dedja wrote:Some mixed messages on the street for this one ... same say conspiracy, others have mention the grassy knoll , and then there's the magic bullett.
He clearly knocked himself out by running into the invisible tree branch that haunts the bay oval. Justin McConnel used to trip over it all the time. Only Backwell could see it - he was always ducking under it.
That no one has seen the incident (or not professing to have seen it), that Kirk himself hasn't come out and said what happened (which you would think he would if it was an accident) or any other player for that matter, we are just going to have to accept that it was a football collision and move on, however hard it is to believe that you can have such a football collision 50m away from the play.
'PAFC don't want any advantages in the SANFL. It would only take away from any achievements we earned.' Keith Thomas ABC 891 Radio, 21/6/14.
CUTTERMAN wrote:That no one has seen the incident (or not professing to have seen it), that Kirk himself hasn't come out and said what happened (which you would think he would if it was an accident) or any other player for that matter, we are just going to have to accept that it was a football collision and move on, however hard it is to believe that you can have such a football collision 50m away from the play.
Perhaps Kirky has come out and spoken to people at Sturt. He's definitely told Glenelg what happened. The information I have heard was it was nothing more then a football collision and that's it.
In the mean time, keep thinking about the conspiracies, and keep assassinating Kirky's character.
Nothing better then assuming a bloke is guilty of "thuggery" when you have no evidence of such.
The joy of being on the hill drinking beer cannot be understated
CUTTERMAN wrote:That no one has seen the incident (or not professing to have seen it), that Kirk himself hasn't come out and said what happened (which you would think he would if it was an accident) or any other player for that matter, we are just going to have to accept that it was a football collision and move on, however hard it is to believe that you can have such a football collision 50m away from the play.
Perhaps Kirky has come out and spoken to people at Sturt. He's definitely told Glenelg what happened. The information I have heard was it was nothing more then a football collision and that's it.
In the mean time, keep thinking about the conspiracies, and keep assassinating Kirky's character.
Nothing better then assuming a bloke is guilty of "thuggery" when you have no evidence of such.
Where have I put forward a conspiracy theory, when have I assassinated his character? I've basically just pointed out that there is no real evidence either way and that we have to accept that it is a football collision, remembering that most football collisions happen reasonably near the ball. So have another read and just admit that your wrong. then if you're big enough you can give me an apology
'PAFC don't want any advantages in the SANFL. It would only take away from any achievements we earned.' Keith Thomas ABC 891 Radio, 21/6/14.
whufc wrote:Obviously the Glenelg bloke did something, footballers dont go off on a stretcher with a suspected broken jaw and neck injuries through thin air. Maybe it was in retaliation maybe it wasnt. No footage and no 100% witnesses caught the incident so the bloke can not be suspended on pure speculation. Worse thing for the Glenelg bloke is KARMA has a very funny way of catching up with people, it may not happen this week, next week or in a years time but karma tends to bite most people on the a..... sorry bottom.
There have been numerous incidents on sports fields where an injury occurs without there being a reportable incident to cause it.
I can't believe that without anyone seeing the incident, a player's reputation is affected and is tarnished to being known as "a thug".
I would have thought the Sturt Cheer Squad would have had a good view? It happened at their end of the ground? Surely another Sturt player would have remonstrated straight away if a vicious act occurred.
No-one from the Sturt FC wants to take it any further, so why do some posters on here? I would have expected any Sturt supporter from the crowd who could be a witness, would have put their hand up by now. It's obvious there isn't any evidence to back up an act of violence occurred.
Should this be a topic for the 'Conspiracy Theory Lover's Thread?"
well, well, well, no-one has bothered to respond to you 85wagy, and why am i not surprised? it just goes to show what a bunch of trash talking pied piper following imbeciles all of these nitwits are, none of them have a clue what happened yet are screaming for blood on the basis of what?
as for you cutterman, how the hell do you know what daniel kirk has or hasnt done to clear his name since saturday??? you dont have a ******* clue, all of you are a disgrace
Perhaps Kirky has come out and spoken to people at Sturt. He's definitely told Glenelg what happened. The information I have heard was it was nothing more then a football collision
If it does not break any confidence, please elaborate on what he has told Glenelg. I am finding it hard to imagine a football collision that could occur in the circumstances described. I am dead against any behind the play acts that tarnish our competition. I am left a little disappointed that the league have put their heads in the sand and release a statement along the lines of "we have no footage and we have not really tried to find out what happened therefore we don't have any evidence and can't proceed". The SANFL should be doing more to provide an answer about what occurred.
SJABC wrote: Perhaps Kirky has come out and spoken to people at Sturt. He's definitely told Glenelg what happened. The information I have heard was it was nothing more then a football collision and that's it.
In the mean time, keep thinking about the conspiracies, and keep assassinating Kirky's character.
Nothing better then assuming a bloke is guilty of "thuggery" when you have no evidence of such.
Wouldn't matter if Kirk told GFC Officials that he deliberately took out Wundke, they were hardly going to hand him up and he isn't going to certainly admit anything to the opposing club or SANFL now is he? "Football collision" is another way of saying Kirk got lucky!
whufc wrote:Obviously the Glenelg bloke did something, footballers dont go off on a stretcher with a suspected broken jaw and neck injuries through thin air. Maybe it was in retaliation maybe it wasnt. No footage and no 100% witnesses caught the incident so the bloke can not be suspended on pure speculation. Worse thing for the Glenelg bloke is KARMA has a very funny way of catching up with people, it may not happen this week, next week or in a years time but karma tends to bite most people on the a..... sorry bottom.
There have been numerous incidents on sports fields where an injury occurs without there being a reportable incident to cause it.
I can't believe that without anyone seeing the incident, a player's reputation is affected and is tarnished to being known as "a thug".
I would have thought the Sturt Cheer Squad would have had a good view? It happened at their end of the ground? Surely another Sturt player would have remonstrated straight away if a vicious act occurred.
No-one from the Sturt FC wants to take it any further, so why do some posters on here? I would have expected any Sturt supporter from the crowd who could be a witness, would have put their hand up by now. It's obvious there isn't any evidence to back up an act of violence occurred.
Should this be a topic for the 'Conspiracy Theory Lover's Thread?"
well, well, well, no-one has bothered to respond to you 85wagy, and why am i not surprised? it just goes to show what a bunch of trash talking pied piper following imbeciles all of these nitwits are, none of them have a clue what happened yet are screaming for blood on the basis of what?
as for you cutterman, how the hell do you know what daniel kirk has or hasnt done to clear his name since saturday??? you dont have a ******* clue, all of you are a disgrace
Kirk obviously hasn't done much to clear his name as far as the Sturt footy club are concerned.
CUTTERMAN wrote:Where have I put forward a conspiracy theory, when have I assassinated his character? I've basically just pointed out that there is no real evidence either way and that we have to accept that it is a football collision, remembering that most football collisions happen reasonably near the ball. So have another read and just admit that your wrong. then if you're big enough you can give me an apology
Go back and read the thread. You insinuated Kirky was a sniper.
As for the rest of my post I was actually referring to the other Sturt posters on here not you.
The joy of being on the hill drinking beer cannot be understated
CUTTERMAN wrote:Where have I put forward a conspiracy theory, when have I assassinated his character? I've basically just pointed out that there is no real evidence either way and that we have to accept that it is a football collision, remembering that most football collisions happen reasonably near the ball. So have another read and just admit that your wrong. then if you're big enough you can give me an apology
Go back and read the thread. You insinuated Kirky was a sniper.
As for the rest of my post I was actually referring to the other Sturt posters on here not you.
You're an idiot. I have never insinuated Kirk was a sniper, you in your paranoia have interpreted that. If anything I've suggested that the whole thing be forgotten about. That's it, I'm not going to argue with such a tool as yourself, I'm right, your wrong, I'm cool and you're a tool!
'PAFC don't want any advantages in the SANFL. It would only take away from any achievements we earned.' Keith Thomas ABC 891 Radio, 21/6/14.
Although there may be nothing in the incident in the wash up, the Glenelg supporters here would probably react the same way if they saw one of their players hospitalised.
Don't let me get in the way of the flying off handles though. Seems like an interesting hobby.
CUTTERMAN wrote:Where have I put forward a conspiracy theory, when have I assassinated his character? I've basically just pointed out that there is no real evidence either way and that we have to accept that it is a football collision, remembering that most football collisions happen reasonably near the ball. So have another read and just admit that your wrong. then if you're big enough you can give me an apology
Go back and read the thread. You insinuated Kirky was a sniper.
As for the rest of my post I was actually referring to the other Sturt posters on here not you.
banging your head against a brick wall like me jabber i'm afraid.
All the informed ones who think they know what happened should ring 82714611 ask duane massey sturts footy ops manager for his thoughts on the matter
CUTTERMAN wrote:Where have I put forward a conspiracy theory, when have I assassinated his character? I've basically just pointed out that there is no real evidence either way and that we have to accept that it is a football collision, remembering that most football collisions happen reasonably near the ball. So have another read and just admit that your wrong. then if you're big enough you can give me an apology
Go back and read the thread. You insinuated Kirky was a sniper.
As for the rest of my post I was actually referring to the other Sturt posters on here not you.
banging your head against a brick wall like me jabber i'm afraid.
All the informed ones who think they know what happened should ring 82714611 ask duane massey sturts footy ops manager for his thoughts on the matter
It's already clear what Mass thinks by the lack of further action.
Barto wrote:Although there may be nothing in the incident in the wash up, the Glenelg supporters here would probably react the same way if they saw one of their players hospitalised.
Don't let me get in the way of the flying off handles though. Seems like an interesting hobby.
Mate we did following Saturdays game, we just aren't banging on about it. Fortunately he didn't need to be to admitted.
Let that be a lesson to you Port, no one beats the Bays five times in a row in a GF and gets away with it!!!
then if you're big enough you can give me an apology 
