Lightning McQueen wrote:whufc wrote:Love your votes and reckon you will be very close to getting it right.
Imo speaking to a few umpires I have no doubt 'personality' is used as a bit of a tie breaker when two players performance cant be separated. Rightfully or wrongly.
Absloutely, it's a life rule too, if someone is being a knob when I'm umpiring footy there's no chance of getting a vote.
I've actually tried taking that into consideration when doing the votes on here, I know most players although I'm all at sea with the Knights & Earwigs.
Enfield: Rackebrandt & Channa are very nice blokes, respectful and quiet spoken... McEwan is a ******* pest, and I don't think I've had much positive feedback to umpires during games this year so rule us out.
Think some of my most constructive piece of feedback came against Smithfield when an LBW appeal against Lowie was turned down, asked what it was missing and Pete Turnbull replied with "Not telling".. fair to say I was happy enough to tell him my thoughts
Couple balls later bowled him anyway, thanks for coming champ.