Kurt Tippett's playing future?

[The Sleeping Giant]

Think they might know what they are doing at Sydney.

[dedja]

Track record is OK ...

[daysofourlives]

I wouldnt rule out Carlton, Fremantle or Brisbane just yet. i hope Brisbane takes him and he never plays finals football again

[woodublieve12]

yes, dumb faarkers ...

crows cheated, haven't won a flag since 98, choked in finals since... hired shaw as a coach, picked up tambling, wasted it's time on carey. a betting scandal, blokes wanting to get out of there.. etc etc etc...

Yeah and we're the dumb ones!!

[dedja]

you forget to mention ... Here we go, here we go Camry Crows

In all seriousness, I can't see how Tippet would be embraced by the great culture at the Swans, plus he's not worth anywhere near the money, but good luck to them if they pick him up.

[Baron Greenback]

I wouldnt rule out Carlton, Fremantle or Brisbane just yet. i hope Brisbane takes him and he never plays finals football again

Thats a bit rough on the lions mate

[Turbo]

I wouldnt rule out Carlton, Fremantle or Brisbane just yet. i hope Brisbane takes him and he never plays finals football again

Definitely wont be going to us. He's not worth half he's asking

[gutterboy]

let him go to the swans the over rated spud.....i'm a mutual supporter who enjoys watching the game...but him putting a price tag on his head like he will be would be a joke....he would never be in a class like ablett sr...lockett or dunstall...the guys a joke...at his age now he isnt near as half as good as those guys...good luck to who ever want to spend the dollars on a spud !!!!

[Pup]

let him go to the swans the over rated spud.....i'm a mutual supporter who enjoys watching the game...but him putting a price tag on his head like he will be would be a joke....he would never be in a class like ablett sr...lockett or dunstall...the guys a joke...at his age now he isnt near as half as good as those guys...good luck to who ever want to spend the dollars on a spud !!!!

Whoever said he was as good as Ablett or Lockett or Dunstall?

[gutterboy]

let him go to the swans the over rated spud.....i'm a mutual supporter who enjoys watching the game...but him putting a price tag on his head like he will be would be a joke....he would never be in a class like ablett sr...lockett or dunstall...the guys a joke...at his age now he isnt near as half as good as those guys...good luck to who ever want to spend the dollars on a spud !!!!

Whoever said he was as good as Ablett or Lockett or Dunstall?

no one....but why put a pice tag on his head when he isn't clearly as half as good as those guys when they wre running around....ablett snr would be worth the money tippett is asking...he could turn a game on his head...!!!

[Rik E Boy]

Think they might know what they are doing at Sydney.

Nah. Tippett won't destroy your club culture at all. You don't even need him. It's hard enough to go back to back without introducing Cancer to your club.

regards,

REB

[Rik E Boy]

I wouldnt rule out Carlton, Fremantle or Brisbane just yet. i hope Brisbane takes him and he never plays finals football again

If he was five or six years older he'd have gone to Hawthorn.

regards,

REB

[The Sleeping Giant]

Think they might know what they are doing at Sydney.

Nah. Tippett won't destroy your club culture at all. You don't even need him. It's hard enough to go back to back without introducing Cancer to your club.

regards,

REB

True, but the only thing he did wrong was sign a shonky contract, then expect it to be fulfilled by the other party. Other than that, he has hardly been a "bad person".

[mighty_tiger_79]

i wonder how the oldies behind the goals feel about their club and tippo

[woodublieve12]

Think they might know what they are doing at Sydney.

Nah. Tippett won't destroy your club culture at all. You don't even need him. It's hard enough to go back to back without introducing Cancer to your club.

regards,

REB

True, but the only thing he did wrong was sign a shonky contract, then expect it to be fulfilled by the other party. Other than that, he has hardly been a "bad person".

agreed..... could be a handy inclusion in the later half of the season for a a tilt at back to back . him and reid up forward could be very dangerous. plus chuck in morton, goodes and some of the swans small forwards... plus he can help in the ruck... if none of this crows/tippett ordeal and just went to the swans on a normal trade happened, everyone wouldn't be carrying on and would say it's a decent pick up!!!

[CoverKing]

You have changed your tune WUB12. As soon as he mentioned he wanted Sydney, you were not happy at all. Saying he is overrated and everything. Couple weeks on and this now? surely you don't need him. I seriously can't believe he is going to the Swans (the reigning premiers) and is going to be the highest paid player. I think this could definitely effect the clubs culture

[woodublieve12]

You have changed your tune WUB12. As soon as he mentioned he wanted Sydney, you were not happy at all. Saying he is overrated and everything. Couple weeks on and this now? surely you don't need him. I seriously can't believe he is going to the Swans (the reigning premiers) and is going to be the highest paid player. I think this could definitely effect the clubs culture

i still think he's overrated and think we dont need him... over payed and as ive said to someone the other day, if or when he comes to the club i'll have to look at the positives. nothing i can do about it... BUT i would love to see him do good only to piss off the crows supporters ... im sticking to the point that the swans have a great record of turning some troublesome players or players struggle at other clubs to good footballs. i.e lockett, hall, mattner, shaw just to name a few... so im hoping our record continues...

[daysofourlives]

Think they might know what they are doing at Sydney.

Nah. Tippett won't destroy your club culture at all. You don't even need him. It's hard enough to go back to back without introducing Cancer to your club.

regards,

REB

Not that hard to go back to back REB, Hawks 88-89, Crows 97-98, Lions 01-02-03, all the great teams of the last 25 years have done it.
Throw in the dogs 00-01, 03-05, 07-10.
Perhaps a more accurate statement would be its hard enough for your teams to go back to back

[Psyber]

True, but the only thing he did wrong was sign a shonky contract, then expect it to be fulfilled by the other party.
Other than that, he has hardly been a "bad person".

Well he was hardly honest and innocent himself, despite his current claims.
He did say that the driving issue was wanting to go home to Qld, then later decide Sydney was "home"...

[daysofourlives]

I wouldnt rule out Carlton, Fremantle or Brisbane just yet. i hope Brisbane takes him and he never plays finals football again

If he was five or six years older he'd have gone to Hawthorn.

regards,

REB

We already got the Crows best forward and he's 5 or 6 years younger than Tippet