bennymacca wrote:am Bays wrote:
This'll be good.....
can someone arrange the beers???
Alright, here we go. Dont be too harsh on me please booney
I could only find room for 7 port players in my combined team. I used the AFL.com.au "projected" teams
Brown
Hombsch Lever
Smith Talia Laird
Gray Crouch
BoakLynch Walker
WingardBetts Jenkins McGovern
Jacobs Sloane
WinesHartlett Ryder Atkins Cameron
Pittard and B Crouch miss due to injury
Westhoff - reckon mcgovern and lynch have him coverd
Trengove - poor man's talia really. Went with Hombsch instead
Ebert - went with the pace and ball use of Atkins and Cameron
Broadbent - stiff to miss but isnt ahead of laird smith or pittard
Polec - could easily have him instead of atkins or cameron.
You can also make a case that Ryder misses as you dont need to play two rucks
Interesting.
Ill have a crack, using the same logic re. injury:
FB: Brown Talia
HombschHB: Smith
Trengove Laird
C:
Polec Wines Atkins
HF: Lynch Walker
WingardFF: Betts Jenkins McGovern
1R: Jacobs Sloane
R.GrayIC: Lever
Boak M.Crouch
EbertI found room for 8, with a few changes to your side.
Don't rate Cameron as highly as you do. I think he is an improvement on Impey, but skills are still average.
I have gone Trengove as the pure CHB who can pinch hit in the Ruck when Jacobs rests. A competent stopper ahead of Hartigan. I don't view Hombsch as a full back, rather a BP/HB who is very useful as that intercept and rebound defender. Just ahead of Lever, who is on my bench.
Gray and Boak are not wingmen, they are on ball rotations. Gray and Sloane are clearly the best pure on ball players for their respective sides, and Wines ahead of Thompson as centre. Both M.Crouch and Boak on the bench as on ball rotation.
Polec is Port's #1 wingman, Atkins looking very good to assume that role at Adelaide. Both good fits there.
Our forward line's are identical, no arguments there. Adelaide have the best Forward Line in the competition.
I struggled with I4, and went with Ebert as he is probably the only mid in either side capable of playing as an inside and outside midfielder.
“Think of me like Yoda, but instead of being little and green I wear suits and I'm awesome. I'm your bro—I'm Broda!”
HOGG Shield 2015 Division I Premiers.
HOGG Shield 2017 Premier League Premiers.