Snags wrote:TOTY IN MY OPINION
FF D Feeley (Mallala) B.Nikaulas(Virginia) A.Duncan(hamley)
HF L.Allmond(two wells) K.Herbele(hamley) C.Howell(Virginia)
C J.Clements(mallala) N.Seccafien(Two Wells) L.Michael(balak)
HB J.Earl(mallala) S.Obrien(two wells) J.Birchmore(mallala)
FB A.Mark(Virginia) A.Pont(Two wells) L Slok (Hamley)
FOL B.Dowdell(hamley) J.montgomerie(mallala) T.Stribling(hamley)
INT (players that could slip in, lots if them)
L.Pearson(balak) H.Pym(United)B.Robertson(Virginia)B.Slattery(two wells) zanandrea(hamley) B.hart(two wells) T.Rowe(HWE) K.Leighton(Twowells) B.Hood(United) B.hardie(mallala)
Couple of small changes to your side if I were picking players on the position they play, not how a side could possibly look. For those reasons I swapped Duncan and Stribling in positions. Robertson is a wingman/midfileder who can kick goals not a FP, so Feely comes in for mine. Cant remember Pym playing HB, unless trying to play loose to shake a tag, therefore Birchmore has done a great job when going back for Mallala, so he's in. Put a strange one in Slok in a BP, but I cant think of a forward who has kicked a bag of goals against him, Feely with 3 might be the only one, so as a pure BP, i think its hard to go past. I was going to swap the Leighton boys, but when you are tlking interchange you could have 20 in there...
As for the comment in reply earlier that Association footy is the recognition, whilst you have to have a certain number of players under the age of X, it is always a compromised team, so it is not a true reflection of the year. Also how many times do imports get selected in that team because they are imports, not because they have got a kick in the first 4 rounds. TOTY is a reflection of the whole season, not picking a team based on age, reputation etc. and therefore, a young kid, who doesnt play Association because he doesn't have a name after 4 games, can still be rewarded if over the course of the season he plays a major part in his teams results.
I love association footy dont get me wrong, but neither should substitute the other, simply we should have both.
There are probably a few players i have missed as I just ran of yours a little, but that being said, ythese are only opinions.