Round 3 Discussion

[zedman]

I have barlow and fyfe so my initial strategy to correct rookies this week is a bit more difficult..

Hold fyfe, barlow out the door downgraded to polec and jkh upgraded to zorko..wanted to bring taylor and ambrose in but that won't happen now..

Good luck to all this weekend!

[woodublieve12]

i reckon i'm going to trade Pav... hasn't done enogh i reckon

[woodublieve12]

Pav and Daisy out... Zorko and M.Thomas (Richmond) in...

[David Brent]

Fyfe Rohan out Zorko & D Buckley in

[woodublieve12]

Fyfe Rohan out Zorko & D Buckley in

Rohan and Buddy have one more chance...

[zedman]

Fyfe Rohan out Zorko & D Buckley in

i like the look of buckley..got one more week before he bubbles though..you could get taylor, dunstan or gleeson on the bubble for roughly the same money this week if you dont have them already..

[Phantom Gossiper]

OUT: Luke Hodge & Eric MacKenzie
IN: James Frawley and David Swallow

Hopefully strengthen a weak backline that i have and gives me a chance to make a play for a premium forward next week,

[Hondo]

Pav and Daisy out... Zorko and M.Thomas (Richmond) in...

I'm looking at the same INs but different OUTs. I'm keeping Daisy for now. I thought he looked good in the second half last week. He can only improve from here on.

[valleys07]

2 Corrective trades for me this week:

Suckling > Swallow

Webster > Georgiou

Why???
Suckling is a keeper and webster is playing this week


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

I turned suckling into Swallow- who im backing in to average more than Suckling over the course of the season. It may come back to bite me, its the risks you take in this game.

Webster is a decision i regret based on cash sitting on the pine, so I downgraded to georgiou to free up $140k to bank for future upgrades, as well as (hopefully) generating more cash out of Georgiou in the long term given lower purchase price and expected lower B/E.

At the end of the day these 2 decisions were based purely to provide a fix for a floundering forward line- in which Rohan most definitely needs to be moved on for someone with greater cash cow potential.

[valleys07]

I'm also not sure, Groover, that you can class a bloke that has never averaged more than 90, a keeper.

Even if I had of kept him in my side, he may have turned into an upgrade down the track. Swallow if he keeps his average up could turn into that keeper, at a cost of an extra $60k.

Risk v Reward.

[Phantom Gossiper]

At the end of the day these 2 decisions were based purely to provide a fix for a floundering forward line- in which Rohan most definitely needs to be moved on for someone with greater cash cow potential.

Rohan was a great disappointment, I shipped him and Dangerfield off after round one and looked to get a rookie who would make me some decent money, with an easy run coming up for the Crows after this week, hopefully Dangerfields price will have dropped significantly and i can bring him back in.

[zedman]

I'm also not sure, Groover, that you can class a bloke that has never averaged more than 90, a keeper.

Even if I had of kept him in my side, he may have turned into an upgrade down the track. Swallow if he keeps his average up could turn into that keeper, at a cost of an extra $60k.

Risk v Reward.

i dont think suckling is a keeper either just a cash cow but thats the beauty of this game..its opinions versus opinions..swallow will average more imo..hes top quality and is a lock..

[Freaky Tah]

Fyfe Bench for M Crouch lucky I had backup

[Phantom Gossiper]

Fyfe Bench for M Crouch lucky I had backup

I'm surprised M Crouch hasn't been picked earlier TBH

[valleys07]

I'm also not sure, Groover, that you can class a bloke that has never averaged more than 90, a keeper.

Even if I had of kept him in my side, he may have turned into an upgrade down the track. Swallow if he keeps his average up could turn into that keeper, at a cost of an extra $60k.

Risk v Reward.

i dont think suckling is a keeper either just a cash cow but thats the beauty of this game..its opinions versus opinions..swallow will average more imo..hes top quality and is a lock..

My thoughts too Zed- and I took the punt based on an expected $60k increase for swallow this weekend, vs keeping suckling and losing the opportunity to add swallow at basement price.

[Rik E Boy]

OUT: Luke Hodge & Eric MacKenzie
IN: James Frawley and David Swallow

Hopefully strengthen a weak backline that i have and gives me a chance to make a play for a premium forward next week,

Frawley turns it over a lot. Not sure why you picked Hodgey and Mack in the first place.

regards,

REB

[Rik E Boy]

I'm also not sure, Groover, that you can class a bloke that has never averaged more than 90, a keeper.

Even if I had of kept him in my side, he may have turned into an upgrade down the track. Swallow if he keeps his average up could turn into that keeper, at a cost of an extra $60k.

Risk v Reward.

i dont think suckling is a keeper either just a cash cow but thats the beauty of this game..its opinions versus opinions..swallow will average more imo..hes top quality and is a lock..

It depends on how well the Defender premos go if Suckling is a keeper or not. One thing he is not though is a Cash Cow as he's too expensive. If you pick Suckling you are hoping for 70-100 a week from him. More expensive options such as Heath Shaw and McVeigh are struggling to bring in the same numbers. If Premos score well you might think of moving Suckling on. In the meantime, he's not that far behind McVeigh in terms of scoring but way ahead in points per dollar.

I'm sticking with Suckling for now as I can cop 70 a week from a bloke of his price. Naturally though I'll get jack of that if he doesn't improve his rating in the next few weeks.

regards,

REB

[Rik E Boy]

Fyfe Rohan out Zorko & D Buckley in

Rohan is bollocks this is true but he can still make you a small amount of money. Buckley isn't a bubble boy yet so why not give Rohan an extra week, collect the small cash increase and then go for Buckley.

Would love to get rid of Rohan but Michie had to go from my team.

regards,

REB

[zedman]

I'm also not sure, Groover, that you can class a bloke that has never averaged more than 90, a keeper.

Even if I had of kept him in my side, he may have turned into an upgrade down the track. Swallow if he keeps his average up could turn into that keeper, at a cost of an extra $60k.

Risk v Reward.

i dont think suckling is a keeper either just a cash cow but thats the beauty of this game..its opinions versus opinions..swallow will average more imo..hes top quality and is a lock..

It depends on how well the Defender premos go if Suckling is a keeper or not. One thing he is not though is a Cash Cow as he's too expensive. If you pick Suckling you are hoping for 70-100 a week from him. More expensive options such as Heath Shaw and McVeigh are struggling to bring in the same numbers. If Premos score well you might think of moving Suckling on. In the meantime, he's not that far behind McVeigh in terms of scoring but way ahead in points per dollar.

I'm sticking with Suckling for now as I can cop 70 a week from a bloke of his price. Naturally though I'll get jack of that if he doesn't improve his rating in the next few weeks.

regards,

REB

fair call..hes not your fat cash cow, i probably used the wrong terminology there, but i cant see him being a D4, 5 or 6 either..he will be a leg up perhaps to a $500k + premo punching out 100+ scores..

[David Brent]

Fyfe Rohan out Zorko & D Buckley in

Rohan is bollocks this is true but he can still make you a small amount of money. Buckley isn't a bubble boy yet so why not give Rohan an extra week, collect the small cash increase and then go for Buckley.

Would love to get rid of Rohan but Michie had to go from my team.

regards,

REB

These were my AFL Fantasy trades so Buckley is on the bubble in that as it changes after 2 games (about only thing I like about the AFL new site). Supercoach ill leave un changed for now 30 trades still in the bank. Michie on my bench a worry like you.