Who was a better footballer?

[tiger07andbeyond]

Gary McIntosh or Mark Naley?

[Mr Beefy]

McIntosh

[on the rails]

Why? You couldn't get two more contrasting styles and types of players to compare so how do you really judge a very subjective question?

[baggy8]

otr's right, but the answer's McIntosh

[GWW]

I agree with the above too. Would probably be more appropriate to compare McIntosh to Chris McDermott, Alan Stringer and maybe even Andrew Jarman, whilst Naley is better compared alongside Platten and McGuinness.

[rd]

I vote for McIntosh ahead of Naley but Naley gets my vote ahead of Phil Gallagher (just in case that topic ever starts up !)

[Wedgie]

McIntosh then daylight, then more daylight, then more daylight, then more daylight, then more daylight, then more daylight, then Naley, maybe.

[darley16]

The comparison is wrong but having witnessed much of Naley's career and his VFL/AFL performance with Carlton and continual status of being amoungst best palyers in Sate of Origin i would still say McIntosh (that fooled ya ) but not by much. Both champions but as i say a wrong comparison.

[FlyingHigh]

Roger Woodcock

[CK]

McIntosh easily but as many have said, two completely different styles. It's like comparing Dean Howard with Scott Bamford.

[rogernumber10]

Roger Woodcock

Here's a bloke who knows his stuff.

[dedja]

Stephen Copping ...

[robranisgod]

Naley

[JK]

Both champions but as i say a wrong comparison.

Perfectly said

[Ian]

Both champions but as i say a wrong comparison.

Perfectly said

agree, very different footballers, would love to have had either at North

BTW, Naley is the new assistant coach at Lockleys this year