Club Best and Fairest Winners 2012

[Jim05]

Nathan Jones won Melbourne's Best and Fairest, Jack Grimes was runner up

[Baron Greenback]

Brock Mclean would be my pick.

Yep McLean for me too.
Haven't been too many guns that have played every game, so even though he missed some early, his 2nd half of the season has been outstanding.

[JK]

Brock Mclean would be my pick.

Yep McLean for me too.
Haven't been too many guns that have played every game, so even though he missed some early, his 2nd half of the season has been outstanding.

Seems to be the story for Carlton .. Judd, Murphy, Carazzo, McLean all played well but had chunks where they missed games or performed below expectation .. Simpson and Scotland seemed fairly consistent.

[beef]

i would think Scotland, maybe Eddie Betts to do ok as well. Very open field, probably sums up season. Not enough good performances

[Media Park]

2012 Melbourne best and fairest - total votes
1 - Nathan Jones (368)
2 - Jack Grimes (348)
3 - Tom McDonald (314)
4 - Jordie McKenzie (312)
5 - Jared Rivers (310)

MIDFIELDER Jordie McKenzie has won his third consecutive coach’s award - the Norm Smith Memorial Trophy.
Second year Demon Tom McDonald gained the Harold Ball Memorial Trophy for the best young player, which was previously for best first year player until changed this season.
Co-captain Jack Grimes received his second consecutive Ron Barassi Jnr Trophy (leadership award), which was also shared this year with fellow skipper Jack Trengove.
Ruckman Max Gawn, who missed the entire 2012 season with a knee injury, was awarded the Ian Ridley Memorial Trophy (club ambassador award) for his work in the community.
Rookie Tom Couch, who came runner up in this year’s Liston Trophy (the Brownlow Medal equivalent in the VFL), accepted the Troy Broadbridge Memorial Trophy for the most votes attained by a Melbourne-listed player in Casey’s best and fairest.

[Squids]

Tom Couch = superstar.

[beef]

Carlton B&F Result

1 - Heath Scotland 362 votes
2 - Eddie Betts 353
3 - Chris Judd 334
4 - Brock Mclean 321
5 - Marc Murphy 299
6 - Andrew Carrazzo 287
7 - Kade Simpson 229
8 - Bryce Gibbs 228
9 - Mitch Robinson 205
10 - Matthew Kruezer 163

[beef]

Essendon winner Jobe Watson (no surprise), runner up Dyson Heppell

[Jim05]

Essendon winner Jobe Watson (no surprise), runner up Dyson Heppell

Won the Crichton by a country mile.

[Jim05]

Tom Hawkins won the Cats B&F narrowly over Joel Selwood, Corey Enright 3rd

[Brodlach]

Dayne Beams wins the Copeland from Pendles and Swan

[RustyCage]

Scott Selwood wins WC B+F
Kennedy wins Sydneys B+F

[Brodlach]

Scott Thompson beat Dangerfirld for the Crows

[Baron Greenback]

Crowley wins freo b&f

[The Dark Knight]

Sam Mitchell won the Hawks 2012 best and fairest, his forth club champion medal and second in a row. Brad Sewell came second, Grant Birchall third and Luke Breust forth.

[Media Park]

Updated list, only Kangaroos (14th November) missing.

[Akkoland]

Carlton B&F Result

1 - Heath Scotland 362 votes
2 - Eddie Betts 353
3 - Chris Judd 334
4 - Brock Mclean 321
5 - Marc Murphy 299
6 - Andrew Carrazzo 287
7 - Kade Simpson 229
8 - Bryce Gibbs 228
9 - Mitch Robinson 205
10 - Matthew Kruezer 163

Good effort by McLean. I reckon he was about $1.05 to be delisted 6 months ago.

[beef]

Nth Melb finally had their B&F last Night

Swallow - 60 votes
S. Thompson - 49 votes
Harvey - 45 votes.

Swallow 3rd B&F win i think

[David Brent]

Nth Melb finally had their B&F last Night

Swallow - 60 votes
S. Thompson - 49 votes
Harvey - 45 votes.

Swallow 3rd B&F win i think

Harvey third? Are you kidding me surely they had better players than him this year

[Baron Greenback]

Nth Melb finally had their B&F last Night

Swallow - 60 votes
S. Thompson - 49 votes
Harvey - 45 votes.

Swallow 3rd B&F win i think

Harvey third? Are you kidding me surely they had better players than him this year

Thought Wells might've made top 3.