Ch9 AFL Division 4 - 2015

[Footy Chick]

traditionally, the jump from 4 to 3 has been the hardest. It's not a decision you'd make without ensuring you've got good stocks or you'll just end up back where you started very quickly.

[HH3]

traditionally, the jump from 4 to 3 has been the hardest. It's not a decision you'd make without ensuring you've got good stocks or you'll just end up back where you started very quickly.

roughly 12 months

[LaughingKookaburra]

Will Salisbury West be able to fill 2 sides? Genuine question because if they can't then you'd think they would be in the same boat as Kilburn and their drop won't stop @ div 5 if 2 sides can't be fielded.

[Q.]

Just have a bye in the reserves comp and let them get pumped every week.

[Footy Chick]

that's fine to say Q but what about the other 9 clubs that lose money by NOT having 2 games on.

I'm sure @Pag can attest...

[Pag]

Out of the 4 games we should've played against Kilburn last year (2 x As, 2 x Bs), we played 1. We were compensated by the league who I believe were compensated by Kilburn, when they couldn't field one side, but I'm sure the league wouldn't want to run the risk of the same happening two years in a row.

[Q.]

that's fine to say Q but what about the other 9 clubs that lose money by NOT having 2 games on.

I'm sure @Pag can attest...

How much do you really lose by not having a Reserves game at home once in the season?

This year we had two extra full round byes, and another home round with only one game on....and managed just fine.

[Footy Chick]

Point is, why should other clubs miss out at all?

[twobob]

If Kilburn & Salisbury West don't make the cut with the two sides. Who will go up to replace them? I am thinking Eastern Park would go up from four to three. Would Woody south and Pultney just stay in four?

[Q.]

Point is, why should other clubs miss out at all?

It just seem so inconsequential to miss out on a Reserves game, that it's hardly worth complaining about. Some people just want something to complain about I guess.

[The Informer]

Point is, why should other clubs miss out at all?

It just seem so inconsequential to miss out on a Reserves game, that it's hardly worth complaining about. Some people just want something to complain about I guess.

Not sure if this is correct but there might be a bigger gathering to a higher grade reserve game than lower?

Could be wrong but.

[Boosh]

Point is, why should other clubs miss out at all?

It just seem so inconsequential to miss out on a Reserves game, that it's hardly worth complaining about. Some people just want something to complain about I guess.

Not sure if this is correct but there might be a bigger gathering to a higher grade reserve game than lower?

Could be wrong but.

Revenue isn't the issue, if you can't field two teams you have no place in a two team comp.

[The Informer]

Point is, why should other clubs miss out at all?

It just seem so inconsequential to miss out on a Reserves game, that it's hardly worth complaining about. Some people just want something to complain about I guess.

Not sure if this is correct but there might be a bigger gathering to a higher grade reserve game than lower?

Could be wrong but.

Revenue isn't the issue, if you can't field two teams you have no place in a two team comp.

Sounds simple lol

[Q.]

Point is, why should other clubs miss out at all?

It just seem so inconsequential to miss out on a Reserves game, that it's hardly worth complaining about. Some people just want something to complain about I guess.

Not sure if this is correct but there might be a bigger gathering to a higher grade reserve game than lower?

Could be wrong but.

Probably more dependent on the club itself than the division.

[Lightning McQueen]

Point is, why should other clubs miss out at all?

It just seem so inconsequential to miss out on a Reserves game, that it's hardly worth complaining about. Some people just want something to complain about I guess.

No they don't.

[Q.]

Point is, why should other clubs miss out at all?

It just seem so inconsequential to miss out on a Reserves game, that it's hardly worth complaining about. Some people just want something to complain about I guess.

No they don't.

Yes they do.

[Cohiba]

Point is, why should other clubs miss out at all?

It just seem so inconsequential to miss out on a Reserves game, that it's hardly worth complaining about. Some people just want something to complain about I guess.

Not sure if this is correct but there might be a bigger gathering to a higher grade reserve game than lower?

Could be wrong but.

Revenue isn't the issue, if you can't field two teams you have no place in a two team comp.

Agreed.....History tells us clubs come and go.........the reasons are many and varied but being emotional doesn't alter the fact......

[Boosh]

When is the deadline for these clubs? I wouldn't want this to drag out into next year.

[twobob]

When is the deadline for these clubs? I wouldn't want this to drag out into next year.

I reckon it will

[Robb_Stark]

id say February 1st would be my deadline for both clubs if Kilburn cant produce a 55 playing list of actual players and salisbury west have not found anyone to take its place in div 3 then yeah the league need to makes some big decisions