Round 10 Port v West

[mots02]

The Power are contesting the Dixon decision.

Wouldn't it be better if the Magpies contested it?

[Dogs64]

Great to see the SANFL embarass themselves again

How?

Based on these https://sanfl-content.imgix.net/content/uploads/2024/03/15091417/State-Territory-Tribunal-Guidelines_SANFL_2024.pdf

it's been graded the lowest possible conduct (careless) the outcome is severe based on the concussion - White will miss at least two games the only possible room for manoeuvre for Port is, is the contact high (four weeks) or three (body) - p 22 of the linked document.

Yep in the past this would've been included in a 2020's version of MMM Rockin' Footy DVD as one of those incidents we all loved 10 years ago but as we all know the our sport takes concussion much more seriously hence why we get this outcome (match review sanction) when players choose to bump.

As your most decorated Port Power player Kane Cornes (4 x BFs 1 x premiership) said on SEN breakfast on Monday - the bump is dead

PS these guidelines would apply if you were in the VFL competition, just quietly

Won't White miss 3 games? Isn't 21 days if you're an SANFL player, but AFL players only take 14 days to recover? Another one of those unfair rules the AFL players have to endure.

[amber_fluid]

The Power are contesting the Dixon decision.

Wouldn't it be better if the Magpies contested it?

Who?

[Wedgie]

The Power are contesting the Dixon decision.

Wouldn't it be better if the Magpies contested it?

I don't think Collingwood care mate.

[Thiele]

Great to see the SANFL embarass themselves again

How?

Based on these https://sanfl-content.imgix.net/content/uploads/2024/03/15091417/State-Territory-Tribunal-Guidelines_SANFL_2024.pdf

it's been graded the lowest possible conduct (careless) the outcome is severe based on the concussion - White will miss at least two games the only possible room for manoeuvre for Port is, is the contact high (four weeks) or three (body) - p 22 of the linked document.

Yep in the past this would've been included in a 2020's version of MMM Rockin' Footy DVD as one of those incidents we all loved 10 years ago but as we all know the our sport takes concussion much more seriously hence why we get this outcome (match review sanction) when players choose to bump.

As your most decorated Port Power player Kane Cornes (4 x BFs 1 x premiership) said on SEN breakfast on Monday - the bump is dead

PS these guidelines would apply if you were in the VFL competition, just quietly

Won't White miss 3 games? Isn't 21 days if you're an SANFL player, but AFL players only take 14 days to recover? Another one of those unfair rules the AFL players have to endure.

White should be available for the Norwood game on Sunday July 7th. That will be 22 days

[knowledge]

Great to see the SANFL embarass themselves again

How?

Based on these https://sanfl-content.imgix.net/content/uploads/2024/03/15091417/State-Territory-Tribunal-Guidelines_SANFL_2024.pdf

it's been graded the lowest possible conduct (careless) the outcome is severe based on the concussion - White will miss at least two games the only possible room for manoeuvre for Port is, is the contact high (four weeks) or three (body) - p 22 of the linked document.

Yep in the past this would've been included in a 2020's version of MMM Rockin' Footy DVD as one of those incidents we all loved 10 years ago but as we all know the our sport takes concussion much more seriously hence why we get this outcome (match review sanction) when players choose to bump.

As your most decorated Port Power player Kane Cornes (4 x BFs 1 x premiership) said on SEN breakfast on Monday - the bump is dead

PS these guidelines would apply if you were in the VFL competition, just quietly

Won't White miss 3 games? Isn't 21 days if you're an SANFL player, but AFL players only take 14 days to recover? Another one of those unfair rules the AFL players have to endure.

White should be available for the Norwood game on Sunday July 7th. That will be 22 days

Only if he doesn't have a recurrence of symptoms in Stage 2 or 3 of the RTP. That may delay his return. I don't know what his concussion history is either. That could impact upon his RTP as well.

[PatowalongaPirate]

Dixon has plead guilty to hopefully reduce the suspension to 2 weeks.

Hoping to reduce from severe impact to high impact.

[Armchair expert]

He failed

3 weeks it is

[dedja]

Bloody thug, should have got 6.

[mots02]

Lots of interesting social media commentary from port folk ‘he didn’t get him high, the player the concussion from hitting his head on the ground, Charlie didn’t hit him, Charlie did nothing wrong.’

Ummm …. Charlie pleaded guilty at the appeal

[MW]

Lots of interesting social media commentary from port folk ‘he didn’t get him high, the player the concussion from hitting his head on the ground, Charlie didn’t hit him, Charlie did nothing wrong.’

Ummm …. Charlie pleaded guilty at the appeal

My favourite "It's because Charlie is big"

[The Dark Knight]

Lots of interesting social media commentary from port folk ‘he didn’t get him high, the player the concussion from hitting his head on the ground, Charlie didn’t hit him, Charlie did nothing wrong.’

Ummm …. Charlie pleaded guilty at the appeal [emoji38]

My favourite "It's because Charlie is big"

It's ridiculous, from what I've seen some people commenting on the incident are delusion with comments highlighting that the SANFL are corrupt and biased against Port for the decision being upheld, others are trying to be funny suggesting that it's a blessing in disguise that he won't be playing in the senior side for three weeks.

[dedja]

Lots of interesting social media commentary from port folk ‘he didn’t get him high, the player the concussion from hitting his head on the ground, Charlie didn’t hit him, Charlie did nothing wrong.’

Ummm …. Charlie pleaded guilty at the appeal

My favourite "It's because Charlie is big"

That’s what his girlfriend says …

[mots02]

Lots of interesting social media commentary from port folk ‘he didn’t get him high, the player the concussion from hitting his head on the ground, Charlie didn’t hit him, Charlie did nothing wrong.’

Ummm …. Charlie pleaded guilty at the appeal

My favourite "It's because Charlie is big"

That’s what his girlfriend says …

She gave him a 3 week ban too?

[dedja]

Lots of interesting social media commentary from port folk ‘he didn’t get him high, the player the concussion from hitting his head on the ground, Charlie didn’t hit him, Charlie did nothing wrong.’

Ummm …. Charlie pleaded guilty at the appeal

My favourite "It's because Charlie is big"

That’s what his girlfriend says …

She gave him a 3 week bang too?

EFA

[mots02]

Lots of interesting social media commentary from port folk ‘he didn’t get him high, the player the concussion from hitting his head on the ground, Charlie didn’t hit him, Charlie did nothing wrong.’

Ummm …. Charlie pleaded guilty at the appeal [emoji38]

My favourite "It's because Charlie is big"

It's ridiculous, from what I've seen some people commenting on the incident are delusion with comments highlighting that the SANFL are corrupt and biased against Port for the decision being upheld, others are trying to be funny suggesting that it's a blessing in disguise that he won't be playing in the senior side for three weeks.

The ‘sanfl is out to get us’ narrative is constant and strong

[am Bays]

The ‘sanfl is out to get us’ narrative is constant and strong

That’s the funniest one of all along with the comment can’t wait to leave and watch it (the SANFL die)

Just shows how little of an understanding they (the vocal minority of Port fans) have of how footy in this state is funded and how the SMA works.

[Booney]

Lots of interesting social media commentary from port folk ‘he didn’t get him high, the player the concussion from hitting his head on the ground, Charlie didn’t hit him, Charlie did nothing wrong.’

Ummm …. Charlie pleaded guilty at the appeal [emoji38]

My favourite "It's because Charlie is big"

It's ridiculous, from what I've seen some people commenting on the incident are delusion with comments highlighting that the SANFL are corrupt and biased against Port for the decision being upheld, others are trying to be funny suggesting that it's a blessing in disguise that he won't be playing in the senior side for three weeks.

It's got me beat mate.

For well over 18 months the onus has been on the player to protect the opponent, if you choose to bump and the player gets concussed you will be suspended. It's not more complicated than that.

[wenchbarwer]

Another roll of the dice

https://sanfl.com.au/league/news/round-10-sanfl-tribunal-appeal-charlie-dixon/

[Spargo]

Another roll of the dice

https://sanfl.com.au/league/news/round-10-sanfl-tribunal-appeal-charlie-dixon/

So he’s appealing the outcome of the challenge, after challenging the original decision. Where to if they’re unsuccessful again tomorrow?