it's fair enough for SAAFL to do it but not HFL or is it fair enough for both comps to do it.

[Q.]

Probably because everyone agrees it's fair enough.

Mind you if we want to debate the measurements on how we determine whether or not side will have two teams in February.... then I'm all ears.

So it's fair enough for SAAFL to do it but not HFL or is it fair enough for both comps to do it.

Totally different scenarios. S/C want to field two senior teams, but HFL has forced them to play with only one.

[cracka]

Probably because everyone agrees it's fair enough.

Mind you if we want to debate the measurements on how we determine whether or not side will have two teams in February.... then I'm all ears.

So it's fair enough for SAAFL to do it but not HFL or is it fair enough for both comps to do it.

Totally different scenarios. S/C want to field two senior teams, but HFL has forced them to play with only one.

Want to & being able to are 2 different things, I'm sure the 4 SAAFL clubs under the pump want to fill 2 sides also. S/C don't fit the requirements of fielding junior sides & never have the whole time they've been in the HFL.

[Old Dog New Tricks]

Probably because everyone agrees it's fair enough.

Mind you if we want to debate the measurements on how we determine whether or not side will have two teams in February.... then I'm all ears.

So it's fair enough for SAAFL to do it but not HFL or is it fair enough for both comps to do it.

I might have missed a previous post or two but who said it isn't fair for the HFL to do it ?

[cracka]

Probably because everyone agrees it's fair enough.

Mind you if we want to debate the measurements on how we determine whether or not side will have two teams in February.... then I'm all ears.

So it's fair enough for SAAFL to do it but not HFL or is it fair enough for both comps to do it.

I might have missed a previous post or two but who said it isn't fair for the HFL to do it ?

See HFL Country div thread.

[Ye Olde Place Kick]

Blackwood have 2 other teams in another comp Cohiiba, do you really think they need to merge?

No, they just need to make up their friggin minds as to which comp they want to play in.

They've had their one year, they can't have their cake and eat it too.

Ye old Place Kick - new rules state that clubs must have 2 sides, if they happen to fall on hard times, they will be given one year with one side to try and rebuild and if they can't produce two teams the following season, they won't be playing in the SAAFL.

All other comps have a minimum teams requirement, it's about time we had one too.

thanks

[marbles]

is there no allowance for blackwood to just put their Cgrade in C1?

[adr107]

Will Flinders Uni be fielding two teams this year? Any updates on them so far?

[finn]

is there no allowance for blackwood to just put their Cgrade in C1?

That doesn't address the one side question though. The safe would need to spell out the reasons as to why one team only is acceptable for Blackwood and not Wingfield for example. This opens a can of worms.

[norm11]

Will Flinders Uni be fielding two teams this year? Any updates on them so far?

I'm under the understanding that a few teams have until the 15 th of feb to rego 55 players.

[morell]

55 now? Jeez it keeps going up

[adr107]

55 now? Jeez it keeps going up

I thought it was always 55 registered players for the clubs that need to provide proof?