All Australian Team to be announced tonight (16/9/14)

smac · Post by **smac** » Wed Sep 17, 2014 7:19 pm

Perhaps @Dissident could do a poster champs one of those

bennymacca · Post by **bennymacca** » Mon Sep 22, 2014 10:32 pm

priddis leading with 2 rounds to go and they havent even got him in the all australian team.

Jim05 · Post by **Jim05** » Mon Sep 22, 2014 10:41 pm

bennymacca wrote:priddis leading with 2 rounds to go and they havent even got him in the all australian team.

To be fair who does he replace?
Remember this is only the umpires votes, the judges who pick the AA sides dont get it wrong too often

helicopterking · Post by **helicopterking** » Mon Sep 22, 2014 10:41 pm

Rik E Boy wrote:Priddis LOL. Gets a nom for being a consistent player over a long period. Lots of the pill but how effectively did he use it? A strong second half of the season gets him over the line, the same for Ellis. No probs with Ward or Libba's gong.

regards,

REB

Gets a Nod for being the best player in the comp for season 2014 and not selected in this bullshit team.

helicopterking · Post by **helicopterking** » Mon Sep 22, 2014 10:42 pm

Jim05 wrote:
bennymacca wrote:priddis leading with 2 rounds to go and they havent even got him in the all australian team.

To be fair who does he replace?
Remember this is only the umpires votes, the judges who pick the AA sides dont get it wrong too often

Pendlebury

helicopterking · Post by **helicopterking** » Mon Sep 22, 2014 10:43 pm

Rockliff

bennymacca · Post by **bennymacca** » Mon Sep 22, 2014 10:43 pm

heppell lewis pendles rockliff for starters.

obviously helps that there wasnt too many other west coast mids stealing votes off him, but it is quite funny that one poster on here got laughed down for suggesting priddis should be in there (cant remember who)

bennymacca · Post by **bennymacca** » Mon Sep 22, 2014 10:45 pm

most disposals, second most clearances, third most tackles. that is pretty impressive.

afl would also be sighing some relief that fyfe didnt win too

Jim05 · Post by **Jim05** » Mon Sep 22, 2014 10:45 pm

helicopterking wrote:
Rik E Boy wrote:Priddis LOL. Gets a nom for being a consistent player over a long period. Lots of the pill but how effectively did he use it? A strong second half of the season gets him over the line, the same for Ellis. No probs with Ward or Libba's gong.

regards,

REB

Gets a Nod for being the best player in the comp for season 2014 and not selected in this bullshit team.

Best player in the umpires eyes.
If you were picking a side to play tomorrow I would think most people would still pick the guys in the AA over him. One reason the Coaches award and MVP is becoming more popular each year. Reckon they are better judges than the umps

bennymacca · Post by **bennymacca** » Mon Sep 22, 2014 10:49 pm

Jim05 wrote:
helicopterking wrote:
Rik E Boy wrote:Priddis LOL. Gets a nom for being a consistent player over a long period. Lots of the pill but how effectively did he use it? A strong second half of the season gets him over the line, the same for Ellis. No probs with Ward or Libba's gong.

regards,

REB

Gets a Nod for being the best player in the comp for season 2014 and not selected in this bullshit team.

Best player in the umpires eyes.
If you were picking a side to play tomorrow I would think most people would still pick the guys in the AA over him. One reason the Coaches award and MVP is becoming more popular each year. Reckon they are better judges than the umps

thats the problem with the AA team though, it seems to be picked on who is the best player, not who has the best season. first disposals, second clearances, third tackles, that shits all over pendles this year. of course pendles is a better player but thats not the point.

i agree with that last bit, but i wonder the last time that the brownlow medal winner wasnt selected in the AA team?

helicopterking · Post by **helicopterking** » Mon Sep 22, 2014 10:51 pm

His stats don't lie. Well Deserved.

helicopterking · Post by **helicopterking** » Mon Sep 22, 2014 10:54 pm

bennymacca wrote:
Jim05 wrote:
helicopterking wrote:
Rik E Boy wrote:Priddis LOL. Gets a nom for being a consistent player over a long period. Lots of the pill but how effectively did he use it? A strong second half of the season gets him over the line, the same for Ellis. No probs with Ward or Libba's gong.

regards,

REB

Gets a Nod for being the best player in the comp for season 2014 and not selected in this bullshit team.

Best player in the umpires eyes.
If you were picking a side to play tomorrow I would think most people would still pick the guys in the AA over him. One reason the Coaches award and MVP is becoming more popular each year. Reckon they are better judges than the umps

thats the problem with the AA team though, it seems to be picked on who is the best player, not who has the best season. first disposals, second clearances, third tackles, that shits all over pendles this year. of course pendles is a better player but thats not the point.

i agree with that last bit, but i wonder the last time that the brownlow medal winner wasnt selected in the AA team?

Correct, picked on reputation, not season performance.

Jim05 · Post by **Jim05** » Mon Sep 22, 2014 10:55 pm

Amazing season by GAJ, misses a third of the season and only just misses out.

Brodlach · Post by **Brodlach** » Mon Sep 22, 2014 10:56 pm

bennymacca wrote:
Jim05 wrote:
helicopterking wrote:
Rik E Boy wrote:Priddis LOL. Gets a nom for being a consistent player over a long period. Lots of the pill but how effectively did he use it? A strong second half of the season gets him over the line, the same for Ellis. No probs with Ward or Libba's gong.

regards,

REB

Gets a Nod for being the best player in the comp for season 2014 and not selected in this bullshit team.

Best player in the umpires eyes.
If you were picking a side to play tomorrow I would think most people would still pick the guys in the AA over him. One reason the Coaches award and MVP is becoming more popular each year. Reckon they are better judges than the umps

thats the problem with the AA team though, it seems to be picked on who is the best player, not who has the best season. first disposals, second clearances, third tackles, that shits all over pendles this year. of course pendles is a better player but thats not the point.

i agree with that last bit, but i wonder the last time that the brownlow medal winner wasnt selected in the AA team?

Ask Bruce I'm sure he would know. I would like to know the stat of how many stats he gave out tonight

kickinit · Post by **kickinit** » Mon Sep 22, 2014 10:58 pm

Brownlow is becoming less of a award each year. Priddis had a very good year and deserved to win it. But Gray no way near it, who was clearly our best player for the year. Dangerfield shouldn't even been close. Coaches award and MVP becoming the main awards.

bennymacca · Post by **bennymacca** » Mon Sep 22, 2014 10:58 pm

Jim05 wrote:Amazing season by GAJ, misses a third of the season and only just misses out.

correct, he would have smashed it otherwise.

Jim05 · Post by **Jim05** » Mon Sep 22, 2014 10:59 pm

helicopterking wrote:
bennymacca wrote:
Jim05 wrote:
helicopterking wrote:
Gets a Nod for being the best player in the comp for season 2014 and not selected in this bullshit team.

Best player in the umpires eyes.
If you were picking a side to play tomorrow I would think most people would still pick the guys in the AA over him. One reason the Coaches award and MVP is becoming more popular each year. Reckon they are better judges than the umps

thats the problem with the AA team though, it seems to be picked on who is the best player, not who has the best season. first disposals, second clearances, third tackles, that shits all over pendles this year. of course pendles is a better player but thats not the point.

i agree with that last bit, but i wonder the last time that the brownlow medal winner wasnt selected in the AA team?

Correct, picked on reputation, not season performance.

Agree to some extent about the AA but how do you explain the Coaches Award or MVP where Priddis didnt finish top 5 in either?

bennymacca · Post by **bennymacca** » Mon Sep 22, 2014 11:01 pm

kickinit wrote:Brownlow is becoming less of a award each year. Priddis had a very good year and deserved to win it. But Gray no way near it, who was clearly our best player for the year. Dangerfield shouldn't even been close. Coaches award and MVP becoming the main awards.

i was definitely surprised danger was so close. definitely the sort of player that the umps will give 3 every time he plays well though.

but given how he polls, he only needs to get half consistent (or play in a melbourne team :shock:

) and he will win a brownlow

Jim05 · Post by **Jim05** » Mon Sep 22, 2014 11:04 pm

bennymacca wrote:
kickinit wrote:Brownlow is becoming less of a award each year. Priddis had a very good year and deserved to win it. But Gray no way near it, who was clearly our best player for the year. Dangerfield shouldn't even been close. Coaches award and MVP becoming the main awards.

i was definitely surprised danger was so close. definitely the sort of player that the umps will give 3 every time he plays well though.

but given how he polls, he only needs to get half consistent (or play in a melbourne team ) and he will win a brownlow

FYI Benny no player from a Melbourne side polled in the top half a dozen

daysofourlives · Post by **daysofourlives** » Mon Sep 22, 2014 11:05 pm

bennymacca wrote:
Jim05 wrote:
helicopterking wrote:
Rik E Boy wrote:Priddis LOL. Gets a nom for being a consistent player over a long period. Lots of the pill but how effectively did he use it? A strong second half of the season gets him over the line, the same for Ellis. No probs with Ward or Libba's gong.

regards,

REB

Gets a Nod for being the best player in the comp for season 2014 and not selected in this bullshit team.

Best player in the umpires eyes.
If you were picking a side to play tomorrow I would think most people would still pick the guys in the AA over him. One reason the Coaches award and MVP is becoming more popular each year. Reckon they are better judges than the umps

thats the problem with the AA team though, it seems to be picked on who is the best player, not who has the best season. first disposals, second clearances, third tackles, that shits all over pendles this year. of course pendles is a better player but thats not the point.

i agree with that last bit, but i wonder the last time that the brownlow medal winner wasnt selected in the AA team?

The last time was Woewodin in 2000

All Australian Team to be announced tonight (16/9/14)

Re: All Australian Team to be announced tonight (16/9/14)

Re: All Australian Team to be announced tonight (16/9/14)

Re: All Australian Team to be announced tonight (16/9/14)

Re: 2014 AFL All Australian Team

Re: All Australian Team to be announced tonight (16/9/14)

Re: All Australian Team to be announced tonight (16/9/14)

Re: All Australian Team to be announced tonight (16/9/14)

Re: All Australian Team to be announced tonight (16/9/14)

Re: All Australian Team to be announced tonight (16/9/14)

Re: All Australian Team to be announced tonight (16/9/14)

Re: All Australian Team to be announced tonight (16/9/14)

Re: All Australian Team to be announced tonight (16/9/14)

Re: All Australian Team to be announced tonight (16/9/14)

Re: All Australian Team to be announced tonight (16/9/14)

Re: All Australian Team to be announced tonight (16/9/14)

Re: All Australian Team to be announced tonight (16/9/14)

Re: All Australian Team to be announced tonight (16/9/14)

Re: All Australian Team to be announced tonight (16/9/14)

Re: All Australian Team to be announced tonight (16/9/14)

Re: All Australian Team to be announced tonight (16/9/14)

Who is online