Seth Efrica Tour Squad announced

[Dutchy]

What about Jacques? Shafted.....

Very happy McGain got a gig...

[brod]

What about Jacques? Shafted.....injured - what form?

Very happy McGain got a gig...

[GWW]

I would have picked Rogers before Jacques. Jacques has no recent form whatsoever to base picking him on.

[hearts on fire]

I would have picked Klinger before Rogers and Jacques...... I personally think Rogers is over-rated.

[Rik E Boy]

What about Jacques? Shafted.....

Very happy McGain got a gig...

Jaques couldn't 'back up' Dutchman.

regards,

REB

[Rik E Boy]

So perhaps it was W Robinson or are the selectors lost in space.

It may have been the selectors' "will". These comments may be a little outdated for some of our younger posters

No 'danger' of selecting a decent squad eh?

regards,

REB

[Dutchy]

I would have picked Rogers before Jacques. Jacques has no recent form whatsoever to base picking him on.

might have to look at his last test innings lads?

[GWW]

Nah i'll look at his most recent first class innings. If it was last test innings i'd be wanting Greg Chappell in the side.

[wycbloods]

I would have picked Rogers before Jacques. Jacques has no recent form whatsoever to base picking him on.

might have to look at his last test innings lads?

Whilst i agree with you dutchy am i correct in saying that was over 12 months ago?

Jaques was certainly ahead of Rogers he needs to make 1300 runs a season to be a sniff IMO

[rod_rooster]

What about Jacques? Shafted.....

Very happy McGain got a gig...

Not sure Jaques was shafted. He would still be very much in the minds of the selectors but he has only just returned, he didn't make any runs and he pulled up sore. Too big a risk for this tour. He will get another chance at some stage i'm sure.

[GWW]

Thats it. He needs runs on the board before getting back in the side. Can't be selected on form from a year ago.

[rod_rooster]

How much do you really take out of ODI form.

Very very little ... if any at all.

Spot on.

[ORDoubleBlues]

Klinger should have been picked if it's going on current form

[panther]

So perhaps it was W Robinson or are the selectors lost in space.

It may have been the selectors' "will". These comments may be a little outdated for some of our younger posters

No 'danger' of selecting a decent squad eh?

regards,

REB

A warning warning for this dangerous precedent.

Just put your thinking cap on, had W Robinson played in a test match in South Africa imagine this dismissal
W Robinson c Smith b Harris


And better still if he plays the last domestic shield game against new south wales this season
this dismissal
W Robinson c D Smith !!!

[Rik E Boy]

You space Cadet panther.

regards,

REB

[Dutchy]

Nah i'll look at his most recent first class innings. If it was last test innings i'd be wanting Greg Chappell in the side.

they didnt look at that when putting Roy back in the side

with a bit of luck Katich will be out and Jacques in before too long

[rod_rooster]

Nah i'll look at his most recent first class innings. If it was last test innings i'd be wanting Greg Chappell in the side.

they didnt look at that when putting Roy back in the side

with a bit of luck Katich will be out and Jacques in before too long

You'll need a lot of luck cos Katich has been making a lot of runs whilst not many others have. He isn't going anywhere for a while yet Dutchy.

[GWW]

Nah i'll look at his most recent first class innings. If it was last test innings i'd be wanting Greg Chappell in the side.

they didnt look at that when putting Roy back in the side

They didn't but they should have. Up there with the worst selection decisions ever made.

[Adelaide Hawk]

W Robinson c Smith b Harris

Will Robinson, c. Dr.Smith, b. Jonathan Harris?