GSFL Movements

[vics01]

Heard a rumour that Marty Clifton (umpire) is looking to coach in the GSFL in the near future.

[damian]

Does anyone know how many weeks the eye gouger from Willunga got?

[Panther32]

Hey Panther32, I heard a whisper that you might be back in the GSFL next season. Is there any truth to that rumour?

No idea Brock, I will wait to make my decision till early next year depending on my coaching committments. May not play again.

[kappars]

Does anyone know how many weeks the eye gouger from Willunga got?

Shaga got off the red card charge, I dont know the details as yet! He must have shown up wearing red and white the league officals seem to like those colors!

[BJ Ernest]

Does anyone know how many weeks the eye gouger from Willunga got?

Shaga got off the red card charge, I dont know the details as yet! He must have shown up wearing red and white the league officals seem to like those colors!

Painted his face red n white, wore his socks on the outside of his jeans and BAM, hes off.

I heard he pleaded guilty to rough conduct but not guilty to eye gouging. Umpire didnt explain what happened well and he got a reprimand. I didnt see the incident so cant comment but am glad that Shag will be playing this week as the B grade are missing 3-4 key players due to them playing last week in the B grade but not 'qualified' for it. Forgive me if im wrong but surely last Saturday the club picked its best 21 so anyone that played B grade last week should be able to play this week. Does that seem wrong?

[kappars]

Does anyone know how many weeks the eye gouger from Willunga got?

Shaga got off the red card charge, I dont know the details as yet! He must have shown up wearing red and white the league officals seem to like those colors!

Painted his face red n white, wore his socks on the outside of his jeans and BAM, hes off.

I heard he pleaded guilty to rough conduct but not guilty to eye gouging. Umpire didnt explain what happened well and he got a reprimand. I didnt see the incident so cant comment but am glad that Shag will be playing this week as the B grade are missing 3-4 key players due to them playing last week in the B grade but not 'qualified' for it. Forgive me if im wrong but surely last Saturday the club picked its best 21 so anyone that played B grade last week should be able to play this week. Does that seem wrong?

That does seem wrong in theory but if on paper they have not played enough games to qualify for finals in B grade then fair enough, i guess its to stop situations like Willunga now in the A grade GF playen Steve Ryan in the B grade this week to get some match practise or dropping two or three players back to make sure your B grade gets the win and qualifies for the GF.

[King Kernas]

Just on why coaches leave their home club, would it have something to do with there being only one position for a coach at each club (A-grade that is) so if there are 3 or 4 fellas at a club that want to take up coaching, 3 of them would have to look elsewhere, correct? And if they are going to be coaching at another club, they would like some money for their efforts.

Fantastic point Damian. I know someone who loves their club but aspires to be an A grade coach and may have to move clubs to get his opportunity.

Who would that be Mr Teach? A current junior coach at that club?

coach of the year maybe?? what a joke - surely your side has to finish equal or higher than they did the previous yr, and with mclaren 17's being premiers last yr and now they are going to lose 2 compass this week, id hardly call that a successful year!! i'd think you would find most of those kids could coach themselves!!

Jimmy RETARD, youv'e only made 4 posts and sledged clubs or people on every post. Get a brain you idiot, and post something worth reading. Why would the coach of the year this year not be worthy. Coaching the association team this year, still in with a great chance of going back to back with a team of a few good players, hardly say they would be able to coach themselves at colts level. With how close the senior colts were this year, i don't think you could bring ladder position into the equation. Didn't the Mclaren boys give the compass boys a bit of a lesson on how to play good footy when it counted last time they met at Mclarens, can't see them losing a home final this time round mate!

[BJ Ernest]

Does anyone know how many weeks the eye gouger from Willunga got?

Shaga got off the red card charge, I dont know the details as yet! He must have shown up wearing red and white the league officals seem to like those colors!

Painted his face red n white, wore his socks on the outside of his jeans and BAM, hes off.

I heard he pleaded guilty to rough conduct but not guilty to eye gouging. Umpire didnt explain what happened well and he got a reprimand. I didnt see the incident so cant comment but am glad that Shag will be playing this week as the B grade are missing 3-4 key players due to them playing last week in the B grade but not 'qualified' for it. Forgive me if im wrong but surely last Saturday the club picked its best 21 so anyone that played B grade last week should be able to play this week. Does that seem wrong?

That does seem wrong in theory but if on paper they have not played enough games to qualify for finals in B grade then fair enough, i guess its to stop situations like Willunga now in the A grade GF playen Steve Ryan in the B grade this week to get some match practise or dropping two or three players back to make sure your B grade gets the win and qualifies for the GF.

You think last week we are going to jeopardise the A grade side to get 2-3 players back to get the B grade through, I think not. You pick your best 21, then your 2nd best 21 play B grade. If you're qualified for B grade but form suggests you get picked in the A grade then i think you should be allowed to play B grade this week. But when last week you if werent in the 21 for the A grade that says to me you should be able to play this week.
I think you understand what im getting at but rules are rules, we know them at the start of year, im not sure if the club is appealing it or not. Will be a cracker of a game this weekend anyway!

[Mr Magoo]

BJ
re Qualification
All Clubs should know the rules!!!
RULES ARE RULES.

A club can seek permission from the league....which in Willunga's case seems genuine ....so you should try that avenue.

Other option was to lose the A's last week and then there are no problems.

2 games in 4 weeks for you....what has training been like?????
Will you have fresh legs next week or have you been training hard?

[kappars]

Shaga got off the red card charge, I dont know the details as yet! He must have shown up wearing red and white the league officals seem to like those colors! [/quote]

Painted his face red n white, wore his socks on the outside of his jeans and BAM, hes off.

I heard he pleaded guilty to rough conduct but not guilty to eye gouging. Umpire didnt explain what happened well and he got a reprimand. I didnt see the incident so cant comment but am glad that Shag will be playing this week as the B grade are missing 3-4 key players due to them playing last week in the B grade but not 'qualified' for it. Forgive me if im wrong but surely last Saturday the club picked its best 21 so anyone that played B grade last week should be able to play this week. Does that seem wrong?[/quote]

That does seem wrong in theory but if on paper they have not played enough games to qualify for finals in B grade then fair enough, i guess its to stop situations like Willunga now in the A grade GF playen Steve Ryan in the B grade this week to get some match practise or dropping two or three players back to make sure your B grade gets the win and qualifies for the GF.[/quote]

You think last week we are going to jeopardise the A grade side to get 2-3 players back to get the B grade through, I think not. You pick your best 21, then your 2nd best 21 play B grade. If you're qualified for B grade but form suggests you get picked in the A grade then i think you should be allowed to play B grade this week. But when last week you if werent in the 21 for the A grade that says to me you should be able to play this week.
I think you understand what im getting at but rules are rules, we know them at the start of year, im not sure if the club is appealing it or not. Will be a cracker of a game this weekend anyway![/quote]

Yea that makes sense BJ, if they have played 5 games during the year in B grade they should be able to be dropped back at any stage.

[Toughcall]

If you play the majority of the last 5 games in the Reserves then you are qualified for the ressies. It is as simple as that and Willunga should have been able to juggle that with their respective ladder positions approaching the finals.
On the points - Bays are chasing 1 point players Modra, Smart, Rolfe, Hough, West and McLean as they played over 20 games (it could be more) for the club. I think that is the amount a previous player had to play to become 1 point? If you played less then you bring the points associated with that league you are coming from and each year you lose a point.
The problem with the points is that clubs could poach players from within the GSFL, as those players would be more long term than a recruit who travels from Adelaide. It could have the reverse effect of what it is trying to do.

[BJ Ernest]

BJ
re Qualification
All Clubs should know the rules!!!
RULES ARE RULES.

A club can seek permission from the league....which in Willunga's case seems genuine ....so you should try that avenue.

Other option was to lose the A's last week and then there are no problems.

2 games in 4 weeks for you....what has training been like?????
Will you have fresh legs next week or have you been training hard?

Not sure what the clubs doing. Agree that rules are rules so we shall see, we may not pursue it at all.

Trainings been good Magoo. Baz works us hard and as a group weve trained very solidly for the past 6 weeks! 2 weeks off games, needed them to freshen up and will be cherry ripe come GF day. Different ways of getting there but once ur there its all about how u play on the day, the previous weeks results mean nothing!

[LuvsFooty]

How good was the interview with the Langhorne Creek paralympian last night? Came 7th in the 1500m final and all he cared about was saying hello to everyone back at the Creek. He wished the team well for the finals and said that he hopes they roll Willunga! Great interview!

[Mr Magoo]

Re: GSFL Movements
If you play the majority of the last 5 games in the Reserves then you are qualified for the ressies. It is as simple as that and Willunga should have been able to juggle that with their respective ladder positions approaching the finals.
On the points - Bays are chasing 1 point players Modra, Smart, Rolfe, Hough, West and McLean as they played over 20 games (it could be more) for the club. I think that is the amount a previous player had to play to become 1 point? If you played less then you bring the points associated with that league you are coming from and each year you lose a point.
The problem with the points is that clubs could poach players from within the GSFL, as those players would be more long term than a recruit who travels from Adelaide. It could have the reverse effect of what it is trying to do.


Does anyone...Cuzzy know what is happening with the coaching at Encounter Bay?
With the progression of their juniors this year one would think that getting these blokes would be a step backwards.
What is the news from Victor?

Mr Teach..I hear Compass was very dissappointed with the way they played..Didn't work, no run from behind

[Toughcall]

One of the assistants at Victor was interviewed this week for the Bay job.

[A Mum]

Hi People,

Was looking forward to posting a lovely image of a ship shape McLaren oval on here tonight... but will be unable to

Sorry about that !!

You'll just have to wait until Saturday

[Mr Magoo]

Hi People,

Was looking forward to posting a lovely image of a ship shape McLaren oval on here tonight... but will be unable to

Sorry about that !!



A Mum
great idea to post what you are not going to do!!!!!!!

Are you just trying to get us to 500 pages

I am off to make a coffee, have smoke and read the Argus so I can see who they tip to win

[A Mum]

Hi People,

Was looking forward to posting a lovely image of a ship shape McLaren oval on here tonight... but will be unable to

Sorry about that !!



A Mum
great idea to post what you are not going to do!!!!!!!

Are you just trying to get us to 500 pages

I am off to make a coffee, have smoke and read the Argus so I can see who they tip to win

Hey Mr Magoo... leave me alone !!

No, actually I was just following up and being polite in the fact that I said I would do something and now will not be ... and anyway, no need to get to ex amount of pages anymore... admin have already said, as soon as we say the 'word' we can have our own forum page

Enjoy your coffee and reading the Argus... but ditch the smokes

[neverwas neverwillbe]

In regards to the player points system - each player will lose a point each year he plays at the club until he reaches the minimum of one.

If players such as Rolfe were to return to the Bays he would attract the 1 point plus an additional 3 as he has come from another division 1/2 league.

As for someone like Lootsy returning to McLaren, he would be 1 as he played junior football at that club but it could also be argued that he played his last game for Pongy or the Valley and could attract 3 extra points.

One of the main ideas of the points system was to stop GSFL clubs "poaching" from within their own league.

There are a lot of grey areas that can be argued with the league if a club feels they are being "ripped off" as to how many points a player may accumulate.

Are you sure about that? My interpretation of the rule was as long as you have played one whole season at the club you will always come back as a 1 point player?

I am almost 100% positive I am correct.

As I stated above "One of the main ideas of the points system was to stop GSFL clubs "poaching" from within their own league."

I should have added that it was to also stop blokes from chasing money in other leagues and returning when the cash dries up.

Unless the player is a junior from that club he will always attract the maximum points if he leaves and then returns. Further - A player like Lootsy may be an exception as stated above.

Speak with GT from the Creek as he authored the points bible. It's all as clear as mud.

[jackpot jim]

How good was the interview with the Langhorne Creek paralympian last night? Came 7th in the 1500m final and all he cared about was saying hello to everyone back at the Creek. He wished the team well for the finals and said that he hopes they roll Willunga! Great interview!

Michael Roeger is his name.

Didn't see it but am led to believe he was a Very Good footballer (despite his disability) for the Creeks in their Senior Colt Premiership Team a few years back. Had the pleasure of playing a season or two of Table Tennis with him a few years back (was my Doubles partner) and he is just the MOST determined young bloke that i've ever seen and No obstacle seems too big for him to overcome. Well done Roges.