Symes to Crows

[NFC]

NFC, I rate Symes, I believe he has footy smarts and is very clean with his skills

Symes is a certainty to join adelaide

The crows will also have a huge GO at Roughead

Great, another flanker who we simply DON'T NEED. Start developing what we've got. Man if this trade goes ahead I will be furious because he doesn't fill a NEED.

Roughead does, I will go insane if we land him. Won't happen though.

[sydney-dog]

NFC

Symes was SA most valuable player and an all australian at the 2003 National Championships as a midfielder

I believe he has the capability to play in the GUTS!!!!!

[redden whites]

The crows will also have a huge GO at Roughead

With what?

[NFC]

NFC

Symes was SA most valuable player and an all australian at the 2003 National Championships as a midfielder

I believe he has the capability to play in the GUTS!!!!!

Yes he's started to expand his capabilities this year with the Dogs but IMO there are just too many concerns over his game. Speed, disposal, awareness, just not the player we should be after. Look he's a decent player and he could go on to play 100 AFL games and be a solid player, but we just don't need him. Douglas, Pfeiffer, Vince, Mackay, Hinge= all similar players who we should be looking to develop, not trading for a like player when we really don't need him.

[sydney-dog]

we must be looking at a different player

speed, I don't have a concern

disposal and awareness, I thouight this was his strength

I would be interested in other members thoughts

[stan]

NFC, I rate Symes, I believe he has footy smarts and is very clean with his skills

Symes is a certainty to join adelaide

The crows will also have a huge GO at Roughead

Great, another flanker who we simply DON'T NEED. Start developing what we've got. Man if this trade goes ahead I will be furious because he doesn't fill a NEED.

Roughead does, I will go insane if we land him. Won't happen though.

If you get roughead ill be impressed.

[heater31]

NFC

Symes was SA most valuable player and an all australian at the 2003 National Championships as a midfielder

I believe he has the capability to play in the GUTS!!!!!

Yes he's started to expand his capabilities this year with the Dogs but IMO there are just too many concerns over his game. Speed, disposal, awareness, just not the player we should be after. Look he's a decent player and he could go on to play 100 AFL games and be a solid player, but we just don't need him. Douglas, Pfeiffer, Vince, Mackay, Hinge= all similar players who we should be looking to develop, not trading for a like player when we really don't need him.

Well bugger off then and find another footy club to follow because its almost a done deal for a 2nd rounder according to 7 news

[NFC]

NFC

Symes was SA most valuable player and an all australian at the 2003 National Championships as a midfielder

I believe he has the capability to play in the GUTS!!!!!

Yes he's started to expand his capabilities this year with the Dogs but IMO there are just too many concerns over his game. Speed, disposal, awareness, just not the player we should be after. Look he's a decent player and he could go on to play 100 AFL games and be a solid player, but we just don't need him. Douglas, Pfeiffer, Vince, Mackay, Hinge= all similar players who we should be looking to develop, not trading for a like player when we really don't need him.

Well bugger off then and find another footy club to follow because its almost a done deal for a 2nd rounder according to 7 news

What? I'm unhappy with a trade so I need to start looking for another club?

Anyway, which one of our second rounder will it be? 22 for Huddo, 27, 28?

[rod_rooster]

The crows will also have a huge GO at Roughead

What could the Crows possibly offer Hawthorn for Roughead?

[stan]

The crows will also have a huge GO at Roughead

What could the Crows possibly offer Hawthorn for Roughead?

Magic beans.

[sydney-dog]

pick #10 and Jericho

[rod_rooster]

pick #10 and Jericho

LMAO

[sydney-dog]

I am not saying that would be the deal, all I am saying is potentially that it something that could be offered..

or

Pick 27 and Kenny McGregor

[rod_rooster]

I am not saying that would be the deal, all I am saying is potentially that it something that could be offered..

or

Pick 27 and Kenny McGregor

Why would Hawthorn give up Roughead, a number 2 pick who has developed into a very good key forward and will only get better given he's only 20, for either one of the hacks you mention who couldn't even regularly break into the Crows 22 let alone Hawthorn's? Pick 27 or 10 is hardly a sweetener that makes it worthwhile.

[redden whites]

pick #10 and Jericho

I am assuming that is Chris Jericho the wrestler !

[GWW]

No way would Hawthorn give up Roughead for pick 10 and Jericho. Hawthorn would be looking at a straight swap for Rutten maybe, or maybe Knights and pick 10 (even those 2 deals unlikely to be enough).

[the joker]

No way would Hawthorn give up Roughead for pick 10 and Jericho. Hawthorn would be looking at a straight swap for Rutten maybe, or maybe Knights and pick 10 (even those 2 deals unlikely to be enough).

has crows trying to get roughhead has that been talked about on the tv or did someone on this site make it up. if crows could get him they would have to give up alot. IT WONT HAPPEN... or centrals supporters are all right clarko is a wanker and cant coach

[ORDoubleBlues]

The crows will also have a huge GO at Roughead

What could the Crows possibly offer Hawthorn for Roughead?

David Noble?

[smac]

or centrals supporters are all right clarko is a wanker and cant coach

Only the first bit - the guy can coach.

[MagareyLegend]

Symes better decision-maker, better skillled and better motor (not his car) than Mattner.
Having said that Mattner is good pick-up for Swannies.