Best S.C.A player ever

[wineflyonthewall]

..

[smithy]

Great idea winefly but 10 of those people wouldn't even make the top 50 let alone greatest ever.

I'll give you my greatest side in batting order.
Heavily influenced by people that have played the last 35 years.

Greg Dowsett
Ken Bermingham
Dale Champion
Darren Thorpe
Dave Green
John Hopkins
Mick Fitzgerald
Jim Curtis
Travis Bahr
Paul Kinnear
Peter McPherson

[MrTeach]

Great idea winefly but 10 of those people wouldn't even make the top 50 let alone greatest ever.

I'll give you my greatest side in batting order.
Heavily influenced by people that have played the last 35 years.

Greg Dowsett
Ken Bermingham
Dale Champion
Darren Thorpe
Dave Green
John Hopkins
Mick Fitzgerald
Jim Curtis
Travis Bahr
Paul Kinnear
Peter McPherson

Hey Smithy i do not know many of the listed players but i do know Greg Dowsett is he the guy who was involved with the juniors at the stingrays for a while.

[Saint]

Travis Gordon???

[shoe boy]

Great idea winefly but 10 of those people wouldn't even make the top 50 let alone greatest ever.

I'll give you my greatest side in batting order.
Heavily influenced by people that have played the last 35 years.

Greg Dowsett
Ken Bermingham
Dale Champion
Darren Thorpe
Dave Green
John Hopkins
Mick Fitzgerald
Jim Curtis
Travis Bahr
Paul Kinnear
Peter McPherson

Smithy I think W/fly had tongue in cheek? I will have a crack but am sure there will be worthy players that miss out.
John Roberts
Dave Green
Dale Champion
John Hopkins
Mick Irvine
Darren Thorpe
Graham Baggs
Peter Baker w/k
Travis Bahr
Peter Mcpherson
Paul Kinnear
Not a bad line up with a lot of all rounders

[lion heart]

Why isnt Leon "Pegs" Hanson on this list?

[cyclops]

The wk in the side must have been pretty f##n good,coz there was a bloke by the name of Scott Lambert use to go ok.

[cyclops]

My vote went too pannunzio,D.PANNUNZIO.

[Diddy]

Best side of the last 10 years:

Marty Clifton (FH/Noar)
Richard Gabb (Rey)
Dale Champion (Cove)
John Hopkins (Rey)
Rhys Allard (SR)
Mick Irvine (Noar)
Mark Boes (Pt Noar)
Marcus Thorpe (Kang)
Travis Bahr (Cove/FH/Noar)
Roger Ross (Kang/SR)
Grant Francis (Rey)

12th man - Brett Swain (Kang)

Very luck to have been mentioned earlier in this thread - Travis Gordon (Kang), Dean Pannunzio (MV)

[heyyouinthebushes!]

how can you have marcus thorpe in the best team for the last 10 year, if your going to pick a keeper you cant go past moose from Noarlunga and if you pick him more as a batsmanyou pick allard to do it.Then you can pick an alrounder perhaps a greg bolton from sullies or a comer to goin that spot.

[heyyouinthebushes!]

Did you mean paul dean as the other two are hacks, no flaggies so michael will miss out on 2 hundred runs this year and gary will miss out on 10 wickets.

[Diddy]

how can you have marcus thorpe in the best team for the last 10 year, if your going to pick a keeper you cant go past moose from Noarlunga and if you pick him more as a batsmanyou pick allard to do it.Then you can pick an alrounder perhaps a greg bolton from sullies or a comer to goin that spot.

Thorpe has mad two A grade centuries, don't think moose has. There also has to be someone there to keep the egoes of all the others in check.

[2008 premiers]

surely gary bilney has to get a mention as one of the best cricketers in the sca of the past 30 - 40 years, scored several thousand runs and still performing well in his 50's

[shoe boy]

What about this side!
K Wood P/N
M Stewart Cove
A Bubner S/R
N Sinclair P/N
J Colo N
Thomas (cove bowler)
R Ross S/R
J Frush S/R
Patto P/N
J Piggins N
T (ive been playing my last year for the last 6) Trebbelcock P/N
CAPT Patto now woulnt they be fun to watch?

[Bag The Points]

What about this side!
K Wood P/N
M Stewart Cove
A Bubner S/R
N Sinclair P/N
J Colo N
Thomas (cove bowler)
R Ross S/R
J Frush S/R
Patto P/N
J Piggins N
T (ive been playing my last year for the last 6) Trebbelcock P/N
CAPT Patto now woulnt they be fun to watch?

The mind boggles, Shoe Boy, even better with Thommo and K.Irvine umpiring
Wish there was a quality cartoonist around to do an oval scene of it ---- I can picture one player on the boundary giving the crowd "the finger" with the ball at his feet, while the bowler has his nose in the face of a batsman that keeps hitting him for six !

[lion heart]

What about this side!
K Wood P/N
M Stewart Cove
A Bubner S/R
N Sinclair P/N
J Colo N
Thomas (cove bowler)
R Ross S/R
J Frush S/R
Patto P/N
J Piggins N
T (ive been playing my last year for the last 6) Trebbelcock P/N
CAPT Patto now woulnt they be fun to watch?

Nice work SB. Maybe Spike from Sullies could be added to this list.

[Deep Heat]

HA HA HA HA HA NOT A BAD TEAM THOUGH WOULD BE ENTERTAINING TO WATCH

[EB Pie]

Gary Bilney would have to be up there, only seen him at 50+, but still is a gun...

[dill boy]

to shoey and fly i dont know what i have done to upset you blokes but thats cool im not the greatest like you think i am i dont even say such trash but it seems to flow quite nicely when your mouth opens fly

*edited by mods*

[DILLIGAF]

What about dion wakefield he was a better batsman than half the guys mentioned