The Chris Judd 'they got off light' award

[Q.]

And Enright popped out a little nugget

[Media Park]

Sherman for mine as well.

[Adelaide Hawk]

you can only be found guilty of staging if there is no contact made. Monfries clearly made contact with Lewis, even though it was very minimal

No contact at all? So, if you get a slight nudge, you're entitled to propel yourself across the ground as if you've been shot out of a cannon? I thought that was what the new rule was supoosd to weed out. Totally mystifying ... but then again most things that happen in AFL these days are.

I'm not being argumentative, I really want to understand it.

[Rik E Boy]

And Enright popped out a little nugget

No that was Varcoe.

regards,

REB

[Q.]

And Enright popped out a little nugget

No that was Varcoe.

regards,

REB

I reckon he's just making sure he gets to his upcoming wedding unscathed. The missus will crack the shits if he ends up like Jono

[NO-MERCY]

There was word today Doctors are worried about permanent brain damage with Brown.
Just how much footy has this bloke got left in him?
It wouldn't surprise me an early retirements not far away.

[The Sleeping Giant]

Punch drunk?

[Jim05]

There was word today Doctors are worried about permanent brain damage with Brown.
Just how much footy has this bloke got left in him?
It wouldn't surprise me an early retirements not far away.

Thats not good. Has to start thinking of his family and his health.
Hope he recovers soon

[CoverKing]

you can only be found guilty of staging if there is no contact made. Monfries clearly made contact with Lewis, even though it was very minimal

No contact at all? So, if you get a slight nudge, you're entitled to propel yourself across the ground as if you've been shot out of a cannon? I thought that was what the new rule was supoosd to weed out. Totally mystifying ... but then again most things that happen in AFL these days are.

I'm not being argumentative, I really want to understand it.

I thought the same AH but heard an interview with Anderson after monfries confirmed he staged for it. Anderson was quick to rule out him getting fined because there was contact! Confusing ay

[stan]

This is an award to recognise the lucky bastards out there who like Chris Judd have walked away thinking 'that could have been a lot worse!'

The 2011 nominees for the Chris Judd 'they got off light' award are

- Angus Monfries for hardly copping any stick after his pathetic dive cost Jordan Lewis matches
- Joel Corey for getting off scott free after doing a sling tackle when everyone in the league has been going for weeks
- The Collingwood football club for not having to leave Victoria until Round 19
- Heath Shaw for being allowed to play finals football this year. What were the odds on that?
- Justin Sherman for only copping four games for being a racist arsehole
- Travis Varcoe for not been slagged mercilessly after the biggest squib I've seen on a footy field for many in a year in a match where Jonathon Brown showed what real courage is


I vote for Sherman. He got off very light for mine.

regards,

REB

And for collingwood I think one of the interstate trips are against Port at AAMI, seriously.........

[Turbo]

This should be 'the Chris Judd is a living legend award'

[Media Park]

This should be 'the Chris Judd is a living legend award'

But Turbo, like Carlton's B&F count for the next five or six years, The Juddernaut would be the only bugger to win it...

[Rik E Boy]

This should be 'the Chris Judd is a living legend award'

regards,

REB

[Turbo]

Now it's 'the Chris Judd got another 3 brownlow votes' award

[Booney]

Pretty certain REB is going to really enjoy Brownlow night.

[Jim05]

Pretty certain REB is going to really enjoy Brownlow night.

Let him have his Brownlow sucess, id much rather be in REB's shoes and celebrate club sucess over an individual prize

[Rik E Boy]

Pretty certain REB is going to really enjoy Brownlow night.

Let him have his Brownlow sucess, id much rather be in REB's shoes and celebrate club sucess over an individual prize

Judging but what I've seen over the past few weeks the Carlton fans might have more to be happy about come the end of the year. A Brownlow is better than yet another Grand Final loss and that's if we play well in September. IMO Collingwood can't be beaten.

regards,

REB

[Q.]

Anyone can be beaten, especially in finals footy.

[Rik E Boy]

Anyone can be beaten, especially in finals footy.

Don't get me wrong, it's yours to lose and I hope you do....maybe I should have said IMO Collingwood won't be beaten.

regards,

REB

[mighty_tiger_79]

Anyone can be beaten, especially in finals footy.

Don't get me wrong, it's yours to lose and I hope you do....maybe I should have said IMO Collingwood won't be beaten.

regards,

REB

spot on

the pies are home n hosed for this years flag

i just hope if the cats are in it, we are competitive