Your Top 5 Most Over-Rated Players Going Around

[helicopterking]

I was having this conversation today at work so I'll throw it out there.
Blokes that seem to have a profile and have for some time, but you don't think they deserve it.

My Five

1) T.Cloke
2) L.Jetta
3) S.Reid
4) P.Ryder
5) T.Varcoe

[GWW]

Does anyone actually rate Varcoe at all?!

[Coach Bombay]

Ryder
Dal Santo
Gibbs
Tippett
Frawley

[Jim05]

Cloke
Tippett
Marc Murphy
Frawley
Dustin Martin

[Chuck Wepner]

Lindsay Thomas
Scott Thompson (Crows)
Angus Monfries
Troy Chaplin
Leigh Montagna

[helicopterking]

Does anyone actually rate Varcoe at all?!

Geelong supporters were the only ones I knew of, not so much now.

[carey]

Harry O (Or what ever the idiots name is now)
L.Thomas
S.Thompson (Never stands the oppositions best forward)
Dangerfield (Can win his own ball but simply can't kick)
Neade (Simply to small)
Chaplin (Spud of the highest order)
Grimes (Check out how many goals he has kicked on him)
Tom Scully (Money)
Nick Malceski
Shane Edwards
Nic Nat (Should deliver soooooo much more)
Damien Hardwick

No doubt this will bite me in the ass this week and Thomas will probably kick 6 and Thompson get best on.

[carey]

Collingwood

[woodublieve12]

Ryder
Dal Santo
Gibbs
Tippett
Frawley

2011-12 Tippett was the best thing since slice bread at cows land

[LaughingKookaburra]

Nic Nat
L Shuey
J Cloke
M Murphy
D Hardwick (great call)

[JK]

Harbrow

[PatowalongaPirate]

Ryder
Dal Santo
Gibbs
Tippett
Frawley

2011-12 Tippett was the best thing since slice bread at cows land

Yes but they're grumpy they lost him..............still...............it will never end.........

And how the hell is Ryder mentioned? Only been talked up by the Adelaide media and Port.

[PatowalongaPirate]

Harry O (Or what ever the idiots name is now)
L.Thomas
S.Thompson (Never stands the oppositions best forward)
Dangerfield (Can win his own ball but simply can't kick)
Neade (Simply to small)
Chaplin (Spud of the highest order)
Grimes (Check out how many goals he has kicked on him)
Tom Scully (Money)
Nick Malceski
Shane Edwards
Nic Nat (Should deliver soooooo much more)
Damien Hardwick

No doubt this will bite me in the ass this week and Thomas will probably kick 6 and Thompson get best on.

Dangerfield overrated? Please put your bias aside. You offer up Neade and cast aspersions on others?

[Dogwatcher]

Collingwood

Over-rated? No one's predicting us to do well this year, mate.
Kangas are the one's looking over-rated at the moment.

[MW]

Harry O (Or what ever the idiots name is now)
L.Thomas
S.Thompson (Never stands the oppositions best forward)
Dangerfield (Can win his own ball but simply can't kick)
Neade (Simply to small)
Chaplin (Spud of the highest order)
Grimes (Check out how many goals he has kicked on him)
Tom Scully (Money)
Nick Malceski
Shane Edwards
Nic Nat (Should deliver soooooo much more)
Damien Hardwick

No doubt this will bite me in the ass this week and Thomas will probably kick 6 and Thompson get best on.

Who on this earth ever rated Chaplin?
Malceski is rated exactly where he should be...hard running rebounding defender.
Dangerfield on this list is a joke surely

[RoosterMan]

I was having this conversation today at work so I'll throw it out there.
Blokes that seem to have a profile and have for some time, but you don't think they deserve it.

My Five

1) T.Cloke
2) L.Jetta
3) S.Reid
4) P.Ryder
5) T.Varcoe

Jetta and Reid overrated?

Both of them are premiership players and both players have been cursed with injuries in recent seasons.

[woodublieve12]

wingard

[Spargo]

Are the critical thinkers on this thread coming to their highly educated conclusions on the back of the first two rounds of this year or the past couple of seasons?

[woodublieve12]

Are the critical thinkers on this thread coming to their highly educated conclusions on the back of the first two rounds of this year or the past couple of seasons?

[RoosterMan]

wingard

Love the profile signature, mate.

That line will line up as one of Bruce's best lines along with his call of Cathy Freeman's win in the 400m at the 2000 Sydney Olympics.