by valleys07 » Mon Jul 09, 2018 4:39 pm
by amber_fluid » Mon Jul 09, 2018 4:39 pm
Fricky wrote:Brodlach wrote:Wonder if Carlton would be able to take Jeremy McGovern as a free agent and trade Pick 1 to Adelaide for Mitch (plus extras)?
I'd take that deal. Give Carlton Hartigan and Hampton as the "extras"
Sloane = 1st round pick at the least. If he leaves I hope he picks the Saints and we get pick 3
McGovern = 1st round pick
M Crouch = 1st round pick (if rumours are true that Brad and he want out)
All speculation and wishful thinking at the moment.
by Fricky » Mon Jul 09, 2018 4:40 pm
mighty hounds wrote:Fricky wrote:Brodlach wrote:Wonder if Carlton would be able to take Jeremy McGovern as a free agent and trade Pick 1 to Adelaide for Mitch (plus extras)?
I'd take that deal. Give Carlton Hartigan and Hampton as the "extras"
Sloane = 1st round pick at the least. If he leaves I hope he picks the Saints and we get pick 3
McGovern = 1st round pick
M Crouch = 1st round pick (if rumours are true that Brad and he want out)
All speculation and wishful thinking at the moment.
I haven't heard any rumour about him and Brad wanting out? Where'd you hear that?
by mighty hounds » Mon Jul 09, 2018 4:44 pm
valleys07 wrote:Rankine will get to the AFC one way or another, whether that be him "sliding" down the order, or the Crows acquiring the picks to select him.
by mighty hounds » Mon Jul 09, 2018 4:45 pm
amber_fluid wrote:Fricky wrote:Brodlach wrote:Wonder if Carlton would be able to take Jeremy McGovern as a free agent and trade Pick 1 to Adelaide for Mitch (plus extras)?
I'd take that deal. Give Carlton Hartigan and Hampton as the "extras"
Sloane = 1st round pick at the least. If he leaves I hope he picks the Saints and we get pick 3
McGovern = 1st round pick
M Crouch = 1st round pick (if rumours are true that Brad and he want out)
All speculation and wishful thinking at the moment.
Hartigan and Hampton, no thanks.
You can have Kerridge back as well when you want.
Wright has been ok this year so we’ll keep him.
I’d take the younger Mcgovern and you can have your first rounder you gave us for Gibbs.
by valleys07 » Mon Jul 09, 2018 4:46 pm
mighty hounds wrote:valleys07 wrote:Rankine will get to the AFC one way or another, whether that be him "sliding" down the order, or the Crows acquiring the picks to select him.
Going the Chad Whingard way you reckon Valleys?
by amber_fluid » Mon Jul 09, 2018 4:47 pm
mighty hounds wrote:amber_fluid wrote:Fricky wrote:Brodlach wrote:Wonder if Carlton would be able to take Jeremy McGovern as a free agent and trade Pick 1 to Adelaide for Mitch (plus extras)?
I'd take that deal. Give Carlton Hartigan and Hampton as the "extras"
Sloane = 1st round pick at the least. If he leaves I hope he picks the Saints and we get pick 3
McGovern = 1st round pick
M Crouch = 1st round pick (if rumours are true that Brad and he want out)
All speculation and wishful thinking at the moment.
Hartigan and Hampton, no thanks.
You can have Kerridge back as well when you want.
Wright has been ok this year so we’ll keep him.
I’d take the younger Mcgovern and you can have your first rounder you gave us for Gibbs.
And your number one pick, cheers
by Booney » Mon Jul 09, 2018 4:57 pm
Fricky wrote:Brodlach wrote:Wonder if Carlton would be able to take Jeremy McGovern as a free agent and trade Pick 1 to Adelaide for Mitch (plus extras)?
I'd take that deal. Give Carlton Hartigan and Hampton as the "extras"
Sloane = 1st round pick at the least. If he leaves I hope he picks the Saints and we get pick 3
McGovern = 1st round pick
M Crouch = 1st round pick (if rumours are true that Brad and he want out)
All speculation and wishful thinking at the moment.
by Jim05 » Mon Jul 09, 2018 5:12 pm
mighty hounds wrote:valleys07 wrote:Rankine will get to the AFC one way or another, whether that be him "sliding" down the order, or the Crows acquiring the picks to select him.
Going the Chad Whingard way you reckon Valleys?
by mighty hounds » Mon Jul 09, 2018 5:30 pm
Jim05 wrote:mighty hounds wrote:valleys07 wrote:Rankine will get to the AFC one way or another, whether that be him "sliding" down the order, or the Crows acquiring the picks to select him.
Going the Chad Whingard way you reckon Valleys?
Already he has if you believe the rumours
by someguy1 » Mon Jul 09, 2018 5:37 pm
Booney wrote:
If Sloane leaves you'll get an end of first round pick as compensation, unless St Kilda trade for him and why would they?
by Booney » Mon Jul 09, 2018 5:40 pm
someguy1 wrote:Booney wrote:
If Sloane leaves you'll get an end of first round pick as compensation, unless St Kilda trade for him and why would they?
Restricted free agent. Would the Crows match just to force a trade instead of going the Compo route? Geelong didn't need to trade for Dangerfield either but still did. Saints pick 4 for Sloane sounds better than 19.
If the Crows are as high on Lukosius and Rankine as it sounds do you sell the farm and swap everything to get pick 1 and 4 (assuming they get something like that for Sloane)? Would 8 and 13 be enough? What about with McGovern in a three way trade to where he wants to go?
by mighty hounds » Mon Jul 09, 2018 5:41 pm
someguy1 wrote:Booney wrote:
If Sloane leaves you'll get an end of first round pick as compensation, unless St Kilda trade for him and why would they?
Restricted free agent. Would the Crows match just to force a trade instead of going the Compo route? Geelong didn't need to trade for Dangerfield either but still did. Saints pick 4 for Sloane sounds better than 19.
If the Crows are as high on Lukosius and Rankine as it sounds do you sell the farm and swap everything to get pick 1 and 4 (assuming they get something like that for Sloane)? Would 8 and 13 be enough? What about with McGovern in a three way trade to where he wants to go?
by someguy1 » Mon Jul 09, 2018 6:31 pm
by Dutchy » Mon Jul 09, 2018 10:21 pm
by Stumps » Tue Jul 10, 2018 10:00 am
Footy Smart wrote:Stumps wrote:Footy Smart wrote:Well disappointing outcome but geez the Tigs were impressive. I thought the lads had a crack but just couldn’t get any clean ball or fluency under the relentless pressure.
Positives -
Greenwoods last 2 weeks been impressive, clearance wise and getting some more footy around the ground
Doedee keeps getting better and better. Calm and his effort and pressure is first rate
Milera showing some consistency, using ball well off half back, just needs to be a bit cleaner at times
Jenkins last 2 weeks competed well and hit the scoreboard
Negatives –
Kelly and Hartigan after solid years last year really struggling to recapture that form
Hampton after an ok game first up had a mare
Inability of half back to get any momentum
Method going inside 50 has been horrendous/non existent
Kyle Cheney getting a game
agree with all points apart from one. Cheney was excellent friday night. Decisions and disposal was good. Watch the tape again
There is a reason Cheney is at his 3rd club. He cant play! he is one of those blokes who makes it look like he is trying hard but fails to impact the contest. Disposal is ok when not under pressure but the fact he is getting a game sums up how well we are going IMO
by Booney » Tue Jul 10, 2018 10:03 am
by Footy Smart » Tue Jul 10, 2018 10:22 am
3 clubs means he cant play. what a statement. you must know more than the Adelaide recruiters put in your CV. I thought he played very well Friday night and deserves to play this weekend that's what i'm saying.
by Bum Crack » Tue Jul 10, 2018 10:29 am
Dutchy wrote:Interesting that AFC have admitted Talia has been playing with this foot injury since the pre-season
by stan » Tue Jul 10, 2018 1:29 pm
Jim05 wrote:mighty hounds wrote:valleys07 wrote:Rankine will get to the AFC one way or another, whether that be him "sliding" down the order, or the Crows acquiring the picks to select him.
Going the Chad Whingard way you reckon Valleys?
Already he has if you believe the rumours
Competitions SANFL Official Site | Country Footy SA | Southern Football League | VFL Footy
Club Forums Snouts Louts | The Roost | Redlegs Forum |