SAAFL division 6 2014

[carey]

How have the playing group taken it carey? Any walked away? Or has it made everyone more determined?

A bit of a mix of emotions mate. There was a genuine belief by the playing group that we were a chance to sneak in the 5 and that would've been a huge reward for some hard work. Numbers at training have been good, The playing group is very strong and really close knit so I would say the overall feeling is more disappointment than anything else.

For 1 individuals stupidity it's cost the whole group would I'm almost certain will have the ramafications of lost friendships and as we've already seen deregistration from the club his played his whole life at and banned from playing there for life.

My honest feelings are that feel so sorry for the great group of young lads that train there ass off every night to play finals football for that chance to be taking away from something out of there control seems really unfair to me.

So I can only answer for me but mine would be Anger and Dissapointment.

[marbles]

How have the playing group taken it carey? Any walked away? Or has it made everyone more determined?

A bit of a mix of emotions mate. There was a genuine belief by the playing group that we were a chance to sneak in the 5 and that would've been a huge reward for some hard work. Numbers at training have been good, The playing group is very strong and really close knit so I would say the overall feeling is more disappointment than anything else.

For 1 individuals stupidity it's cost the whole group would I'm almost certain will have the ramafications of lost friendships and as we've already seen deregistration from the club his played his whole life at and banned from playing there for life.

My honest feelings are that feel so sorry for the great group of young lads that train there ass off every night to play finals football for that chance to be taking away from something out of there control seems really unfair to me.

So I can only answer for me but mine would be Anger and Dissapointment.

do u have an alternative penalty that doesnt penalise those who do well by the league & the club

because one man's hot headed UFC aspirations, has destroyed the livelihood of volunteers, reserves, agraders, parents and girlfriends and all their efforts put into every day of this season, and all is now scorned by some wanker, who if he performed the same action on the streets, would be behind bars?

and even the sponsors of the club, who were so hard to come by across several seasons, now scorned.

[Roaring Lion!]

Central United play hard but are a very disciplined unit of young blokes so it's sad to see that from the actions of 1 x loose cannon have cost them their season & any chance of playing finals this year but this will make the playing group hungry for success next season.
Harsh penalty seeing the huge improvement out there but guess this a huge warning to all clubs that bad behaviour is being cracked down on with heavy consequences & all coaches have to look out for their playing groups & remove these types of players from the ground for a rest before they get tired as that's when frustration boils over which now hurts your whole club.

[Roaring Lion!]

Congratulations to Fitzroy's Captain Brad Keast on game 100 against Mitchell Park tomorrow.

Will be a big day at the Roy's with the 10 x year Premiership reunion for the the Reserves three-peat premiership '02/'03/'04 sides.

Followed by the one of the biggest nights of the year with annual running of the Mouse Cup.

[Phantom Gossiper]

I don't understand why 9 points Carey? What does deducting 9 points achieve?

Units needed to win every game to make the 5 in both grades, if you are going to deduct points why not say 2 or 3 so it makes it impossible for them to qualify and just miss - surely that would sting more?

Angle Vale won't win a game, Central United will beat Mitchell Park, at worst Units win 2 more games and still finish 7th so relegation is extremely unlikely so why bother imposing such a severe penalty?

Are there not other penalties that could be imposed that would hurt more? Stupid penalty that really potentially could've caused more harm than good - If it did cause Central United to get relegated they would dominate D7 but more importantly on the flip side it would mean a side like Mitchell Park whose struggled and trying to rebuild would be stuck in D6 again - this time with two grand finalists coming up!

Tribunal go home you're drunk!

[carey]

The player received 9 games hence losing the 9 points.

[Arch44]

Congratulations to Fitzroy's Captain Brad Keast on game 100 against Mitchell Park tomorrow.

Will be a big day at the Roy's with the 10 x year Premiership reunion for the the Reserves three-peat premiership '02/'03/'04 sides.

Followed by the one of the biggest nights of the year with annual running of the Mouse Cup.

Also cricketers day at the footy.

[Phantom Gossiper]

Also cricketers day at the footy.

Can't wait for cricket season!

[marbles]

i dont agree with the penalty i think they earnt those wins fair & square, victories are mini trophies in history and u wouldnt come along and smash your sons trophies if he did wrong

future matches should be forfieted

an alternative idea could be like the afl points system...

if a player gets 4 weeks, the whole club has to forfiet all of their matches on the next upcoming Saturday

if a player gets 6 weeks, that means the club has 2 carry over points, meaning the next offense will only require 2 weeks for another full day club suspension

ie: 1 week suspension = 1 quarter forfieted for the whole club

[human_torpedo]

I always just thought that the suspension to the player was the punishment? Why are we trying to find a punishment for the punishment? The onus should be on the club to deal with the player if further action is required for repeat offenders.. If incidents get out of control, then by all means put the club on notice, but that should only be in extreme cases, shouldnt be across the board for all clubs

[Q.]

^^^ these clubs have conditions placed upon their affiliation this year. They're aware of these sanctions.

[human_torpedo]

Im not saying they werent, or even disagreeing with the sanctions, it was more of a response to the idea of a league wide ruling.. No issue with clubs having sanctions placed upon them for repeat issues.. I do feel for Carey and CUFC though, it sounds like alot of hard work has been put in this season to turn the club around, and the actions of one bloke has cost them any chance of a finals spot, and put them right back to square one..

[The Old Fellow]

What sort of player and person is Bain? Has he been made to front the player group or better still volunteer to front the player group and apologise to them for his actions and stuffing up their season and rep or does he believe he is the victim for being banned? It would be a tough penalty to front your peers and admit your guilt (if you are sincere about it).

[Mr Beefy]

Any scores, Rosies knocked off the farmers

[mighty hounds]

Any scores, Rosies knocked off the farmers

Bos by 31

[UK Fan]

Lockleys by 7 goals over mawson lakes.

[wassprinttospace]

Any scores, Rosies knocked off the farmers

Well that makes round 17 more interesting.

[Phantom Gossiper]

Rosies came to play today! Both grades amazing pressure and intensity, they wanted it more and duly got the reward.

In the B grade the pressure and tackling from Rosewater was incredible, their tackles stuck and they made them count, by a long way the toughest game the Ingle Farm B grade have played in a few years - had a finals like intensity about it. To be honest it was like playing a mirror image of ourselves.. We went to war today with Rosies, and football was the winner.. Look forward to meeting them in the finals, should be a beeeeeeauty..

[S Demon]

Rosies came to play today! Both grades amazing pressure and intensity, they wanted it more and duly got the reward.

In the B grade the pressure and tackling from Rosewater was incredible, their tackles stuck and they made them count, by a long way the toughest game the Ingle Farm B grade have played in a few years - had a finals like intensity about it. To be honest it was like playing a mirror image of ourselves.. We went to war today with Rosies, and football was the winner.. Look forward to meeting them in the finals, should be a beeeeeeauty..

Incorrect. Rosies were the winners

[Phantom Gossiper]

Rosies came to play today! Both grades amazing pressure and intensity, they wanted it more and duly got the reward.

In the B grade the pressure and tackling from Rosewater was incredible, their tackles stuck and they made them count, by a long way the toughest game the Ingle Farm B grade have played in a few years - had a finals like intensity about it. To be honest it was like playing a mirror image of ourselves.. We went to war today with Rosies, and football was the winner.. Look forward to meeting them in the finals, should be a beeeeeeauty..

Incorrect. Rosies were the winners

Yeah that too