AFL Preliminary Finals - Live scores and discussion

[am Bays]

I don't bash umpires but for me this says a lot

ImageUploadedByTapatalk1348351231.316688.jpg

Bwa ha ha ha

All due respect to Michael, I wouldn't be using him as justification for perceived poor umpiring.

Maybe Willo, or SplinterDick but not the son of Ding Dong.

[smac]

I don't bash umpires but for me this says a lot

ImageUploadedByTapatalk1348351231.316688.jpg

That was his review from the last match he umpired.

[hearts on fire]

Worst game i've seen Hawthorn play this year yesterday, Crows played well but if they replayed the game today or any other day, the Crows wouldn't of even got close.

[woodublieve12]

Has Buddy been reported or sighted for his shirt front???

[stampy]

Mr 66 would know about footy Karma after all the biggest footy karma in the history of the AFL is the sacking of John Coleman. Credit to where it's due from experience....

do u mean norm smith?

[the joker]

I don't bash umpires but for me this says a lot

ImageUploadedByTapatalk1348351231.316688.jpg

That was his review from the last match he umpired.

Probably.

[TEX07]

Has Buddy been reported or sighted for his shirt front???

You wish It would be the worst decision if he was, nothing in it at all.

[Brodlach]

Excellent game of footy, just not quite the correct result for me
Got to be proud of the way Adelaide played, absolutely played out of their skin. Didn't think they would get that close.

Sick of hearing about umpires, if we were good enough we would have won

[daysofourlives]

Mumford have any carry over points?

[Jim05]

Mumford have any carry over points?

What exactly did he do?
No TV footage of incident but they will check out the behind goals camera view.
Has been charged with misconduct over an incident with Dawes, some media are reporting that he was trying to knock Dawes' injured knee

[woodublieve12]

Has Buddy been reported or sighted for his shirt front???

You wish It would be the worst decision if he was, nothing in it at all.

Thug, should at least get 1 for it...

[woodublieve12]

Mumford have any carry over points?

What exactly did he do?
No TV footage of incident but they will check out the behind goals camera view.
Has been charged with misconduct over an incident with Dawes, some media are reporting that he was trying to knock Dawes' injured knee

Nothing in it... They spoke on game day, said he'd be fine

[Johno6]

He should atleast get 1

[woodublieve12]

He should atleast get 1

won't happen...

[daysofourlives]

Mumford have any carry over points?

What exactly did he do?
No TV footage of incident but they will check out the behind goals camera view.
Has been charged with misconduct over an incident with Dawes, some media are reporting that he was trying to knock Dawes' injured knee

You can see Mumford move his lower leg in the direction of Dawes legs, wether he was trying to knee his leg or stomp on his foot i dont know.
Worst case scenario would be the standard 93 pts for early plea, hence if he has carry over pts could be worrying times for him

[Magpiespower]

You can see Mumford move his lower leg in the direction of Dawes legs, wether he was trying to knee his leg or stomp on his foot i dont know.
Worst case scenario would be the standard 93 pts for early plea, hence if he has carry over pts could be worrying times for him

Mumford is safe.

Refer to "The Dunkley Precedent."

No Swans player can be rubbed out for a GF...

[Johno6]

Mumford Is a dirty player
Does it every game
Should get 1 maybe 2

















Just stirring.....

[Jim05]

You can see Mumford move his lower leg in the direction of Dawes legs, wether he was trying to knee his leg or stomp on his foot i dont know.
Worst case scenario would be the standard 93 pts for early plea, hence if he has carry over pts could be worrying times for him

Mumford is safe.

Refer to "The Dunkley Precedent."

No Swans player can be rubbed out for a GF...

True, just ask Barry Hall

[LaughingKookaburra]

Saw both games and if any player gets suspended for any incident I'd be horrified.

I really think the mrp needs an overhaul and umpires need to be given more control over reports not a bunch of old pricks who think they know the game. If we are serious about player safety we'd have all players wearing helmets, shin guards and padded vests. I swear the only reason these blokes make changes is because if they left things alone they wouldn't have a job.
I agree about deliberate malice and suspending blokes but 1 week suspensions should not exist. If its bad then put them out of the game for 2 plus, **** the carryover points system treat every case on its Merritt's. If its a minor offence make the player pay a fine to their grass roots club.

[woodublieve12]

You can see Mumford move his lower leg in the direction of Dawes legs, wether he was trying to knee his leg or stomp on his foot i dont know.
Worst case scenario would be the standard 93 pts for early plea, hence if he has carry over pts could be worrying times for him

Mumford is safe.

Refer to "The Dunkley Precedent."

No Swans player can be rubbed out for a GF...

True, just ask Barry Hall

A west coast player was reported too that year and I what he did was worse then hall