Port Adelaide 2017

[morell]

Thankyou, Trader.

Ruck SWARM v3!

[The Bedge]

Can't we just talk footy ball simply ways?

[woodublieve12]

When you add it all together. It's about as irrefutable as you can get.

Ryder is the best ruck in the comp as per the empirical ruck stats and aggregated anecdotal expert opinion.

I'll leave ya'll do it. I need to do some work.

Stats hey! So going by that Tom Mitchell is the best footballer in the comp because he gets the footy more than anyone else.

Is that how it works???

[morell]

Are you deliberately trying to make me smash my keyboard into my screen?

[woodublieve12]

Are you deliberately trying to make me smash my keyboard into my screen?

[daysofourlives]

Thankyou, Trader.

Ruck SWARM v3!

Umm, where Is Big Boy? He has been in the AA ruck conversation too? I hope you havent left him out because he beats Ryder on the Z score

[bertiebeatle]

Houston re-signed. Apparently Bonner & Howard have as well, just waiting for the official word.

Great news for Port! All 2 year deals

[valleys07]

Bonner is the one from this lot that I am just waiting for to explode.

Came to the club with a bit of hype on the back of a good U18 championships in 2015, and after his debut at the end of last year I had him pencilled in for 10-15 games this season.

Shat the bed massively in this seasons JLT games, and is well back in the pecking order now. Needs a massive off-season to prove that this extension is talent and not hype.

Absolutely love what "Housto" is producing. Absolutely solid as a rock back there.

[morell]

Thankyou, Trader.

Ruck SWARM v3!

Umm, where Is Big Boy? He has been in the AA ruck conversation too? I hope you haven't left him out because he beats Ryder on the Z score

He wasn't raised in the thread as an option.

Hes not in contention, sorry.

[Trader]

Interesting that adding McEvoy moves Mumford ahead of Kreuzer.

What happens if you add all of the ruckmen in the comp?

[morell]

Interesting that adding McEvoy moves Mumford ahead of Kreuzer.

What happens if you add all of the ruckmen in the comp?

I'd suspect not much. As in, the order would stay pretty much the same and the scores would condense.

If someone wants to add up the scores for the coaches MVP from here:

http://www.aflca.com.au/index.php?id=63

and the SEN votes from here:

http://www.aflplayerratings.com.au/

Then I'll do the rest.

I was also going to incude a ToG somehow as well. Maybe take a proportion off the hit outs, disposals and team clearances.

[valleys07]

Houston re-signed. Apparently Bonner & Howard have as well, just waiting for the official word.

Great news for Port! All 2 year deals

Back to the Bonner discussion for a moment;

Should Pittard re-commit to the club, we will be left with trying to condense he, Broadbent, Hartlett, DBJ, Houston, Jonas, Hombsch, Austin and Clurey into 6 spots.

A poster on BigFooty suggested we try Bonner as a high half forward? He has great athleticism for his height (191cm), is super quick and has a booming kick- all the attributes required to succeed in that sort of role.

IMO, this is the role that Hartlett should be fulfilling as that player who can mark strong overhead and kick goals from outside 50, but Ken likes him off of half back. Perhaps Bonner could become this player for us?

[Wedgie]

I'm still trying to work out who the greatest Power player ever is/was. Paddy Ryder or Johann Wagner?

[bennymacca]

Interesting that adding McEvoy moves Mumford ahead of Kreuzer.

What happens if you add all of the ruckmen in the comp?

I'd suspect not much. As in, the order would stay pretty much the same and the scores would condense.

.

You have already proven this to be incorrect by adding a single extra ruck.

[woodublieve12]

I'm still trying to work out who the greatest Power player ever is/was. Paddy Ryder or Johann Wagner?

Russell Ebert. Oh that was the magpies, a totally different club. Sorry

[bertiebeatle]

Houston re-signed. Apparently Bonner & Howard have as well, just waiting for the official word.

Great news for Port! All 2 year deals

Back to the Bonner discussion for a moment;

Should Pittard re-commit to the club, we will be left with trying to condense he, Broadbent, Hartlett, DBJ, Houston, Jonas, Hombsch, Austin and Clurey into 6 spots.

A poster on BigFooty suggested we try Bonner as a high half forward? He has great athleticism for his height (191cm), is super quick and has a booming kick- all the attributes required to succeed in that sort of role.

IMO, this is the role that Hartlett should be fulfilling as that player who can mark strong overhead and kick goals from outside 50, but Ken likes him off of half back. Perhaps Bonner could become this player for us?

Very good question to ask. We are definitely stacked down back (Throw JT and Impey in there who can go down back as well). I'd like Hartlett on a HFF but can't see that happening. Bonner has the good disposal behind him as does Hammer. One of those two for me would be perfect at half forward. Even throw one of them onto a wing for White. Wouldn't mind seeing Bonner on a wing & Hartlett at HFF

[morell]

Interesting that adding McEvoy moves Mumford ahead of Kreuzer.

What happens if you add all of the ruckmen in the comp?

I'd suspect not much. As in, the order would stay pretty much the same and the scores would condense.

.

You have already proven this to be incorrect by adding a single extra ruck.

Struggling with reading comprehension too benny?

Mumford went ahead of Kreuzer because McEvoys hitouts made Kreuzers relatively low number even more "variant".

I doubt adding other rucks would change it all that much other than some minor jockeying for positions.

[Wedgie]

Just a small request, but do you have to be rude to everyone that might not have the same opinion as you?

[amber_fluid]

I'm still trying to work out who the greatest Power player ever is/was. Paddy Ryder or Johann Wagner?

Russell Ebert. Oh that was the magpies, a totally different club. Sorry

IMG_1533.JPG (32.07 KiB) Viewed 661 times

[morell]

Just a small request, but do you have to be rude to everyone that might not have the same opinion as you?

No. Provided those people read what I've said, understand it, and as a result provide counter points that are pertinent to the argument I'm putting forward.

I will, however, provide ignominy to the ignorant.

But really, what I said isn't really rude these days.