Ch9 AFL Division 5 - 2015

[Footy Chick]

Fire away.

[Look Good In Leather]

What was consensus on that North Haven King Hit?

[Q.]

What was consensus on that North Haven King Hit?

Was more of a Queen hit.

[Dogwatcher]

Wrong thread

[twobob]

What was consensus on that North Haven King Hit?

Was more of a Queen hit.

Hasn't this been gone over enough

[Look Good In Leather]

OKC "That is 100% king hit. Sometimes it can be out of character for the person to do, but in the end, has to be penalised. Mind you the tribunal system is so laughable, surprised they got this one right in relation to penalty."

The tribunal system needs to be looked at seriously. They are so inconsistant. I wouldn't say they got this one about right as they someone else 6 matches for spitting.

6 for spitting and only one more for a king kit (didn't see it - only going by what I have heard and read). Neither act has any place in any sport.

Other thing I don't understand is how some get a reduced penalty for being a good boy at the tribunal. If two people are found guilty of the same offence in similar situations they should get the same penalty. If one co-operates with the tribunal and one pays up at the tribunal the later should get an extra penalty, not reduce the first's penalty.

Seems to be the case in most leagues, tribunals are inconsistent.

[mighty hounds]

BOS vs CBC for the first time out of the school comp. Be good to watch.

[Dogwatcher]

OKC "That is 100% king hit. Sometimes it can be out of character for the person to do, but in the end, has to be penalised. Mind you the tribunal system is so laughable, surprised they got this one right in relation to penalty."

The tribunal system needs to be looked at seriously. They are so inconsistant. I wouldn't say they got this one about right as they someone else 6 matches for spitting.

6 for spitting and only one more for a king kit (didn't see it - only going by what I have heard and read). Neither act has any place in any sport.

Other thing I don't understand is how some get a reduced penalty for being a good boy at the tribunal. If two people are found guilty of the same offence in similar situations they should get the same penalty. If one co-operates with the tribunal and one pays up at the tribunal the later should get an extra penalty, not reduce the first's penalty.

Seems to be the case in most leagues, tribunals are inconsistent.

Go ask in Div 4.

[Q.]

What was consensus on that North Haven King Hit?

Was more of a Queen hit.

Hasn't this been gone over enough

I just want to break free.

[Pag]

Did the name of the players involved ever get mentioned?

[The Old Fellow]

Thanks for your support Dogwatcher. At least someone read my post and understood what I was referring to. It seems that the ones from NH don't believe it was a king hit or they are too close to it. If the disputed "king hit" doesn't make my comments legit maybe I should have substituted it with "an unprovoked ( by any prior immediate act) targeted ASSAULT on a player off the ball and out of play".

[jo172]

Add head high to the story. They're playing the semantics game with 'king hit' because they're trying to defend what they know to be the indefensible

[superboot7]

NH player who got 7 games got a good result for him I'd say....mate of mine got 8 games and there was no video, no report from any umpire, but got 8 games on a supporters statement who said he saw the alleged hit!! Personally I think a king hit and spitting on a player is deservant of similar games...whilst a hit can be deadly and thatnk god it's unlikely a lot of the time....to spit on someone is the lowest form of human filth. Just my 2 cents

[Lightning McQueen]

What was consensus on that North Haven King Hit?

Was more of a Queen hit.

Hasn't this been gone over enough

I just want to break free.

Are you gonna let it all hang out?

[tkr]

NH player who got 7 games got a good result for him I'd say....mate of mine got 8 games and there was no video, no report from any umpire, but got 8 games on a supporters statement who said he saw the alleged hit!! Personally I think a king hit and spitting on a player is deservant of similar games...whilst a hit can be deadly and thatnk god it's unlikely a lot of the time....to spit on someone is the lowest form of human filth. Just my 2 cents

Absolutely agree with what you said about spitting on someone!

[Boosh]

Thanks for your support Dogwatcher. At least someone read my post and understood what I was referring to. It seems that the ones from NH don't believe it was a king hit or they are too close to it. If the disputed "king hit" doesn't make my comments legit maybe I should have substituted it with "an unprovoked ( by any prior immediate act) targeted ASSAULT on a player off the ball and out of play".

If you substituted it for unprovoked you would be even further from the truth, the WOS player gave the NH player a cheeky one in the stomach and ran off, something he freely admitted when the NH player rang him to apologise.

For 1000th time this does not justify what he did and I thought it was worth 8 games which I have stated previously.

[holdy2323]

HI

[Lightning McQueen]

HI

It worked.

[scottroo]

Colonel Light Gardens would like to welcome Mark Donovan as A grade Assistant coach under Matthew Dent. Mark played 116 games for Glenelg including the 1986 Premiership

[X Runna]

Colonel Light Gardens would like to welcome Mark Donovan as A grade Assistant coach under Matthew Dent. Mark played 116 games for Glenelg including the 1986 Premiership

Building a very formidable team there Scotty