Round 12 - live scores, results & gas bagging.

[carey]

Dees by 1 point at 1/4 Time

Melbourne seem reluctant to go forward. Gee they've improved out of sight tho I haven't really seen them at all this year till today.

[Q.]

This is horrible to watch.

[woodublieve12]

Lance cleared

[Jim05]

Lance cleared

And rightly so, just a good hard hit.
Common sense sees Myers get off aswell.
Vickery gets 2 and Matt Thomas 1.
Ballantyne referred directly to tribunal for his hit on Jaensch. Was a great hit and a good decision to send it to the tribunal as with his record he would of got 3 with the points system, hopefully the tribunal chucks it out, not worth a free kick let alone a game

[the joker]

Nathan jones has had 15 touches in 14 minutes In the third qtr


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[Jim05]

Pies getting their usual armchair ride. Melbourne robbed of atleast 2 certain goals courtesy of blatant cheating by 1 umpire in particular

[carey]

Watts simply has to kick them. That's a shocking miss

[Jim05]

Right on cue another soft free kick goal to Collingwood

[mighty_tiger_79]

lingy commentary is priming for an assistant with roos

[gadj1976]

it's a shocking game to have as a standalone game. Melbourne, 3 goals. I mean, come on....

[Fricky]

Lance cleared

And rightly so, just a good hard hit.
Common sense sees Myers get off aswell.
Vickery gets 2 and Matt Thomas 1.
Ballantyne referred directly to tribunal for his hit on Jaensch. Was a great hit and a good decision to send it to the tribunal as with his record he would of got 3 with the points system, hopefully the tribunal chucks it out, not worth a free kick let alone a game

Both Ballantyne's and Buddy's bumps were great BUT going on the rules of today that head high contact is not tolerated then Buddy should be going to the MRP and Ballantyne should get off. The MRP continues to confuse things more for players, coaches and supporters.

[daysofourlives]

Lance cleared

Put him in a Hawthorn guernsey and he gets one. (or any other guernsey apart from a Swans one)
There was no difference between this hit and the one on Malceski last year, apart from the squealing by Malceski and the Swans.

Don't get me wrong I think it was a fair bump and the right decision has been made this time.

[jackpot jim]

Lance cleared

Put him in a Hawthorn guernsey and he gets one. (or any other guernsey apart from a Swans one)
There was no difference between this hit and the one on Malceski last year, apart from the squealing by Malceski and the Swans.

Don't get me wrong I think it was a fair bump and the right decision has been made this time.

Fair bump?
How the hell do you figure that?
Chose to bump and got him in the head.
Reckless, careless, unnecessary, does it every week and the MRP continue to look the other way.
Absolute FARCE the MRP are, bordering on corrupt !

[whufc]

Lance cleared

Put him in a Hawthorn guernsey and he gets one. (or any other guernsey apart from a Swans one)
There was no difference between this hit and the one on Malceski last year, apart from the squealing by Malceski and the Swans.

Don't get me wrong I think it was a fair bump and the right decision has been made this time.

Fair bump?
How the hell do you figure that?
Chose to bump and got him in the head.
Reckless, careless, unnecessary, does it every week and the MRP continue to look the other way.
Absolute FARCE the MRP are, bordering on corrupt !

Yep there right up there with the likes of FIFA and the Olympics Committee.

Always looking from a financial point of view rather than fairness and equality.

[kickinit]

I seriously don't get MRP. What it comes down to is how injuries the players is which is absolute crap. I fully agree with trying to cut out the head high contact. There is always going to be accidental head clashes, but there are head clashes which thankfully don't cause injury but have the potential to. I don't see how a accidental head clash gets you sent straight to the tribunal and shoulder to the head gets off. I'm glad the MRP isn't in the court of law, if someone tried to commit murder and didn't succeed they would let them off to do it again.

[carey]

Whilst I agree with that Kickinit I also think it matters who the player is. We can't have Buddy or Goodes out now can we

Should've got at least sighted and with his record 1 week. Purely on the MRP's 2014 record

[kickinit]

Whilst I agree with that Kickinit I also think it matters who the player is. We can't have Buddy or Goodes out now can we

Should've got at least sighted and with his record 1 week. Purely on the MRP's 2014 record

It sure does. I really hope Freo go to the tribunal with the buddy footage and ask the question how can a intentional bump get off over a accidental head clash.

[woodublieve12]

I thought you lot would want lance to play. You guys have had enough luck with players out from top 4 sides

[carey]

We need them out that's the only reason were top remember.

As a fellow poster on here highlighted

[woodublieve12]

Whilst I agree with that Kickinit I also think it matters who the player is. We can't have Buddy or Goodes out now can we

Should've got at least sighted and with his record 1 week. Purely on the MRP's 2014 record

probably have to do something wrong first...