SANFL Slaughter Comp - R6 2008

[smac]

ROUND 6
Saturday May 3
- Eagles v Sturt @ Thebarton
- North v South @ Prospect
- Port v West @ Alberton
Sunday May 4
- Glenelg v Central @ Challenge Rec
(Norwood - Bye)

STILL IN: CENTRALS
blueboy
grantj
jimmy

STILL IN: EAGLES
gadj 1976

[gadj1976]

port

[grant j]

Sturt

[Blue Boy]

Ill tip Port !!!

[Jimmy]

north

[Dog_ger]

You have a good avitar Blue Boy...

[therisingblues]

Tough round this one. I hope at least one of you get through. I hate the "everyone loses play again" rule.
If you all screw up you should have to do "rock paper scissors" and finish it quick so we can start again the next week.
My upset this round would be West to beat Port. Don't know why, it just seems possible.

[smac]

Tough round this one. I hope at least one of you get through. I hate the "everyone loses play again" rule.
If you all screw up you should have to do "rock paper scissors" and finish it quick so we can start again the next week.
My upset this round would be West to beat Port. Don't know why, it just seems possible.

Hadn't contemplated that, good point. If it does happen this week then I will run with the old rule, but will think of an alternative before next week.

[magpie in the 80's]

Tough round this one. I hope at least one of you get through. I hate the "everyone loses play again" rule.
If you all screw up you should have to do "rock paper scissors" and finish it quick so we can start again the next week.
My upset this round would be West to beat Port. Don't know why, it just seems possible.

Hadn't contemplated that, good point. If it does happen this week then I will run with the old rule, but will think of an alternative before next week.

if i can add my 2 cents worth, i think if no one picks a winner then on to the next competition. i know its different to last year but a wins a win

[smac]

Tough round this one. I hope at least one of you get through. I hate the "everyone loses play again" rule.
If you all screw up you should have to do "rock paper scissors" and finish it quick so we can start again the next week.
My upset this round would be West to beat Port. Don't know why, it just seems possible.

Hadn't contemplated that, good point. If it does happen this week then I will run with the old rule, but will think of an alternative before next week.

if i can add my 2 cents worth, i think if no one picks a winner then on to the next competition. i know its different to last year but a wins a win

I'll conjure up some way to manufacture a winner. Looking at the tips in this week, I don't think it will be something to worry about just yet.

[gadj1976]

Tough round this one. I hope at least one of you get through. I hate the "everyone loses play again" rule.
If you all screw up you should have to do "rock paper scissors" and finish it quick so we can start again the next week.
My upset this round would be West to beat Port. Don't know why, it just seems possible.

Hadn't contemplated that, good point. If it does happen this week then I will run with the old rule, but will think of an alternative before next week.

if i can add my 2 cents worth, i think if no one picks a winner then on to the next competition. i know its different to last year but a wins a win

We're not playing for anything anyway.............*gulp* are we?

PS. We've got 20:1 moderators vs competitors!!!!!

[therisingblues]

Tough round this one. I hope at least one of you get through. I hate the "everyone loses play again" rule.
If you all screw up you should have to do "rock paper scissors" and finish it quick so we can start again the next week.
My upset this round would be West to beat Port. Don't know why, it just seems possible.

Hadn't contemplated that, good point. If it does happen this week then I will run with the old rule, but will think of an alternative before next week.

if i can add my 2 cents worth, i think if no one picks a winner then on to the next competition. i know its different to last year but a wins a win

I'll conjure up some way to manufacture a winner. Looking at the tips in this week, I don't think it will be something to worry about just yet.

I was thinking about it in the bath just before.
I reckon if everyone goes out in the same round, then they should also tip a points margin for the next round. Whoever goes closest to the winner and margin wins the competition outright. A bit like a golden goal, or a penalty shoot out, but at least we get to decide a winner out of the remaining tipsters (who are technically all losers seeing they all screwed up in the same round).
In addition, the second slaughter competition could begin concurrently with the tie-breaker round. In effect, tipsters involved in the tie-breaker could also paticipate in the second slaughter comp' in the same round.
Quite a productive bath I think...

[Dog_ger]

Leave it as it is.

Everyone deserves their 10 minutes of fame.

[smac]

I was thinking about it in the bath just before.
I reckon if everyone goes out in the same round, then they should also tip a points margin for the next round. Whoever goes closest to the winner and margin wins the competition outright. A bit like a golden goal, or a penalty shoot out, but at least we get to decide a winner out of the remaining tipsters (who are technically all losers seeing they all screwed up in the same round).
In addition, the second slaughter competition could begin concurrently with the tie-breaker round. In effect, tipsters involved in the tie-breaker could also paticipate in the second slaughter comp' in the same round.
Quite a productive bath I think...

A bath is only productive if you make your own bubbles!

[grant j]

Then there were three

boo Sturt

[magpie in the 80's]

those through to the next round

STILL IN: NORTH
JIMMY

STILL IN: PORT
GADJ 1976
BLUEBOY

THOSE OUT:
GRANTJ PICKED STURT

[Dog_ger]

THE THREE BEST IN 2008

(FIRST ROUND)

STILL IN: NORTH
JIMMY

STILL IN: PORT
GADJ 1976
BLUEBOY

Well done Guys...