trade week 2010 Oct 5-11

[CoverKing]

Thank god Tambling wants a move. We should've done it two years ago.

he has been pretty good for us considering his injuries IMO.
Last year when Jade came in he played some bloody good footy! I just think he will be a superstar in a good side simply cause he is a front runner!

Still hurts we didn't get Franklin tho

[cossi11]

Thank god Tambling wants a move. We should've done it two years ago.

he has been pretty good for us considering his injuries IMO.
Last year when Jade came in he played some bloody good footy! I just think he will be a superstar in a good side simply cause he is a front runner!

Still hurts we didn't get Franklin tho

But we got Jack! he will be better than Tambling and Franklin put together...

[Booney]

Thank god Tambling wants a move. We should've done it two years ago.

he has been pretty good for us considering his injuries IMO.
Last year when Jade came in he played some bloody good footy! I just think he will be a superstar in a good side simply cause he is a front runner!

Still hurts we didn't get Franklin tho

BWAHAHAHA - "he has been pretty good for us"......Oh thats GOLD CK.

This trade week ,more than any other, will be a case of better the devil you know. If clubs trade for a bloke now and find he is a dud by mid-2011 they are stuck with him for another year until the GWS is out of the way of the drafts.

Always thought this one would be more smoke and mirrors than any other draft period.

[CoverKing]

Not just football wise I meant tho Booney! He has had a massive influence in the indigenous program that tigers are/have set up!

[clanger]

as usual the first day nothing happen expect the father/son selections. I reckon no more than three trades will be done in the first three days. the clubs will all rush in the last three days.

[Booney]

Not just football wise I meant tho Booney! He has had a massive influence in the indigenous program that tigers are/have set up!

Yep, he has helped such players as.....um. Of course there is.....err......their names just escape me at the moment.

[CoverKing]

Not just football wise I meant tho Booney! He has had a massive influence in the indigenous program that tigers are/have set up!

Yep, he has helped such players as.....um. Of course there is.....err......their names just escape me at the moment.

Maybe you should learn what the program at Richmond does for young indigenous kids before you pass judgement!

[brod]

According to Sportal.com.au

ON THE TABLE
Jonathon Griffin (Adelaide)
Jared Brennan (Brisbane)
Justin Sherman (Brisbane)
Mitch Clark (Brisbane)
Sam Jacobs (Carlton)
Andrew Walker (Carlton)
Shaun Grigg (Carlton)
Bret Thornton (Carlton)
Setanta O'hAilpin (Carlton)
John Anthony (Collingwood)
Josh Fraser (Collingwood)
Paul Medhurst (Collingwood)
Leon Davis (Collingwood)
Ricky Dyson (Essendon)
Brent Stanton (Essendon)
Brent Prismall (Essendon)
Andrew Welsh (Essendon)
Sam Lonergan (Essendon)
Leroy Jetta (Essendon)
Chris Tarrant (Fremantle)
Mark Blake (Geelong)
Ryan Gamble (Geelong)
Nathan Djerrkura (Geelong)
Trent West (Geelong)
Beau Dowler (Hawthorn)
Cameron Bruce (Melbourne)
David Hale (North Melbourne)
Gavin Urquhart (North Melbourne)
Leigh Harding (North Melbourne)
Chad Cornes (Port Adelaide)
Daniel Motlop (Port Adelaide)
Richard Tambling (Richmond)
Will Thursfield (Richmond)
David Armitage (St Kilda)
Raphael Clarke (St Kilda)
Patrick Veszpremi (Sydney)
Ed Barlow (Sydney)
Matt O'Dwyer (Sydney)
Daniel Currie (Sydney)
Matt Spangher (West Coast)
Ben McKinley (West Coast)
Daniel Kerr (West Coast)
Josh Hill (Western Bulldogs)
Brennan Stack (Western Bulldogs)
Andrejs Everitt (Western Bulldogs)

[tigerland09]

According to Sportal.com.au

ON THE TABLE
Jonathon Griffin (Adelaide)
Jared Brennan (Brisbane)
Justin Sherman (Brisbane)
Mitch Clark (Brisbane)
Sam Jacobs (Carlton)
Andrew Walker (Carlton)
Shaun Grigg (Carlton)
Bret Thornton (Carlton)
Setanta O'hAilpin (Carlton)
John Anthony (Collingwood)
Josh Fraser (Collingwood)
Paul Medhurst (Collingwood) Retired
Leon Davis (Collingwood)
Ricky Dyson (Essendon)
Brent Stanton (Essendon) Re-signed
Brent Prismall (Essendon)
Andrew Welsh (Essendon)
Sam Lonergan (Essendon)
Leroy Jetta (Essendon) Re-signed
Chris Tarrant (Fremantle)
Mark Blake (Geelong)
Ryan Gamble (Geelong)
Nathan Djerrkura (Geelong)
Trent West (Geelong)
Beau Dowler (Hawthorn)
Cameron Bruce (Melbourne)
David Hale (North Melbourne)
Gavin Urquhart (North Melbourne)
Leigh Harding (North Melbourne)
Chad Cornes (Port Adelaide)
Daniel Motlop (Port Adelaide)
Richard Tambling (Richmond)
Will Thursfield (Richmond)
David Armitage (St Kilda)
Raphael Clarke (St Kilda)
Patrick Veszpremi (Sydney)
Ed Barlow (Sydney)
Matt O'Dwyer (Sydney)
Daniel Currie (Sydney)
Matt Spangher (West Coast)
Ben McKinley (West Coast)
Daniel Kerr (West Coast)
Josh Hill (Western Bulldogs)
Brennan Stack (Western Bulldogs)
Andrejs Everitt (Western Bulldogs)

[whufc]

what would happen if a club traded a player to another club, but that player had actually signed for the Gold Coast but hadnt informed anyone as yet.

[Voice]

what would happen if a club traded a player to another club, but that player had actually signed for the Gold Coast but hadnt informed anyone as yet.

The trade would happen via the players manager and therefore wouldn't go ahead as the manager wouldn't be able to agree to terms.

[the big bang]

what would happen if a club traded a player to another club, but that player had actually signed for the Gold Coast but hadnt informed anyone as yet.

The trade would happen via the players manager and therefore wouldn't go ahead as the manager wouldn't be able to agree to terms.

another different question, using paul medhurst as an example......

what if we traded meddy back to freo for chris tarrant, then the day after it's all finalized and a done deal, meddy retired. obviously he would forfeit all future pay and whatnot, but would there be a single thing Freo could do about it, as it would mean they basically gave Taz away for nothing.

[The Riddler]

Latest news from yesterday

http://www.afl.com.au/news/newsarticle/ ... fault.aspx

[Strawb]

Nathan Djerrkura for Brent Primsall would work for me.

[Gingernuts]

Looks like a deal to bring Tambling to Adelaide is close, it's just hanging on the Jacobs deal. Unlike others I think Tambling has talent that he is still yet to realise and perhaps a change of environment will do that. Worth the punt I reckon.

Jacobs - if Carlton want to play hard ball, I say tell them to get stuffed. We'll take our chances in the pre-season draft and if we still don't get him, I don't reckon it's the end of the world. IMO Sellar showed a bit at the end of last year, McKernan is a talent that deserves a chance and Moran is handy also if he can get his body right.

Will be interesting to see how things develop as the week goes on.

[JK]

Looks like a deal to bring Tambling to Adelaide is close, it's just hanging on the Jacobs deal. Unlike others I think Tambling has talent that he is still yet to realise and perhaps a change of environment will do that. Worth the punt I reckon.

Completely agree.

[Voice]

what would happen if a club traded a player to another club, but that player had actually signed for the Gold Coast but hadnt informed anyone as yet.

The trade would happen via the players manager and therefore wouldn't go ahead as the manager wouldn't be able to agree to terms.

another different question, using paul medhurst as an example......

what if we traded meddy back to freo for chris tarrant, then the day after it's all finalized and a done deal, meddy retired. obviously he would forfeit all future pay and whatnot, but would there be a single thing Freo could do about it, as it would mean they basically gave Taz away for nothing.

The AFL would investigate the circumstances and would compensate Freo accordingly, probably in the next seasons draft.

[D14]

Looks like a deal to bring Tambling to Adelaide is close, it's just hanging on the Jacobs deal. Unlike others I think Tambling has talent that he is still yet to realise and perhaps a change of environment will do that. Worth the punt I reckon.

Jacobs - if Carlton want to play hard ball, I say tell them to get stuffed. We'll take our chances in the pre-season draft and if we still don't get him, I don't reckon it's the end of the world. IMO Sellar showed a bit at the end of last year, McKernan is a talent that deserves a chance and Moran is handy also if he can get his body right.

Will be interesting to see how things develop as the week goes on.

I also agree. In a new environment I think Tambling has the potential to shine and I would also prefer to give McKernan game time instead of Jacobs. DO NOT want to lose McKernan for lack of oppertunities. I don't know much about Walker but unless he has a truck load of pace I wouldn't bother.

[Pat Malone]

I think Adelaide and Richmond have more or less agreed to swap Tambling for their Bock pick but will not finalise this deal until Jacobs deal is done. Carlton want this pick for Jacobs although the Crows have offered up their second round pick, which sits at 32 (before the compensation picks are considered). I think the crows will need to offer this pick as well as a swap of pick 14 for Carlton's 18 to get this deal completed.

Bulldogs appear to be falling out of the race for Walker as they have lost thier first 2 picks and look likely to offer their compensation pick to Brisbane in exchange for Sherman. The crows will hold their first round draft pick, meaning that the most they can give up for Walker is pick 49 (which becomes mid 50's after compensation pick) unless they can get something earlier for Griffin.

If Adelaide were to get all 3 players and lose Griffin for a draft pick then we would have 5 spots on the senior list with at least 2 rookie upgrades (Jaensch and Henderson) so a maximum of 3 draft picks including the PSD.

[X Runna]

Looks like a deal to bring Tambling to Adelaide is close, it's just hanging on the Jacobs deal. Unlike others I think Tambling has talent that he is still yet to realise and perhaps a change of environment will do that. Worth the punt I reckon.

Jacobs - if Carlton want to play hard ball, I say tell them to get stuffed. We'll take our chances in the pre-season draft and if we still don't get him, I don't reckon it's the end of the world. IMO Sellar showed a bit at the end of last year, McKernan is a talent that deserves a chance and Moran is handy also if he can get his body right.

Will be interesting to see how things develop as the week goes on.

Looked pretty good in the Bay's finals campaign too - NOT.